Authentication integrity protection

ABSTRACT

Systems, methods, and processor-readable media are disclosed to adaptively secure access operations with respect to electronic resources. A request from an endpoint device may be detected, and adaptive authentication may be initiated. Identifiers for the endpoint device may be generated or retrieved. An access-right indicator may be identified to facilitate determination of whether particularized access for electronic resources is to be granted. Initiation of access events by the endpoint device may be detected. Sensor-based data that is based on a first set of sensors capturing phenomena at the endpoint device may be received. A particularized specification of recognized patterns mapped to the access-right indicator may be adaptively developed. A nonconformance of additional data with respect to the particularized specification may be detected. Responsive to the nonconformance, an activation adjustment in sensor operation may be selectively caused, and subsequent sensor-based data may be collected based on the activation adjustment.

CROSS-REFERENCES TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation of, and incorporates by referenceherein, U.S. application Ser. No. 15/991,926, filed on May 29, 2018, andentitled “AUTHENTICATION INTEGRITY PROTECTION,” which is acontinuation-in-part of U.S. application Ser. No. 14/256,857, filed onApr. 18, 2014, and entitled “ACADEMIC INTEGRITY PROTECTION,” whichclaims benefit to U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/813,958, filed onApr. 19, 2013, and entitled “ACADEMIC INTEGRITY PROTECTION.”

BACKGROUND

Disclosed embodiments of the present disclosure relate generally toauthentication, and in particular to systems, methods, andprocessor-readable media for authentication integrity protection.

Maintaining authentication integrity is paramount to fully securingaccess to computer systems. As use, access, and demand corresponding tocomputer systems continue to increase, circumvention of authenticationmeasures continues to develop and to become more of a concern.Traditional means of authentication has been limited, failing to addressvarious types of circumvention. Thus, there is a need for improvementsin systems, methods, and processor-readable media that address theforegoing problems. This and other needs are addressed by the presentdisclosure.

BRIEF SUMMARY

Disclosed embodiments of the present disclosure relate generally toauthentication, and in particular to systems, methods, andprocessor-readable media for authentication integrity protection.

In one aspect, an adaptive authentication system to adaptively secure aset of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources is disclosed. The adaptive authentication system may includeone or more adaptive processing devices and one or more non-transitory,computer-readable storage media storing instructions which, whenexecuted by the one or more adaptive processing devices, cause the oneor more adaptive processing devices to perform actions disclosed herein.The actions may include detecting a request received via an endpointdevice, and initiating adaptive authentication with respect to theendpoint device. For example, the adaptive authentication one or acombination of the following. Responsive to the request, one or moreidentifiers for the endpoint device may be generated or retrieved. Theone or more identifiers may uniquely correspond to the endpoint deviceamongst a set of endpoint devices. An access-right indicator may beidentified, the access-right indicator configured to facilitatedetermination of whether particularized access for electronic resourcesis to be granted. Initiation of a set of one or more access events bythe endpoint device may be detected. Sensor-based data that is based atleast in part on a first set of one or more sensors at the endpointdevice capturing phenomena at the endpoint device may be received, wherethe first set of one or more sensors is communicatively connected to theone or more adaptive processing devices. A particularized specificationof one or more recognized patterns mapped to the access-right indicatormay be adaptively developed based at least in part on processing thesensor-based data, the particularized specification of the one or morerecognized patterns including one or more recognized patterns of sensorinput. Additional data, which is one or more of based at least in parton the first set of one or more sensors, based at least in part on asecond set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device, and/or basedat least in part on input via an input interface of the endpoint device,may be received. A nonconformance of the additional data with respect tothe particularized specification of the one or more recognized patternsmapped to the access-right indicator may be detected. Responsive to thedetection of the nonconformance, an activation adjustment in operationof one or both of the first set of one or more sensors and the secondset of one or more sensors may be selectively caused, and subsequentsensor-based data may be collected based at least in part on theactivation adjustment of one or both of the first set of one or moresensors and the second set of one or more sensors.

In another aspect, one or more non-transitory, processor-readable mediaare disclosed as having processor-readable instructions thereon which,when executed by one or more processing devices, cause the one or moreprocessing devices to facilitate adaptively securing a set of accessoperations with respect to one or more electronic resources byperforming actions disclosed herein. The actions may include detecting arequest received via an endpoint device, and initiating adaptiveauthentication with respect to the endpoint device. For example, theadaptive authentication one or a combination of the following.Responsive to the request, one or more identifiers for the endpointdevice may be generated or retrieved. The one or more identifiers mayuniquely correspond to the endpoint device amongst a set of endpointdevices. An access-right indicator may be identified, the access-rightindicator configured to facilitate determination of whetherparticularized access for electronic resources is to be granted.Initiation of a set of one or more access events by the endpoint devicemay be detected. Sensor-based data that is based at least in part on afirst set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device capturingphenomena at the endpoint device may be received, where the first set ofone or more sensors is communicatively connected to the one or moreadaptive processing devices. A particularized specification of one ormore recognized patterns mapped to the access-right indicator may beadaptively developed based at least in part on processing thesensor-based data, the particularized specification of the one or morerecognized patterns including one or more recognized patterns of sensorinput. Additional data, which is one or more of based at least in parton the first set of one or more sensors, based at least in part on asecond set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device, and/or basedat least in part on input via an input interface of the endpoint device,may be received. A nonconformance of the additional data with respect tothe particularized specification of the one or more recognized patternsmapped to the access-right indicator may be detected. Responsive to thedetection of the nonconformance, an activation adjustment in operationof one or both of the first set of one or more sensors and the secondset of one or more sensors may be selectively caused, and subsequentsensor-based data may be collected based at least in part on theactivation adjustment of one or both of the first set of one or moresensors and the second set of one or more sensors.

In yet another aspect, a method of adaptive authentication to adaptivelysecure a set of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources is disclosed. The method may include one or a combination ofthe following. A request received via an endpoint device may bedetected, and adaptive authentication with respect to the endpointdevice may be initiated. For example, the adaptive authentication one ora combination of the following. Responsive to the request, one or moreidentifiers for the endpoint device may be generated or retrieved. Theone or more identifiers may uniquely correspond to the endpoint deviceamongst a set of endpoint devices. An access-right indicator may beidentified, the access-right indicator configured to facilitatedetermination of whether particularized access for electronic resourcesis to be granted. Initiation of a set of one or more access events bythe endpoint device may be detected. Sensor-based data that is based atleast in part on a first set of one or more sensors at the endpointdevice capturing phenomena at the endpoint device may be received, wherethe first set of one or more sensors is communicatively connected to theone or more adaptive processing devices. A particularized specificationof one or more recognized patterns mapped to the access-right indicatormay be adaptively developed based at least in part on processing thesensor-based data, the particularized specification of the one or morerecognized patterns including one or more recognized patterns of sensorinput. Additional data, which is one or more of based at least in parton the first set of one or more sensors, based at least in part on asecond set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device, and/or basedat least in part on input via an input interface of the endpoint device,may be received. A nonconformance of the additional data with respect tothe particularized specification of the one or more recognized patternsmapped to the access-right indicator may be detected. Responsive to thedetection of the nonconformance, an activation adjustment in operationof one or both of the first set of one or more sensors and the secondset of one or more sensors may be selectively caused, and subsequentsensor-based data may be collected based at least in part on theactivation adjustment of one or both of the first set of one or moresensors and the second set of one or more sensors.

In various embodiments, the systems, methods, and processor-readablemedia disclosed herein may further include one or a combination of thefollowing. In disclosed embodiments, consequent to the request receivedvia the endpoint device, activation of the first set of one or moresensors at the endpoint device may be caused. In disclosed embodiments,performance of at least part of the set of one or more access events maybe selectively permitted based at least in part on processing thesubsequent sensor-based data and matching one or more derived valuescorresponding to the subsequent sensor-based data to one or more storedvalues mapped to the access-right indicator.

In disclosed embodiments, after the selectively permitting performance,subsequently detected data may be received that is one or more of basedat least in part on the first set of one or more sensors, based at leastin part on the second set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device,based at least in part on a third set of one or more sensors at theendpoint device, and/or based at least in part on additional input viathe input interface of the endpoint device. A subsequent nonconformanceof the subsequently detected data with respect to the particularizedspecification of the one or more recognized patterns mapped to theaccess-right indicator may be detected. Responsive to the detection ofthe subsequent nonconformance, a subsequent activation adjustment inoperation of one or more of the first set of one or more sensors, thesecond set of one or more sensors, and/or the second set of one or moresensors may be selectively caused. Further access may be selectivelyprohibited based at least in part on the subsequent activationadjustment.

In disclosed embodiments, performance of at least part of the set of oneor more access events may be selectively prohibited based at least inpart on processing the subsequent sensor-based data and detecting amismatch of one or more derived values corresponding to the subsequentsensor-based data to one or more stored values mapped to theaccess-right indicator. In disclosed embodiments, the subsequentsensor-based data may be stored in association with the one or moreidentifiers for the endpoint device. A communication to a secondendpoint device to facilitate authenticated access to the subsequentsensor-based data consequent to authentication of the second endpointdevice by the one or more adaptive processing devices. In disclosedembodiments, the particularized specification of the one or morerecognized patterns of the sensor input mapped to the access-rightindicator may include a set of values corresponding to anticipatedsensor input. The subsequent sensor-based data may be processed, and oneor more derived values corresponding to the subsequent sensor-based datamay be compared to the set of values.

In still another aspect, an adaptive authentication system to adaptivelysecure a set of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources is disclosed as including one or a combination of thefollowing. The adaptive authentication system may include one or moreadaptive processing devices and one or more non-transitory,computer-readable storage media storing instructions which, whenexecuted by the one or more adaptive processing devices, cause the oneor more adaptive processing devices to perform actions disclosed herein.For example, a request received via an endpoint device may be detected,and, responsive to the request, an access-right indicator may beidentified that is configured to facilitate determination of whetherparticularized access for electronic resources is to be granted. One ormore identifiers for the endpoint device may be generated or retrieved,the one or more identifiers uniquely corresponding to the endpointdevice amongst a set of endpoint devices. Initiation of a set of one ormore access events initiated by the endpoint device may be detected.Sensor-based data may be received that is based at least in part on afirst set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device capturingphenomena at the endpoint device, where the first set of one or moresensors is communicatively connected to the one or more adaptiveprocessing devices. Additional data may be received that is one or moreof based at least in part on the first set of one or more sensors, basedat least in part on a second set of one or more sensors at the endpointdevice, and/or based at least in part on input via an input interface ofthe endpoint device. A set of one or more authentication rules specifiedby a protocol record may be accessed, the set of one or moreauthentication rules including criteria for endpoint authentication. Aparticularized specification of one or more recognized patterns mappedto the access-right indicator may be adaptively developed based at leastin part on processing the additional data. An endpoint qualificationthat is based at least in part on the particularized specification ofone or more recognized patterns and the criteria for endpointauthentication may be generated. An activation adjustment in operationof one or more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second setof one or more sensors, a third set of one or more sensors, and/or acommunication interface may be selected. A command to cause theactivation adjustment may be transferred.

In still another aspect, one or more non-transitory, processor-readablemedia are disclosed as having processor-readable instructions thereonwhich, when executed by one or more processing devices, cause the one ormore processing devices to facilitate adaptively securing a set ofaccess operations with respect to one or more electronic resources byperforming actions disclosed herein. The actions may include one or acombination of the following. example, a request received via anendpoint device may be detected, and, responsive to the request, anaccess-right indicator may be identified that is configured tofacilitate determination of whether particularized access for electronicresources is to be granted. One or more identifiers for the endpointdevice may be generated or retrieved, the one or more identifiersuniquely corresponding to the endpoint device amongst a set of endpointdevices. Initiation of a set of one or more access events initiated bythe endpoint device may be detected.

Sensor-based data may be received that is based at least in part on afirst set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device capturingphenomena at the endpoint device, where the first set of one or moresensors is communicatively connected to the one or more adaptiveprocessing devices. Additional data may be received that is one or moreof based at least in part on the first set of one or more sensors, basedat least in part on a second set of one or more sensors at the endpointdevice, and/or based at least in part on input via an input interface ofthe endpoint device. A set of one or more authentication rules specifiedby a protocol record may be accessed, the set of one or moreauthentication rules including criteria for endpoint authentication. Aparticularized specification of one or more recognized patterns mappedto the access-right indicator may be adaptively developed based at leastin part on processing the additional data. An endpoint qualificationthat is based at least in part on the particularized specification ofone or more recognized patterns and the criteria for endpointauthentication may be generated. An activation adjustment in operationof one or more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second setof one or more sensors, a third set of one or more sensors, and/or acommunication interface may be selected. A command to cause theactivation adjustment may be transferred.

In a further aspect, a method of adaptive authentication to adaptivelysecure a set of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources is disclosed as including one or a combination of thefollowing. A request received via an endpoint device may be detected,and, responsive to the request, an access-right indicator may beidentified that is configured to facilitate determination of whetherparticularized access for electronic resources is to be granted. One ormore identifiers for the endpoint device may be generated or retrieved,the one or more identifiers uniquely corresponding to the endpointdevice amongst a set of endpoint devices. Initiation of a set of one ormore access events initiated by the endpoint device may be detected.Sensor-based data may be received that is based at least in part on afirst set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device capturingphenomena at the endpoint device, where the first set of one or moresensors is communicatively connected to the one or more adaptiveprocessing devices. Additional data may be received that is one or moreof based at least in part on the first set of one or more sensors, basedat least in part on a second set of one or more sensors at the endpointdevice, and/or based at least in part on input via an input interface ofthe endpoint device. A set of one or more authentication rules specifiedby a protocol record may be accessed, the set of one or moreauthentication rules including criteria for endpoint authentication. Aparticularized specification of one or more recognized patterns mappedto the access-right indicator may be adaptively developed based at leastin part on processing the additional data. An endpoint qualificationthat is based at least in part on the particularized specification ofone or more recognized patterns and the criteria for endpointauthentication may be generated. An activation adjustment in operationof one or more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second setof one or more sensors, a third set of one or more sensors, and/or acommunication interface may be selected. A command to cause theactivation adjustment may be transferred.

In various embodiments, the systems, methods, and processor-readablemedia disclosed herein may further include one or a combination of thefollowing. In disclosed embodiments, performance of at least part of theset of one or more access events may be selectively permitted orprohibited based at least in part on processing subsequent sensor-baseddata consequent to the activation adjustment. In disclosed embodiments,the endpoint qualification may include an authentication score that ismapped to a characterization corresponding to the endpoint device. Indisclosed embodiments, the first set of one or more sensors maycorrespond to a first sensor type, and the second set of one or moresensors may correspond to a second sensor type that is different fromthe first sensor type. In disclosed embodiments, the third set of one ormore sensors may correspond to a third sensor type that is differentfrom the first sensor type and the second sensor type. In disclosedembodiments, the one or more recognized patterns mapped to theaccess-right indicator may correspond to one or more of anidentification pattern, an action pattern, a location pattern, and/or atemporal pattern. In disclosed embodiments, the criteria for endpointauthentication may specify a first weight accorded to a first type ofsensor-based data generated based at least in part on the first set ofone or more sensors, and a second weight accorded to a second type ofsensor-based data generated based at least in part on the second set ofone or more sensors.

In a further aspect, an adaptive authentication system to adaptivelysecure a set of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources is disclosed as including one or a combination of thefollowing. The adaptive authentication system may include one or moreadaptive processing devices and one or more non-transitory,computer-readable storage media storing instructions which, whenexecuted by the one or more adaptive processing devices, cause the oneor more adaptive processing devices to perform actions disclosed herein.The action may include one or a combination of the following. Initiationof a set of one or more access events initiated by the endpoint devicemay be detected. Adaptive authentication with respect to the endpointdevice may be caused and may include one or a combination of thefollowing. A stage of authentication of the endpoint device may beinitiated. The stage of authentication may include activation of one orboth of a first set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device and asecond set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device to capturephenomena at the endpoint device. One or both of the first set of one ormore sensors and the second set of one or more sensors may becommunicatively connected to the one or more adaptive processingdevices. The first set of one or more sensors may correspond to a firstsensor type. The second set of one or more sensors may correspond to asecond sensor type that is different from the first sensor type.Sensor-based data may be received that is based at least in part on oneor both the first set of one or more sensors and/or the second set ofone or more sensors first set of one or more sensors activated with thefirst stage of authentication. Additional sensor-based data detected atthe endpoint device may be received. A deviation of at least part of theadditional data with respect to the sensor-based data previouslyreceived may be detected. An authentication score with respect to theendpoint device may be generated that is based at least in part on theadditional sensor-based data and the sensor-based data previouslyreceived. One or more additional stages of authentication of theendpoint device may be initiated at least in part by transferring acommand to cause an activation adjustment that is a function of theauthentication score, where the activation adjustment adjusts operationof one or more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second setof one or more sensors, and/or a third set of one or more sensors.Consequent to the one or more additional stages of authentication,further sensor-based data detected at the endpoint device may bereceived, and access of the endpoint device to resources may becontrolled based at least in part on the further sensor-based data.

In yet a further aspect, one or more non-transitory, processor-readablemedia are disclosed as having processor-readable instructions thereonwhich, when executed by one or more processing devices, cause the one ormore processing devices to facilitate adaptively securing a set ofaccess operations with respect to one or more electronic resources byperforming actions disclosed herein. The actions may include one or acombination of the following. For example, initiation of a set of one ormore access events initiated by the endpoint device may be detected.Adaptive authentication with respect to the endpoint device may becaused and may include one or a combination of the following. A stage ofauthentication of the endpoint device may be initiated. The stage ofauthentication may include activation of one or both of a first set ofone or more sensors at the endpoint device and a second set of one ormore sensors at the endpoint device to capture phenomena at the endpointdevice. One or both of the first set of one or more sensors and thesecond set of one or more sensors may be communicatively connected tothe one or more adaptive processing devices. The first set of one ormore sensors may correspond to a first sensor type. The second set ofone or more sensors may correspond to a second sensor type that isdifferent from the first sensor type. Sensor-based data may be receivedthat is based at least in part on one or both the first set of one ormore sensors and/or the second set of one or more sensors first set ofone or more sensors activated with the first stage of authentication.Additional sensor-based data detected at the endpoint device may bereceived. A deviation of at least part of the additional data withrespect to the sensor-based data previously received may be detected. Anauthentication score with respect to the endpoint device may begenerated that is based at least in part on the additional sensor-baseddata and the sensor-based data previously received. One or moreadditional stages of authentication of the endpoint device may beinitiated at least in part by transferring a command to cause anactivation adjustment that is a function of the authentication score,where the activation adjustment adjusts operation of one or more of thefirst set of one or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors,and/or a third set of one or more sensors. Consequent to the one or moreadditional stages of authentication, further sensor-based data detectedat the endpoint device may be received, and access of the endpointdevice to resources may be controlled based at least in part on thefurther sensor-based data.

In still a further aspect, a method of adaptive authentication toadaptively secure a set of access operations with respect to one or moreelectronic resources is disclosed as including one or a combination ofthe following. For example, initiation of a set of one or more accessevents initiated by the endpoint device may be detected. Adaptiveauthentication with respect to the endpoint device may be caused and mayinclude one or a combination of the following. A stage of authenticationof the endpoint device may be initiated. The stage of authentication mayinclude activation of one or both of a first set of one or more sensorsat the endpoint device and a second set of one or more sensors at theendpoint device to capture phenomena at the endpoint device. One or bothof the first set of one or more sensors and the second set of one ormore sensors may be communicatively connected to the one or moreadaptive processing devices. The first set of one or more sensors maycorrespond to a first sensor type. The second set of one or more sensorsmay correspond to a second sensor type that is different from the firstsensor type. Sensor-based data may be received that is based at least inpart on one or both the first set of one or more sensors and/or thesecond set of one or more sensors first set of one or more sensorsactivated with the first stage of authentication. Additionalsensor-based data detected at the endpoint device may be received. Adeviation of at least part of the additional data with respect to thesensor-based data previously received may be detected. An authenticationscore with respect to the endpoint device may be generated that is basedat least in part on the additional sensor-based data and thesensor-based data previously received. One or more additional stages ofauthentication of the endpoint device may be initiated at least in partby transferring a command to cause an activation adjustment that is afunction of the authentication score, where the activation adjustmentadjusts operation of one or more of the first set of one or moresensors, the second set of one or more sensors, and/or a third set ofone or more sensors. Consequent to the one or more additional stages ofauthentication, further sensor-based data detected at the endpointdevice may be received, and access of the endpoint device to resourcesmay be controlled based at least in part on the further sensor-baseddata.

In various embodiments, the systems, methods, and processor-readablemedia disclosed herein may further include one or a combination of thefollowing. In disclosed embodiments, a mode of sensor operation for oneor more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second set of oneor more sensors, and/or a third set of one or more sensors may beselected, where the mode of sensor operation is a function of theauthentication score. The activation adjustment may include causing oneor more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second set of oneor more sensors, and/or a third set of one or more sensors to operate inaccordance with the mode of sensor operation.

In disclosed embodiments, an updated authentication score with respectto the endpoint device may be generated that is based at least in parton the further sensor-based data. A subsequent mode of sensor operationfor one or more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second setof one or more sensors, and/or the third set of one or more sensors maybe selected, where the subsequent mode of sensor operation is a functionof the updated authentication score and is different from the mode ofsensor operation. A subsequent command may be transferred to cause asubsequent activation adjustment so that one or more of the first set ofone or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors, and/or athird set of one or more sensors to operate in accordance with thesecond mode of sensor operation.

In disclosed embodiments, one or more of the first set of one or moresensors, the second set of one or more sensors, and/or a third set ofone or more sensors for operation according to the activation adjustmentmay be selected, where the selecting is based at least in part on theauthentication score. In disclosed embodiments, the selecting one ormore of the first set of one or more sensors, the second set of one ormore sensors, and/or a third set of one or more sensors for operationaccording to the activation adjustment may be further based at least inpart on a precedence order. In disclosed embodiments, an updatedauthentication score with respect to the endpoint device may begenerated that is based at least in part on the further sensor-baseddata. The controlling access of the endpoint device to resources may bea function of the of the updated authentication score. In disclosedembodiments, the controlling access of the endpoint device to resourcesas a function of the of the updated authentication score may includeselectively permitting or prohibiting performance of at least part ofthe set of one or more access events.

With one aspect, an adaptive authentication system to adaptively securea set of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources is disclosed as including one or a combination of thefollowing. The adaptive authentication system may include one or moreadaptive processing devices and one or more non-transitory,computer-readable storage media storing instructions which, whenexecuted by the one or more adaptive processing devices, cause the oneor more adaptive processing devices to perform actions disclosed hereinthat may include one or a combination of the following. For example, aplurality of endpoint subsystems communicatively coupled to the one ormore adaptive processing devices may be detected. A request received viaan endpoint device of an endpoint subsystem of the plurality of endpointsubsystems may be detected. Adaptive authentication with respect to theendpoint device may be initiated. The adaptive authentication mayinclude one or a combination of the following. A first stage ofauthentication of the endpoint device may be initiated. The first stageof authentication may include activation one or both of a first set ofone or more sensors at the endpoint device and a second set of one ormore sensors at the endpoint device to capture phenomena at the endpointdevice. The endpoint device being colocated with at least one otherendpoint device of the plurality of endpoint subsystems may be detected.A second stage of authentication of the endpoint device may beinitiated. Additional sensor-based data detected at the endpoint deviceconsequent to the second stage of authentication may be received. Basedat least in part on the additional sensor-based data detected at theendpoint device consequent to the second stage of authentication, athird stage of authentication of a set of colocated endpoint devices maybe initiated. The set of colocated endpoint devices may include theendpoint device and the at least one other endpoint device of theplurality of endpoint subsystems. Access of the set of colocatedendpoint devices to resources may be controlled based at least in parton further sensor-based data received consequent to the third stage ofauthentication.

With another aspect, one or more non-transitory, processor-readablemedia are disclosed as having processor-readable instructions thereonwhich, when executed by one or more processing devices, cause the one ormore processing devices to facilitate adaptively securing a set ofaccess operations with respect to one or more electronic resources byperforming actions disclosed herein. The actions may include one or acombination of the following. For example, a plurality of endpointsubsystems communicatively coupled to the one or more adaptiveprocessing devices may be detected. A request received via an endpointdevice of an endpoint subsystem of the plurality of endpoint subsystemsmay be detected. Adaptive authentication with respect to the endpointdevice may be initiated. The adaptive authentication may include one ora combination of the following. A first stage of authentication of theendpoint device may be initiated. The first stage of authentication mayinclude activation one or both of a first set of one or more sensors atthe endpoint device and a second set of one or more sensors at theendpoint device to capture phenomena at the endpoint device. Theendpoint device being colocated with at least one other endpoint deviceof the plurality of endpoint subsystems may be detected. A second stageof authentication of the endpoint device may be initiated. Additionalsensor-based data detected at the endpoint device consequent to thesecond stage of authentication may be received. Based at least in parton the additional sensor-based data detected at the endpoint deviceconsequent to the second stage of authentication, a third stage ofauthentication of a set of colocated endpoint devices may be initiated.The set of colocated endpoint devices may include the endpoint deviceand the at least one other endpoint device of the plurality of endpointsubsystems. Access of the set of colocated endpoint devices to resourcesmay be controlled based at least in part on further sensor-based datareceived consequent to the third stage of authentication.

With still another aspect, a method of adaptive authentication toadaptively secure a set of access operations with respect to one or moreelectronic resources is disclosed as including one or a combination ofthe following. For example, a plurality of endpoint subsystemscommunicatively coupled to the one or more adaptive processing devicesmay be detected. A request received via an endpoint device of anendpoint subsystem of the plurality of endpoint subsystems may bedetected. Adaptive authentication with respect to the endpoint devicemay be initiated. The adaptive authentication may include one or acombination of the following. A first stage of authentication of theendpoint device may be initiated. The first stage of authentication mayinclude activation one or both of a first set of one or more sensors atthe endpoint device and a second set of one or more sensors at theendpoint device to capture phenomena at the endpoint device. Theendpoint device being colocated with at least one other endpoint deviceof the plurality of endpoint subsystems may be detected. A second stageof authentication of the endpoint device may be initiated. Additionalsensor-based data detected at the endpoint device consequent to thesecond stage of authentication may be received. Based at least in parton the additional sensor-based data detected at the endpoint deviceconsequent to the second stage of authentication, a third stage ofauthentication of a set of colocated endpoint devices may be initiated.The set of colocated endpoint devices may include the endpoint deviceand the at least one other endpoint device of the plurality of endpointsubsystems. Access of the set of colocated endpoint devices to resourcesmay be controlled based at least in part on further sensor-based datareceived consequent to the third stage of authentication.

In various embodiments, the systems, methods, and processor-readablemedia disclosed herein may further include one or a combination of thefollowing. In disclosed embodiments, the adaptive authentication mayfurther include detecting a deviation of at least part of the additionaldata with respect to the sensor-based data previously received for theendpoint device. The third stage of authentication of the set ofcolocated endpoint devices may be initiated responsive to the detecting.

In disclosed embodiments, the adaptive authentication may furtherinclude, based at least in part on the additional sensor-based datadetected at the endpoint device consequent to the second stage ofauthentication, detecting a coincidental action attribute, acoincidental temporal attribute, and/or a coincidental contextualattribute correlated to each endpoint device at least a subset of theset of colocated endpoint devices. The third stage of authentication ofthe set of colocated endpoint devices may be initiated responsive to thedetecting. In disclosed embodiments, the detecting may be performedafter determining that there is no a deviation of at least part of theadditional data with respect to the sensor-based data previouslyreceived for the endpoint device that satisfies a threshold.

In disclosed embodiments, the third stage of authentication may includetransferring commands to each subsystem corresponding to the set ofcolocated endpoint devices to cause activation adjustments of one ormore sensors at each of the set of colocated endpoint devices. Indisclosed embodiments, the activation may include a plurality ofdifferent activation adjustments. In disclosed embodiments, whetherreceived requests from each endpoint device of the plurality of endpointsubsystems satisfy a threshold of temporal proximity may be determined,and the third stage of authentication may be initiated, and access maybe controlled, only with respect to those endpoint devices sending arequest that satisfies the threshold of temporal proximity.

Further areas of applicability of the present disclosure will becomeapparent from the detailed description provided hereinafter. It shouldbe understood that the detailed description and specific examples, whileindicating various embodiments, are intended for purposes ofillustration only and are not intended to necessarily limit the scope ofthe disclosure.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 is a block diagram illustrating an example of a content accessnetwork, in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 2 is a block diagram illustrating a computer server and computingenvironment within a content access network, in accordance withembodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 2A is a block diagram illustrating an example of an endpointdevice, in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 3 is a block diagram illustrating an example of one or more datastorage servers within a content access network, in accordance withembodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 4 is a block diagram illustrating an example of one or more contentmanagement servers within a content access network, in accordance withembodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 5 is a block diagram illustrating the physical and logicalcomponents of a special-purpose computer device within a content accessnetwork, in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 6 is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of thecommunication network, in accordance with embodiments of the presentdisclosure.

FIG. 7 is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of endpoint deviceand administrator device communication, in accordance with embodimentsof the present disclosure.

FIG. 8 is a schematic illustration of one embodiment of a computingstack, in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 9 is a schematic illustration of one embodiment of communicationand processing flow of modules within the content access network, inaccordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 10 is a schematic illustration of one embodiment of communicationand processing flow of modules within the content access network, inaccordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 11 is a schematic illustration of one embodiment of communicationand processing flow of modules within the content access network, inaccordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 12 is a schematic illustration of one embodiment of communicationand processing flow of modules within the content access network, inaccordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 13 is a flowchart illustrating one embodiment of a process for datamanagement, in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 14 is a flowchart illustrating one embodiment of a process forevaluating a response, in accordance with embodiments of the presentdisclosure.

FIG. 15 illustrates a subsystem to facilitate adaptively securing a setof access operations with respect to one or more electronic resources,in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 15A illustrates certain aspects of adaptive data processing andcontrol flow, in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 15B depicts certain aspects of a method to adaptively secure a setof access operations with respect to one or more electronic resourcesvia authentication control based at least in part on individualizedauthentication protocol, in accordance with embodiments of the presentdisclosure.

FIG. 16 depicts certain aspects of a method for protection ofauthentication integrity, in accordance with embodiments of the presentdisclosure.

FIG. 17 depicts certain aspects of a method for authenticating anendpoint, in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 18 depicts certain aspects of a method for authentication integrityprotection with image batches, in accordance with embodiments of thepresent disclosure.

FIG. 19 depicts certain aspects of a method to adaptively secure a setof access operations with respect to one or more electronic resources,in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 20 depicts certain aspects of first-stage authentication, inaccordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 21 depicts certain aspects of additional machine-intelligentauthentication, in accordance with embodiments of the presentdisclosure.

FIG. 22 depicts certain aspects of a method to adaptively secure a setof access operations with respect to electronic resources and withrespect to multiple endpoint subsystems, in accordance with embodimentsof the present disclosure.

In the appended figures, similar components and/or features may have thesame reference label. Further, various components of the same type maybe distinguished by following the reference label by a dash and a secondlabel that distinguishes among the similar components. If only the firstreference label is used in the specification, the description isapplicable to any one of the similar components having the same firstreference label irrespective of the second reference label.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

The ensuing description provides illustrative embodiment(s) only and isnot intended to limit the scope, applicability, or configuration of thedisclosure. Rather, the ensuing description of the illustrativeembodiment(s) will provide those skilled in the art with an enablingdescription for implementing a preferred exemplary embodiment. It isunderstood that various changes can be made in the function andarrangement of elements without departing from the spirit and scope asset forth in the appended claims.

With reference now to FIG. 1, a block diagram is shown illustratingvarious components of a content access network 100 which implements andsupports certain embodiments and features described herein. The contentaccess network 100 may correspond to, and may be variously referencedherein as, an adaptive authentication system 100. In some embodiments,the content access network 100 can comprise one or several physicalcomponents and/or one or several virtual components such as, forexample, one or several cloud computing components. In some embodiments,the content access network 100 can comprise a mixture of physical andcloud computing components.

Content access network 100 may include one or more content managementservers 102. As discussed below in more detail, content managementservers 102 may be any correct type of server including, for example, arack server, a tower server, a miniature server, a blade server, a minirack server, a mobile server, an ultra-dense server, a super server, orthe like, and may include various hardware components, for example, amotherboard, a processing unit, memory systems, hard drives, networkinterfaces, power supplies, etc. Content management server 102 mayinclude one or more server farms, clusters, or any other appropriatearrangement and/or combination or computer servers. Content managementserver 102 may act according to stored instructions located in a memorysubsystem of the server 102, and may run an operating system, includingany commercially available server operating system and/or any otheroperating systems discussed herein.

The content access network 100 may include one or more data storageservers 104, such as data storage servers and file-based storagesystems. The data storage servers 104 can access data that can be storedon a variety of hardware components. These hardware components caninclude, for example, components forming tier 0 storage, componentsforming tier 1 storage, components forming tier 2 storage, and/or anyother tier of storage. In some embodiments, tier 0 storage refers tostorage that is the fastest tier of storage in the data storage server104, and particularly, the tier 0 storage is the fastest storage that isnot RAM or cache memory. In some embodiments, the tier 0 memory can beembodied in solid state memory such as, for example, a solid-state drive(SSD) and/or flash memory.

In some embodiments, the tier 1 storage refers to storage that is one orseveral higher performing systems in the memory management system, andthat is relatively slower than tier 0 memory, and relatively faster thanother tiers of memory. The tier 1 memory can be one or several harddisks that can be, for example, high-performance hard disks. These harddisks can be one or both of physically or communicatively connected suchas, for example, by one or several fiber channels. In some embodiments,the one or several disks can be arranged into a disk storage system, andspecifically can be arranged into an enterprise class disk storagesystem. The disk storage system can include any correct level ofredundancy to protect data stored therein, and in one embodiment, thedisk storage system can be made with grid architecture that createsparallelism for uniform allocation of system resources and balanced datadistribution.

In some embodiments, the tier 2 storage refers to storage that includesone or several relatively lower performing systems in the memorymanagement system, as compared to the tier 1 and tier 2 storages. Thus,tier 2 memory is relatively slower than tier 1 and tier 0 memories. Tier2 memory can include one or several SATA-drives (e.g., Serial ATAttachment drives) or one or several NL-SATA drives.

In some embodiments, the one or several hardware and/or softwarecomponents of the data storage server 104 can be arranged into one orseveral storage area networks (SAN), which one or several storage areanetworks can be one or several dedicated networks that provide access todata storage, and particularly that provides access to consolidated,block level data storage. A SAN typically has its own network of storagedevices that are generally not accessible through the local area network(LAN) by other devices. The SAN allows access to these devices in amanner such that these devices appear to be locally attached to theendpoint device.

Data storages 104 may comprise stored data germane to the functions ofthe content access network 100. Illustrative examples of data storages104 that may be maintained in certain embodiments of the content accessnetwork 100 are described below in reference to FIG. 3. In someembodiments, multiple data storages may reside on a single server 104,either using the same storage components of server 104 or usingdifferent physical storage components to assure data security andintegrity between data storages. In other embodiments, each data storagemay have a separate dedicated data storage server 104.

Content access network 100 also may include one or more endpoint devices106 and/or administrator devices 110. Endpoint devices 106 andadministrator devices 110 may display content received via the contentaccess network 100, and may support various types of endpointinteractions with the content. Endpoint devices 106 and administratordevices 110 may include mobile devices such as smartphones, tabletcomputers, particular digital assistants, and wearable computingdevices. Such mobile devices may run a variety of mobile operatingsystems and may be enabled for Internet, e-mail, short message service(SMS), Bluetooth®, mobile radio-frequency identification (M-RFID),and/or other communication protocols. Other endpoint devices 106 andadministrator devices 110 may be special-purpose computing devicesincluding, by way of example, particular computers, laptop computers,workstation computers, projection devices, and interactive room displaysystems. Additionally, endpoint devices 106 and administrator devices110 may be any other electronic devices, such as a thin-clientcomputers, an Internet-enabled gaming systems, business or homeappliances, and/or particular messaging devices, capable ofcommunicating over network(s) 120.

In different contexts of content access networks 100, endpoint devices106 and administrator devices 110 may correspond to different types ofspecialized devices. In some embodiments, endpoint devices 106 andadministrator devices 110 may operate in the same physical location 107.In such cases, the devices may contain components that support directcommunications with other nearby devices, such as wireless transceiversand wireless communications interfaces, Ethernet sockets or other LocalArea Network (LAN) interfaces, etc. In other implementations, theendpoint devices 106 and administrator devices 110 need not be used atthe same location 107, but may be used in remote geographic locations inwhich each endpoint device 106 and administrator device 110 may usesecurity features and/or specialized hardware (e.g.,hardware-accelerated SSL and HTTPS, WS-Security, firewalls, etc.) tocommunicate with the content management server 102 and/or other remotelylocated endpoint devices 106. Additionally, different endpoint devices106 and administrator devices 110 may be assigned different designatedparticularized sets of access permissions and, in such cases, thedifferent devices may be provided with additional hardware and/orsoftware components to provide content and support endpoint capabilitiesnot available to the other devices.

The content access network 100 also may include a privacy server 108that maintains private endpoint data at the privacy server 108 whileusing applications or functionalities hosted on other servers. Forexample, the privacy server 108 may be used to maintain private data ofan endpoint within one jurisdiction even though the endpoint isaccessing an application hosted on a server (e.g., the contentmanagement server 102) located outside the jurisdiction. In such cases,the privacy server 108 may intercept communications between an endpointdevice 106 or administrator device 110 and other devices that includeprivate endpoint data. The privacy server 108 may create a token oridentifier that does not disclose the private data and may use the tokenor identifier when communicating with the other servers and systems,instead of using the endpoint's private data.

As illustrated in FIG. 1, the content management server 102 may be incommunication with one or more additional servers, such as a contentserver 112, an endpoint data server 114, and/or an administrator server116. Each of these servers may include some or all of the same physicaland logical components as the content management server(s) 102, and insome cases, the hardware and software components of these servers112-116 may be incorporated into the content management server(s) 102,rather than being implemented as separate computer servers.

Content server 112 may include hardware and software components togenerate, store, and maintain the content resources for distribution toendpoint devices 106 and other devices in the network 100. Contentserver 112 may include data storages of materials, reviews, diagnostics,interactive programs and simulations, models, outlines, and variousinterfaces that correspond to different materials and/or different typesof endpoint devices 106. In content access networks 100 used forresource distribution, endpoint interactives, and the like, a contentserver 112 may include resource content files.

Endpoint data server 114 may include hardware and software componentsthat store and process data for multiple particularized access instancesrelating to particularized endpoint accesses of the content accessnetwork 100. For example, the content management server 102 may recordand track each endpoint's system usage, including their endpoint device106, content resources accessed, and interactions with other endpointdevices 106. This data may be stored and processed by the endpoint dataserver 114, to support endpoint tracking and analysis features. Forinstance, the endpoint data server 114 may store and analyze eachendpoint's access histories, attendances, completions, interactions,diagnostic results, and the like. The endpoint data server 114 may alsoinclude a repository for endpoint-created material, such as diagnosticsand tests completed by endpoints, and documents and assignments preparedby endpoints. In the context of resource distribution and interactivegaming, the endpoint data server 114 may store and process resourceaccess data for multiple endpoints (e.g., content titles accessed,access times, data usage amounts, interaction histories, endpointdevices and device types, etc.).

Administrator server 116 may include hardware and software components toinitiate various administrative functions at the content managementserver 102 and other components within the content access network 100.For example, the administrator server 116 may monitor device status andperformance for the various servers, data storages, and/or endpointdevices 106 in the content access network 100. When necessary, theadministrator server 116 may add or remove devices from the network 100,and perform device maintenance such as providing software updates to thedevices in the network 100. Various administrative tools on theadministrator server 116 may allow authorized endpoints to set endpointaccess permissions to various content resources, monitor resource usageby endpoints and devices 106, and perform analyses and generate reportson specific network endpoints and/or devices (e.g., resource usagetracking reports, development diagnostics, etc.).

The content access network 100 may include one or more communicationnetworks 120. Although only a single network 120 is identified in FIG.1, the content access network 100 may include any number of differentcommunication networks between any of the computer servers and devicesshown in FIG. 1 and/or other devices described herein. Communicationnetworks 120 may enable communication between the various computingdevices, servers, and other components of the content access network100. As discussed below, various implementations of content accessnetworks 100 may employ different types of networks 120, for example,computer networks, telecommunications networks, wireless networks,and/or any combination of these and/or other networks.

The content access network 100 may include one or several navigationsystems or features including, for example, the Global PositioningSystem (“GPS”), GALILEO (e.g., Europe's global positioning system), orthe like, or location systems or features including, for example, one orseveral transceivers that can determine location of the one or severalcomponents of the content access network 100 via, for example,triangulation. All of these are depicted as navigation system 122.

In some embodiments, navigation system 122 can include or severalfeatures that can communicate with one or several components of thecontent access network 100 including, for example, with one or severalof the endpoint devices 106 and/or with one or several of theadministrator devices 110. In some embodiments, this communication caninclude the transmission of a signal from the navigation system 122which signal is received by one or several components of the contentaccess network 100 and can be used to determine the location of the oneor several components of the content access network 100.

The content access network 100 may correspond to an adaptiveauthentication system 100 that corresponds to, and includes, multipletechnical improvements. The adaptive authentication system 100 maycollect and store endpoint specification data from an endpoint that isalleged to be performing an authenticated operation. This endpoint isreferred to as the provisional endpoint. The adaptive authenticationsystem 100 likewise collects authentication data for use in identifyingthe endpoint performing the authenticated operation. This endpoint maybe referred to as the actual endpoint. The adaptive authenticationsystem 100 compares the collected authentication data with the storedendpoint specification data to determine whether the actual endpointperforming the authenticated operation is the provisional endpoint. Insome embodiments, this determination can be performed at any pointduring the completion of the authenticated operation, and can be, forexample, performed continuously and/or randomly during the completion ofthe authenticated operation. In some embodiments, the adaptiveauthentication system 100 can further determine if other applicationsare open and/or running during the time of the completion of theauthenticated operation and/or determine the level of usage of otherprograms during the time of the completion of the authenticatedoperation.

In various embodiments, the present disclosure provides a method forprotection of authentication integrity. This method can include, forexample, providing an authenticated operation and receiving and/orcollecting authentication data during the actual endpoint's performanceof the authenticated operation. This received and/or collectedauthentication data can be compared to stored endpoint specificationdata for the provisional endpoint. This comparison of the storedendpoint specification data and the collected authentication data can beused to determine whether the actual endpoint is the provisionalendpoint.

In some embodiments, for example, this comparison can result in thegeneration of an authentication score that can reflect the likelihoodthat the provisional endpoint is the actual endpoint. This score can becompared to an integrity criterion, and based on the comparison of thescore to the integrity criteria, the actual endpoint can be identifiedas the provisional endpoint or as an endpoint other than the provisionalendpoint.

The collected authentication data can comprise a variety of informationrelating to the actual endpoint. In some embodiments, for example, thecollected authentication data can be one or more of an indicator of aphysical attribute of the actual endpoint, an indicator of a performanceattribute of the actual endpoint, and an indicator of an interactionattribute of the actual endpoint. In one embodiment, an indicator of aphysical attribute of the actual endpoint can include, for example, astill image, a batch of still images, video data, or biometric data.Biometric data can be anything that is likely to be unique to theendpoint, for example, keystroke patterns, mouse movement patterns,interaction patterns like common misspellings, interaction patterns withsoftware, etc. A performance attribute could include deviations fromtypical or expected grades, writing style, word choice, typing speed,etc. In some embodiments, the performance attribute can include a screencapture of the screen at an instant during the completion of theauthenticated operation. In some embodiments, this screen capture can beprovided to an administrator for review to determine if any unapprovedactivity or collaboration is indicated in the screen capture.Additionally, any provided identification such as passwordauthentication, or government-issued ID can be additional authenticationdata in one embodiment.

In some embodiments, for example, a single type of authentication datacan be collected and used to determine the identity of the actualendpoint, and in some embodiments, for example, a plurality of types ofauthentication data can be collected and used to determine the identityof the actual endpoint. In one embodiment, for example, a first type ofauthentication data is collected and a first authentication score isgenerated for the first type of authentication data, and an additionaltype of authentication data is collected and an additionalauthentication score is generated. The first authentication score andthe additional authentication score can be combined to determine anoverall authentication score for the endpoint performing theauthenticated operation, which score can then be used to determine ifthe actual endpoint is the provisional endpoint.

In some embodiments, for example, authentication data can be collectedat different points during the performance of the authenticatedoperation. Thus, in one embodiment, authentication data can becollected, for example, at a plurality of points during the performanceof the authenticated operation such as, for example, at the beginning ofthe authenticated operation, at the end of the authenticated operation,or at one or several intermediate points during the authenticatedoperation. In some embodiments, the collection of authentication data atdifferent points during the performance of the authenticated operationcan be used to provide further verification that the actual endpoint isthe provisional endpoint.

With reference to FIG. 2, an illustrative distributed computingenvironment 200 is shown including a computer server 202, four clientcomputing devices 206, and other components that may implement certainembodiments and features described herein. In some embodiments, theserver 202 may correspond to the content management server 102 discussedabove in FIG. 1, and the client computing devices 206 may correspond tothe endpoint devices 106 and devices 110. However, the computingenvironment 200 illustrated in FIG. 2 may correspond to any othercombination of devices and servers configured to implement aclient-server model or other distributed computing architecture.

Client devices 206 may be configured to receive and execute clientapplications over one or more networks 220. Such client applications maybe web browser based applications and/or standalone softwareapplications, such as mobile device applications. Server 202 may becommunicatively coupled with the client devices 206 via one or morecommunication networks 220. Client devices 206 may receive clientapplications from server 202 or from other application providers (e.g.,public or private application stores). Server 202 may be configured torun one or more server software applications or functionalities, forexample, web-based or cloud-based, to support resource access andinteraction with client devices 206. Endpoints operating client devices206 may in turn utilize one or more client applications (e.g., virtualclient applications) to interact with server 202 to utilize thefunctionalities provided by these components.

Various different subsystems and/or components 204 may be implemented onserver 202. Endpoints operating the client devices 206 may initiate oneor more client applications to use functionalities provided by thesesubsystems and components. The subsystems and components within theserver 202 and client devices 206 may be implemented in hardware,firmware, software, or combinations thereof. Various different systemconfigurations are possible in different distributed computing systems200 and content access networks 100. The embodiment shown in FIG. 2 isthus one example of a distributed computing system and is not intendedto be limiting. Although exemplary computing environment 200 is shownwith four client computing devices 206, any number of client computingdevices may be supported. Other devices, such as specialized sensordevices, etc., may interact with client devices 206 and/or server 202.

As shown in FIG. 2, various security and integration components 208 maybe used to send and manage communications between the server 202 andendpoint devices 206 over one or more communication networks 220. Inembodiments disclosed herein, the endpoint device 106 may include orotherwise correspond to endpoint device 206. The security andintegration components 208 may include separate servers, such as webservers and/or authentication servers, and/or specialized networkingcomponents, such as firewalls, routers, gateways, load balancers, andthe like. In some cases, the security and integration components 208 maycorrespond to a set of dedicated hardware and/or software operating atthe same physical location and under the control of the same entities asserver 202. For example, components 208 may include one or morededicated web servers and network hardware in a datacenter or a cloudinfrastructure. In other examples, the security and integrationcomponents 208 may correspond to separate hardware and softwarecomponents which may be operated at a separate physical location and/orby a separate entity.

Security and integration components 208 may implement various securityfeatures for data transmission and storage, such as authenticatingendpoints and restricting access to unknown or unauthorized endpoints.In various implementations, security and integration components 208 mayprovide, for example, a file-based integration scheme or a webservice(WS) based integration scheme for transmitting data between the variousdevices in the content access network 100. Security and integrationcomponents 208 also may use secure data transmission protocols and/orencryption for data transfers, for example, File Transfer Protocol(FTP), Secure File Transfer Protocol (SFTP), and/or Pretty Good Privacy(PGP) encryption.

In some embodiments, one or more WSs may be implemented within thesecurity and integration components 208 and/or elsewhere within thecontent access network 100. Such WSs, including cross-domain and/orcross-platform WSs, may be developed for enterprise use in accordancewith various WS standards, such as RESTful WSs (i.e., those based on theRepresentation State Transfer (REST) architectural style andconstraints), and/or WSs designed in accordance with the WSInteroperability (WS-I) guidelines. Some WSs may use the Secure SocketsLayer (SSL) or Transport Layer Security (TLS) protocol to provide secureconnections between the server 202 and endpoint devices 206. SSL or TLSmay use HTTP or HTTPS to provide authentication and confidentiality. Inother examples, WSs may be implemented using REST over HTTPS with theOAuth open standard for authentication, or using the WS-Securitystandard which provides for secure SOAP (e.g., Simple Object AccessProtocol) messages using Extensible Markup Language (XML) encryption. Inother examples, the security and integration components 208 may includespecialized hardware for providing secure WSs. For example, security andintegration components 208 may include secure network appliances havingbuilt-in features such as hardware-accelerated SSL and HTTPS,WS-Security, and firewalls. Such specialized hardware may be installedand configured in front of any web servers, so that any external devicesmay communicate directly with the specialized hardware.

Communication network(s) 220 may be any type of network that can supportdata communications using any of a variety of commercially-availableprotocols, including without limitation, TCP/IP (transmission controlprotocol/Internet protocol), SNA (systems network architecture), IPX(Internet packet exchange), Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) or TransportLayer Security (TLS) protocols, Hyper Text Transfer Protocol (HTTP) andSecure Hyper Text Transfer Protocol (HTTPS), Bluetooth®, Near FieldCommunication (NFC), and the like. Merely by way of example, network(s)220 may be local area networks (LAN), such as one based on Ethernet,Token-Ring, and/or the like. Network(s) 220 also may be wide-areanetworks, such as the Internet. Networks 220 may includetelecommunication networks such as a public switched telephone networks(PSTNs), or virtual networks such as an intranet or an extranet.Infrared and wireless networks (e.g., using the Institute of Electricaland Electronics (IEEE) 802.11 protocol suite or other wirelessprotocols) also may be included in networks 220.

Computing environment 200 also may include one or more data storages 210and/or back-end servers 212. In certain examples, the data storages 210may correspond to data storage server(s) 104 discussed above in FIG. 1,and back-end servers 212 may correspond to the various back-end servers112-116. Data storages 210 and servers 212 may reside in the samedatacenter or may operate at a remote location from server 202. In somecases, one or more data storages 210 may reside on a non-transitorystorage medium within the server 202. Other data storages 210 andback-end servers 212 may be remote from server 202 and configured tocommunicate with server 202 via one or more networks 220. In certainembodiments, data storages 210 and back-end servers 212 may reside in astorage-area network (SAN), or may use STorageasaService (STaaS)architectural model.

The adaptive authentication system 100 collects, receives, and storesendpoint specification data for the provisional endpoint and collectsand stores authentication data for the actual endpoint. In someembodiments, the adaptive authentication system 100 can compare theendpoint specification data for the provisional endpoint with theauthentication data for the actual endpoint to determine if the actualendpoint is the provisional endpoint. The adaptive authentication system100 can provide an indicator to, for example, an provisional endpointand/or an administrator indicating the result of the comparison of theendpoint specification data with the authentication data in theauthenticated operation associated therewith.

The adaptive authentication system 100 can include one or more adaptiveprocessing devices. The one or more adaptive processing devices canprovide instructions to and receive information from the othercomponents of the adaptive authentication system 100. The one or moreadaptive processing devices can act according to stored instructions,which stored instructions can be located in memory associated with theone or more processors and/or in other components of the adaptiveauthentication system 100. In various embodiments, the one or moreadaptive processing devices may correspond to one or more processors ofone or a combination of the devices 106, 108, 102, 114, 206, 208, and/or212 specially adapted to adaptively secure a set of access operationswith respect to one or more electronic resources as disclosed herein.

With reference now to FIG. 2A, a block diagram of one embodiment of anendpoint device 206 is shown. As discussed above, the endpoint device206 can be configured to provide information to and/or receiveinformation from other components of the adaptive authentication system100. The endpoint device can access the adaptive authentication system100 through any desired means or technology, including, for example, awebpage such as, for example, a social network service page, or a webportal. As depicted, the endpoint device 206 can include a networkinterface 222. The network interface 222 allows the endpoint device 206to access the other components of the adaptive authentication system100, and specifically allows the endpoint device 206 to access thenetwork of the adaptive authentication system 100. The network interface222 can include features configured to send and receive information,including, for example, an antenna, a modem, a transmitter, receiver, orany other feature that can send and receive information. The networkinterface 222 can communicate via telephone, cable, fiber-optic, or anyother wired communication network. In some embodiments, the networkinterface 222 can communicate via cellular networks, WLAN networks, orany other wireless network.

The endpoint device 206 can include, for example, verification engine208-1. Verification engine 208-1 can identify and/or facilitate inidentifying the actual endpoint. In some embodiments, for example, theverification engine 208-1 can cooperate with other components of theadaptive authentication system 100 to identify and/or facilitate inidentifying the actual endpoint. In one embodiment, for example, theverification engine 208-1 can receive authentication data and endpointspecification data and compare the authentication data to the endpointspecification data, and identify the actual endpoint based on thecomparison of the authentication data to the endpoint specificationdata.

The endpoint device 206 can include an update engine 204. The updateengine 204 can facilitate updating any information within the adaptiveauthentication system 100. In some embodiments, for example, the updateengine 204 can be used by an endpoint to provide provisional endpointspecification data. In some embodiments, for example, the update engine204 can be used by an endpoint such as, for example, an administrator,to update provisional endpoint specification data and/or one or severalauthenticated operations.

The endpoint device 206 can include an endpoint interface 207 thatcommunicates information to, and receives inputs from an endpoint. Theendpoint interface 207 can include a screen, a speaker, a monitor, akeyboard, a microphone, a mouse, a touchpad, a keypad, or any otherfeature or features that can receive inputs from an endpoint and provideinformation to an endpoint.

The adaptive authentication system 100 can include one or more sensors209. Various embodiments of the adaptive authentication system 100 caninclude multiple sets of one or more sensors 209, e.g., two, three,four, ten, or many more sets of one or more sensors. For example,several sets of one or more sensors 209 may be configured to capturephenomena at several endpoint devices 206 at one or more locations 107.Additionally or alternatively, several sets of one or more sensors maybe configured to capture phenomena at a single endpoint device 206. Oneor more sets of one or more sensors 209 may be communicatively coupledto the endpoint device 206. Additionally or alternatively, one or moresets of one or more sensors may be communicatively coupled to the device110 and/or the server 108.

An endpoint subsystem may include one or more endpoint devices 106, 206and one or more sensors 209. In some embodiments, one or more sets ofone or more sensors 209 may be integrated with the endpoint device 206.Additionally or alternatively, one or more sets of one or more sensorsmay be external to the endpoint device 206. A plurality of sensors 209may include different types of sensors 209, each different type ofsensor 209 configured to detect a different type of phenomena and/orgenerate a different type of data based on the detected phenomena. Thus,a multiplicity of integrated and non-integrated sensors may beconfigured to capture phenomena at a single endpoint device 206 in orderto identify aspects of an endpoint, endpoint states, and/or theenvironment proximate to the endpoint, to facilitate any one orcombination of facial recognition, optical recognition, infraredimpressions, voice recognition, heat impressions, gestures, otherendpoint movements, and/or the like. Data captured from such sensors maybe used in identification processes disclosed herein. For example, datafrom various types of sensors 209 may be used for recognizing image(e.g., facial) baselines, sound (e.g., voices of the endpoint and othersproximate to the endpoint) baselines, activity (e.g., changinglocations, others at the location, performance, writing, and typing)baselines, and/or device location baselines, as well as deviations fromthe baselines.

The adaptive authentication system 100 (e.g., each of endpoint device206, the device 110 and/or the server 108) may be configured tocommunicate with multiple sensors 209. Such communication may usedifferent communication standards or protocols. In various embodiments,for example, the sensors 209 can be communicatively connected to andcontrollable by the adaptive authentication system 100, including, forexample, the device 110 and/or backend devices such as devices 102, 116,and/or the like.

Sensors and control units may be coupled and the sensors 209 may beconnected in a serial, parallel, star, hierarchical, and/or the liketopologies and may communicate to the endpoint device 206, the device110 and/or the server 108 via one or more serial, bus, or wirelessprotocols and technologies which may include, for example, WiFi, CANbus, Bluetooth, I2C bus, ZigBee, Z-Wave and/or the like. For instance,one or more sensors 209 may use a ZigBee® communication protocol whileone or more other sensors 209 communicate with endpoint device 206, thedevice 110 and/or the server 108 using a Z-Wave® communication protocol.Other forms of wireless communication may be used by sensors 209 and theendpoint device 206, the device 110 and/or the server 108. For instance,one or more sensors 209 and the endpoint device 206, the device 110and/or the server 108 may be configured to communicate using a wirelesslocal area network, which may use a communication protocol such as802.11.

In some embodiments, a separate device may be connected with theendpoint device 206, the device 110 and/or the server 108 to enablecommunication with authentication control devices. For instance, acommunication device may be attached to endpoint device 206, the device110 and/or the server 108. The communication device may be in the formof a dongle. The communication device may be configured to allow forZigBee®, Z-Wave®, and/or other forms of wireless communication.

The communication device and/or one or more sensors 209 may connect withthe endpoint device 206, the device 110 and/or the server 108 via a USBport or via some other type of (wired) communication port. Thecommunication device and/or one or more sensors 209 may be powered bythe endpoint device 206, the device 110 and/or the server 108 or may beseparately coupled with a power source. In some embodiments, theendpoint device 206, the device 110 and/or the server 108 may be enabledto communicate via a local wireless network and may use thecommunication device in order to communicate with sensors 209 that use aZigBee® communication protocol, Z-Wave® communication protocol, and/orsome other wireless communication protocols.

The one or more sensors 209 may include a fingerprint scanner and/or adifferent type of biometric scanner for biometric identification, suchas a retina scanner that may be used for optical identification.Further, the one or more sensors 209 may include, for example, one ormore cameras. The camera can be any device configured to generate imageand/or audio data including, for example, still image data, video imagedata, and/or any sound data, corresponding to detected phenomena. Theone or more sensors 209 of different types may include infrared sensorsand/or heat sensors. In some embodiments, the camera(s) may include oneor more infrared cameras. The camera(s) may, in some embodiments,include infrared sensors. The camera(s) may provide a video and, in someembodiments, an audio stream. The adaptive authentication system 100 mayperform image analysis of image data captured with cameras to determineone or more image baselines for endpoints and areas proximate thereto.Captured endpoint image data may be correlated to reference images usingany suitable facial trait qualifications for correlation. As disclosedherein, a matching engine 507 (depicted in FIG. 15) of the adaptiveauthentication system 100 may link particular endpoint image data toendpoint specifications with image data associated with endpoints, toidentify a known endpoint or a new endpoint. The reference image datamay be refined over time as an image baseline(s) for a particularendpoint is developed with additional data captures. Such referenceimages may be used by the system to identifyinconsistencies/nonconformities with respect to particularized patterns.When such inconsistencies/nonconformities satisfy one or morethresholds, certain authentication control actions, such as securitymeasures, may be caused.

The matching engine 507 may correspond to a learning engine thatincludes logic to implement and/or otherwise facilitate any taxonomy,classification, categorization, correlation, mapping, qualification,scoring, organization, and/or the like features disclosed herein. Invarious embodiments, the matching engine 507 may be configured toanalyze, classify, categorize, characterize, tag, and/or annotatesensor-based data. The matching engine 507 may employ one or moreartificial intelligence (machine learning or, more specifically, deeplearning) algorithms to perform pattern matching to detect patterns ofmetrics of the sensor-based data. The visual characteristics of anobject may be identified at least in part by formatting, rescaling,cropping, and/or otherwise preparing images (or portions of the imageswhere the outer shapes are defined as boundaries) for further imageprocessing. For example, as disclosed in further detail herein, thematching engine 507 may include an image analyzer and handling module,and may learn patterns of sensor-based data corresponding to visualcharacteristics of the sensor-based data gathered regarding the endpointdevice such as one or a combination of colors and any visual metricbased at least in part on light detection—e.g., aggregate color palette,color palette as a function of time, changes in light, backgroundcharacteristics, objects recognized, static/moving objects, pixelidentification, detecting color component values, detecting color codes,and/or the like. and/or the like. These different visual metric typesmay be bases for various visual metric categories. Ranges of visualmetric values for these different visual metric types may be mapped tovisual metric categories.

Additionally or alternatively, the adaptive authentication system 100may perform infrared analysis of infrared data captured with infraredsensors to determine one or more infrared baselines for endpoints andareas proximate thereto. Some embodiments may perform infrared analysisof heat data captured with heat sensors to determine one or more heatbaselines for endpoints and areas proximate thereto. Captured endpointsourced infrared and/or heat data may be correlated to referenceinfrared and/or heat impressions. As disclosed herein, the matchingengine 507 may link particular endpoint infrared and/or heat impressionsto endpoint specifications with infrared and/or heat impressionsassociated with endpoints, to identify a known endpoint or a newendpoint. The reference infrared and/or heat impressions data may berefined over time as infrared and/or heat baseline(s) for a particularindividual are developed with additional data captures. Such referenceimpressions may be used by the system to identifyinconsistencies/nonconformities with respect to particularized patterns.When such inconsistencies/nonconformities satisfy one or morethresholds, certain authentication control actions, such as securitymeasures, may be caused.

The one or more sensors 209 may include one or more microphones and/oranother audio sensor (which may or may not be dedicated to capturingaudio data for audio analysis). The adaptive authentication system 100may perform audio analysis of audio data captured with audio sensorand/or microphones on one or more other authentication control devicesto determine one or more sound baselines for the endpoint and the areaproximate thereto. The matching engine 507 may learn patterns ofsensor-based data metrics corresponding to audio characteristicsdisclosed herein, such as tonal, pitch, and volume characteristics;keywords and corresponding language used; cadence, pauses, and accents;ambient noise; and/or the like as distinctive markings. The matchingengine 507 may include an audio analyzer and handling module tofacilitate that detection, which may detect one or more audiocharacteristics by way of analyzing audio, applying voice recognition,acoustic spectrum analysis, and/or the like. For example, an acousticanalysis may include analyzing and identifying the sample for acousticcharacteristics such as frequencies, intensities, tones, pitches, and/orthe like audio metrics (such as those disclosed above) over time. Thedifferent audio metric types may be bases for various audio metriccategories. Ranges of audio metric values for the different audio metrictypes may be mapped to audio metric categories. The matching engine 507may select values of one or a combination of the acoustic metrics asdistinctive markings and may compile the values as an acousticimpression for the purposes of characterizing a sample. The acousticimpression may include a spectrum of frequencies in various embodiments.In some cases, the matching engine 507 may correlate the acousticimpression to one or more audio metric categories for the similaracoustic impressions. In various embodiments, the correlation may bebased at least in part on matching selected values of the acousticmetrics (e.g., distinctive values such as peaks, baselines, averages,etc.) to acoustic metric ranges of values specified for certain audiometric categories.

Thus, the audio impressions may be used by the system to identifyinconsistencies/nonconformities of real-time audio detection withrespect to particularized patterns. When suchinconsistencies/nonconformities satisfy one or more thresholds, certainauthentication control actions, such as security measures, may becaused.

Additionally, the one or more sensors 209 may correspond to the device206 input devices to enable recording of data pertaining to keystrokes,typing characteristics, such as typing speed, keystroke pressure, typingaccuracy/inaccuracy, usage of input options, and/or the like. Someembodiments may perform analysis of such data to determine one or moresound baselines for the endpoint and the area proximate thereto. Suchtyping impressions may be used by the system to identifyinconsistencies/nonconformities of real-time typing detection withrespect to particularized patterns. When suchinconsistencies/nonconformities satisfy one or more thresholds, certainauthentication control actions, such as security measures, may becaused.

Sensor data from sensors 209 may be recorded by the device 206, device110, a backend device such device 102, 104, 113, 114, 116, and/orstorage on external storage devices, such as a network attached storagedevice. For example, video may be transmitted across the local and/orwide area network to other storage devices upon occurrence of a triggerevent for later playback. Video and, in some embodiments, audio fromsensors 209 may be available live for viewing via device 110 and/or abackend device. In some embodiments, video may only be presented uponoccurrence of a trigger event. In various embodiments, such recordingmay or may not be constrained by the rolling window associated with atriggering event being detected. Also, sensor data may be recorded basedupon a timer, remote command, and/or a randomized interval function.

With reference to FIG. 3, an illustrative set of data storages and/ordata storage servers is shown, corresponding to the data storage servers104 of the content access network 100 discussed above in FIG. 1. One ormore particular data storages 301-311 may reside in storage on a singlecomputer server 104 (or a single server farm or cluster) under thecontrol of a single entity, may be virtually implemented, or may resideon separate servers operated at different remote locations. In someembodiments, data storages 301-311 may be accessed by the contentmanagement server 102 and/or other devices and servers within thenetwork 100 (e.g., endpoint devices 106, administrator devices 110,administrator servers 116, etc.). Access to one or more of the datastorages 301-311 may be limited or denied based on the processes,endpoint credentials, and/or devices attempting to interact with thedata storage.

The following description includes examples of specific data storagesthat may be implemented within some embodiments of a content accessnetwork 100. It should be understood that the below descriptions of datastorages 301-311, including their functionality and types of datastorage therein, are illustrative and non-limiting. Data storages serverarchitecture, design, and the execution of specific data storages301-311 may depend on the context, size, and functional requirements ofa content access network 100. For example, in content access systems 100used for development purposes, separate data storages or file-basedstorage systems may be implemented in data storage server(s) 104 tostore development module, data development results, diagnostics data,and the like. In contrast, in content access systems 100 used forresource access from resource repositories, separate data storages maybe implemented in data storages server(s) 104 to store availableresource descriptors, access statistics, endpoint specifications,network statistics, etc.

An endpoint specification data storage 301 may include endpointspecification data relating to endpoint characteristics such as theendpoint identifiers, access credentials, endpoint preferences, and datarelating to any previous endpoint interactions within the content accesssystem 100 (e.g., requested resources, posted content, resource modulescompleted, development scores or diagnostics, other associatedendpoints, etc.). In some embodiments, this data can relate to one orseveral particular endpoints such as, for example, one or severalendpoints, administrator devices, or the like, and in some embodiments,this data can relate to one or several institutional endpoints. In someembodiments, this data can identify one or several endpoint membershipsin one or several groups.

The endpoint specification data storage 301 can include data relating toan endpoint's status, location, or the like. This data can identify, forexample, an endpoint device in use, the location of that device, or thelike. In some embodiments, this data can be created based on anylocation detection technology including, for example, alocation-detection system 122, or the like.

In some embodiments, the endpoint specification data can include anyinformation relating to the provisional endpoint that is useful inidentifying the provisional endpoint. In some embodiments, for example,the endpoint specification data can include data relating to one or morephysical attributes of the provisional endpoint, data relating to one ormore performance attributes of the provisional endpoint, and/or datarelating to one or more interaction attributes of the provisionalendpoint. In some embodiments, for example, the endpoint specificationdata can include the provisional endpoint's name and/or age.

In some embodiments, for example, data relating to one or more physicalattributes of the provisional endpoint can include image data of theprovisional endpoint including, for example, image data for one orseveral still images of the provisional endpoint and/or image data forvideo of the provisional endpoint. In some embodiments, for example, thedata relating to one or more physical attributes of the provisionalendpoint can include biometric information for the provisional endpoint.This information can include, for example, a fingerprint of theprovisional endpoint, a retina scan of the provisional endpoint, a DNAsample of the provisional endpoint, or any other data relating to aphysical attribute of the endpoint.

In some embodiments, for example, data relating to one or moreperformance attributes of the provisional endpoint can include, forexample, data indicative of the provisional endpoint's past performance.This information can include, for example, data relating to courses ofstudy that the provisional endpoint has completed and/or data relatingto the provisional endpoint's performance in the completed courses. Insome embodiments, for example, the data relating to one or moreperformance attributes of the provisional endpoint can includeauthenticated operations that the provisional endpoint has completedand/or the provisional endpoint's performance in the completedauthenticated operations. In some embodiments, for example, the datarelating to one or more performance attributes of the provisionalendpoint can include an identification of information and/or topics thatthe provisional endpoint has mastered and/or identification ofinformation and/or topics that the provisional endpoint has notmastered.

In some embodiments, for example, data relating to one or moreinteraction attributes of the provisional endpoint can include, forexample, information relating to how the provisional endpoint interactswith components of the adaptive authentication system 100. Thisinformation can include, for example, the provisional endpoint'spatterns for providing inputs to the adaptive authentication system 100.In some embodiments, for example, this information can include endpointpreferences such as the input device such as, for example, a keyboard, anumber pad, a mouse, a joystick, track ball, and microphone, with whichthe provisional endpoint normally provides inputs to the adaptiveauthentication system 100. In some embodiments, for example, theprovisional endpoint's patterns for providing inputs can include typingpatterns, mouse click patterns, typing speed, words used by theendpoint, words not used by the endpoint, typing speed, which typingspeed can be either a general typing speed or a typing speed for one orseveral words, synonym pairs that include a used and a non-used word, orany other input. In some embodiments, for example, the provisionalendpoint's patterns for providing inputs can include data relating tothe provisional endpoint's demonstrated vocabulary or relating to and/oridentifying words that the provisional endpoint typically correctlyand/or incorrectly spells.

In some embodiments, for example, the endpoint specification datastorage 301 can comprise login information. This information caninclude, for example, information identifying an endpoint such as, forexample, an endpoint name and password or an endpoint identificationnumber. In some embodiments, for example, when an endpoint desires toaccess the adaptive authentication system 100, the endpoint can beprompted to enter identification information such as, for example, anendpoint name and password. After the endpoint provides theidentification information, the adaptive authentication system 100 canverify the identification information, and specifically, the one or moreadaptive processing devices can compare the endpoint-providedidentification information to information stored within the endpointspecification data storage 301 to determine if the actual endpoint is anauthorized endpoint.

In some embodiments, the endpoint specification data stored in theendpoint specification data storage 301 can be dynamically updated overtime to reflect changes to the provisional endpoint. In someembodiments, these changes can be, for example, a change in appearance,a change in performance, a change in a preference and/or interaction, orthe like. In some embodiments, these updates to the endpointspecification data storage 301 can be based on actual measured changesin the appearance, performance, preference and/or interaction, or thelike, and in some embodiments these updates to the endpointspecification data storage 301 can be based on a predictive algorithmwhich can, for example, predict changes in appearance, performance,preference and/or interaction, or the like.

Data relating to the endpoint's status can identify, for example,logged-in status data that can indicate whether the endpoint device ispresently logged-in to the content access network 100 and/or whether thelog-in is active. In some embodiments, the data relating to theendpoint's status can identify whether the endpoint is currentlyaccessing content and/or participating in an activity from the contentaccess network 100.

In some embodiments, data relating to the endpoint's status canidentify, for example, one or several attributes of the endpoint'sinteraction with the content access network 100, and/or contentdistributed by the content access network 100. This can include dataidentifying the endpoint's interactions with the content access network100, the content processed by the endpoint through the content accessnetwork 100, or the like. In some embodiments, this can include dataidentifying the type of data accessed through the content access network100 and/or the type of activity performed by the endpoint via thecontent access network 100, the lapsed time since the last time theendpoint accessed content and/or participated in an activity from thecontent access network 100, or the like. In some embodiments, this datacan relate to a content program comprising an aggregate of data,content, and/or activities, and can identify, for example, progressthrough the content program, or through the aggregate of data, content,and/or activities forming the content program. In some embodiments, thisdata can track, for example, the amount of time since participation inand/or completion of one or several types of activities, the amount oftime since communication with one or several administrators and/oradministrator devices 110, or the like.

In some embodiments in which the one or several endpoints correspond toparticular particulars, the endpoint specification data storage 301 canfurther include data relating to particular development records,statuses, and diagnostic metrics. In some embodiments, the developmentrecords can further include data identifying diagnostic metrics on oneor several diagnostics and/or assignments. In some embodiments, thisdata can be stored in a tier of memory that is not the fastest memory inthe content access network 100. In some embodiments, this can compriseresponse data such as, for example, data identifying one or severalqueries or pieces of content and responses provided to the same. In someembodiments, this response data can be formed into one or severalmatrices “D” containing data for n endpoints responding to p items,these one or several matrices D are also referred to herein as thematrix D, the D matrix, the endpoint matrix, and/or the response matrix.Thus, the matrix D can have n×p dimensions, and in some embodiments, thematrix D can identify whether endpoint responses to items were corrector incorrect. In some embodiments, for example, the matrix D can includean entry “1” for an item when an endpoint response to that item iscorrect and can otherwise include and entry “0”.

The endpoint specification data storage 301 can include data relating toone or several particular processing modes. In some embodiments, forexample, the endpoint, also referred to herein as the particular or theparticular endpoint, may have one or several processing modes, one orseveral most effective processing modes, and/or the like. In someembodiments, the endpoint's processing modes can be any processing modesdescribing how the endpoint best adapts or how the endpoint tends toadapt. In one embodiment, these processing modes can include, forexample, identification of the endpoint as an auditory adapter, as avisual adapter, and/or as a tactile adapter. In some embodiments, thedata identifying one or several endpoint processing modes can includedata identifying an adaptive approach based on the endpoint'sdevelopment history such as, for example, identifying an endpoint as anauditory adapter when the endpoint has received significantly higherscores on assignments and/or in processes favorable to auditoryadapters. In some embodiments, this data can be stored in a tier ofmemory that is not the fastest memory in the content access network 100.

In some embodiments, the endpoint specification data storage 301 canfurther include data identifying one or several endpoint performancelevels. In some embodiments, these one or several endpoint performancelevels can identify a performance level determined based on pastperformance by the endpoint interacting with the content access network100, and in some embodiments, these one or several endpoint performancelevels can identify a predicted performance level determined based onpast performance by the endpoint interacting with the content accessnetwork 100 and one or several predictive models.

The endpoint specification data storage 301 can further include datarelating to one or several administrators who are responsible fororganizing, presenting, and/or managing the presentation of data to theendpoint. In some embodiments, endpoint specification data storage 301can include data identifying processes and/or process flows that havebeen executed by endpoint devices, data identifying processes and/orprocess flows currently being executed by endpoint devices, and/or dataidentifying processes and/or process flows that will be executed byendpoint device. In some embodiments, the endpoint specification datastorage 301 can further include data indicating past diagnostics and/ordiagnostic reports received by the administrator device. In someembodiments, the endpoint specification data storage 301 can furtherinclude data relating to improvement suggestions received by theadministrator device, development received by the administrator device,continuing development received by the administrator device, and/or thelike. In some embodiments, this data can be stored in a tier of memorythat is not the fastest memory in the content access network 100.

A particularized records data storage 302 may generate and storeparticularized record data for different endpoints within the contentaccess network 100. Particularized records may be created for particularendpoints, administrators, and the like. Particularized record data mayinclude various particularized sets of access permissions,particularized record types, current particularized record status,particularized record characteristics, and any parameters and/orrestrictions associated with the particularized records.

A content object data storage 303 may include data describing theparticular content objects (or data packets) available via the contentaccess network 100. In some embodiments, these data packets in thecontent object data storage 303 can be linked to from an object network,or specifically to form a Bayes Net content network or developmentgraph. In some embodiments, these data packets can be linked in theobject network according to one or several prerequisite relationshipsthat can, for example, identify the relative hierarchy and/or difficultyof the data objects. In some embodiments, such a hierarchy of dataobjects can be created by the content access network 100 according toendpoint performance with the object network, and in some embodiments,this hierarchy of data objects can be created based on one or severalexisting and/or external hierarchies such as, for example, a processflow, an index, or the like. In some embodiments, for example, theobject network can correspond to a process flow such that contentobjects for the process flow correspond to the object network.

In some embodiments, the content object data storage 303 can comprise aprocess flow, a scheduler output, or the like that identify one orseveral operations and/or events for the endpoint device. In someembodiments, for example, when the endpoint device is a member of agroup of endpoint devices, these operations and/or events germane to theendpoint can identify one or several assignments, tests, or the like.

In some embodiments, the content object data storage 303 may includemetadata, properties, and other characteristics associated with thecontent resources stored in the content server 112. Such data mayidentify one or more aspects or content attributes of the associatedcontent resources, for example, subject matter, access level, orperformance level of the content resources, rating attributes for thecontent resources (e.g., data indicating the diagnostic or effectivenessof the content resource), and the like. In some embodiments, the contentobject data storage 303 may be configured to allow updating of contentmetadata or properties, and to allow the addition and/or removal of datarelating to the content resources. For example, content relationshipsmay be implemented as graph structures, which may be stored in thecontent object data storage 303 or in an additional storage for use byselection algorithms along with the other metadata.

In some embodiments, the content object data storage 303 can containdata used in evaluating responses received from endpoints. In someembodiments, for example, an endpoint can receive content from thecontent access network 100 and can, subsequent to receiving thatcontent, provide a response to the received content. In someembodiments, for example, the received content can comprise one orseveral queries, prompts, or the like, and the response to the receivedcontent can comprise an answer to those one or several queries, prompts,or the like. In some embodiments, data, referred to herein as“comparative data,” from the content object data storage 303 can be usedto determine whether the responses are the correct responses.

In some embodiments, the content object data storage 303 and/or theendpoint specification data storage 301 can comprise an aggregationnetwork also referred to herein as a content object network. Theaggregation network can comprise a plurality of content aggregationsthat can be linked together by, for example: creation by commonendpoint; relation to a common subject, topic, performance, or the like;creation from a common set of source material such as source datapackets; or the like. In some embodiments, the content aggregation cancomprise a grouping of content comprising the presentation portion thatcan be provided to the endpoint in the form of, for example, aquery-response object and an extraction portion that can comprise thecorrect response to the presentation portion such as for example, ananswer to a query-response object. In some embodiments, one or severalcontent aggregations can be created by the content access network 100and can be related to one or several data packets they can be, forexample, organized in object network. In some embodiments, the one orseveral content aggregations can be each created from content stored inone or several of the data packets.

In some embodiments, the content aggregations located in the contentobject data storage 303 and/or the endpoint specification data storage301 can be associated with an endpoint-creator of those contentaggregations. In some embodiments, access to content aggregations canvary based on, for example, whether an endpoint created the contentaggregations. In some embodiments, the content object data storage 303and/or the endpoint specification data storage 301 can comprise a datastorage of content aggregations associated with a specific endpoint, andin some embodiments, the content object data storage 303 and/or theendpoint specification data storage 301 can comprise a plurality of datastorages of content aggregations that are each associated with aspecific endpoint. In some embodiments, these data storages of contentaggregations can include content aggregations created by their specificendpoint and in some embodiments, these data storages of contentaggregations can further include content aggregations selected forinclusion by their specific endpoint and/or an administrator of thatspecific endpoint. In some embodiments, these content aggregations canbe arranged and/or linked in a hierarchical relationship similar to thedata packets in the object network and/or linked to the object networkin the object network or the operations or performances associated withthe data packets in the object network or the process flow or scheduleroutput.

In some embodiments, the content object network, and the contentaggregations forming the content object network, can be organizedaccording to the object network and/or the hierarchical relationshipsembodied in the object network. In some embodiments, the content objectnetwork, and/or the content aggregations forming the content objectnetwork, can be organized according to one or several operationsidentified in the process flow, scheduler output or the like.

A content access data storage 304 may include access permissions andsecurity data for the content access network 100 and specific contentresources. For example, the content access data storage 304 may includelogin data (e.g., endpoint identifiers, logins, passwords, etc.) thatcan be verified during endpoint login attempts to the network 100. Thecontent access data storage 304 also may be used to store assignedendpoint particularized sets of access permissions and/or endpointlevels of access. For example, an endpoint's access level may correspondto the sets of content resources and/or the client or serverapplications that the endpoint is permitted to access. Certain endpointsmay be permitted or denied access to certain applications and resourcesbased on their development program, process/performance level, etc.Certain endpoints may have administratory access over one or moreendpoints, allowing the administrator to access all or portions of theend endpoint's content, activities, diagnostics, etc. Additionally,certain endpoints may have administrative access over some endpointsand/or some applications in the content access network 100, allowingsuch endpoints to add and remove endpoint particularized records, modifyendpoint access permissions, perform maintenance updates on software andservers, etc.

A source data storage 305 may include data relating to the source of thecontent resources available via the content access network. For example,a source data storage 305 may identify the authors and originatingdevices of content resources, previous pieces of data and/or groups ofdata originating from the same authors or originating devices and thelike.

An diagnostic data storage 306 may include data used to direct thediagnostic of endpoints and content resources in the content accessnetwork 100. In some embodiments, the diagnostic data storage 306 maycontain, for example, the analysis criteria and the analysis guidelinesfor evaluating endpoints and/or for evaluating the content resources inthe network 100. The diagnostic data storage 306 also may include datarelating to diagnostic processing operations, for example, theidentification of endpoints and endpoint devices 106 that have receivedcertain content resources or accessed certain applications, the statusof diagnostics or diagnostic histories for content resources, endpoints,or applications, and the like. Diagnostic criteria may be stored in thediagnostic data storage 306 including data and/or instructions in theform of one or several electronic rubrics or scoring guides for use inthe diagnostic of the content, endpoints, or applications. Thediagnostic data storage 306 also may include past diagnostics and/ordiagnostic analyses for endpoints, content, and applications, includingrelative rankings, characterizations, explanations, and the like.

A model data storage 307, also referred to herein as a model datastorage 307 can store data relating to one or several predictive models.In some embodiments, these can include one or several evidence models,probability models, performance models, or the like. In someembodiments, an evidence model can be a mathematically-based statisticalmodel. The evidence model can be based on, for example, Item ResponseTheory (IRT), Bayesian Network (Bayes net), Performance Factor Analysis(PFA), or the like. The evidence model can, in some embodiments, becustomizable to an endpoint and/or to one or several content objects.Specifically, one or several inputs relating to the endpoint and/or toone or several content objects can be inserted into the evidence model.These inputs can include, for example, one or several measures ofendpoint performance level, one or several measures of content objectdifficulty and/or performance level, or the like. The customizedevidence model can then be used to predict the likelihood of theendpoint providing correct or incorrect responses to one or several ofthe content objects.

In some embodiments, the probability models can include one or severalmodels that can be used to calculate one or several model functionvalues. In some embodiments, these one or several model function valuescan be used to calculate a probability, which can characterize theprobability of a particular endpoint device failing to achieve a correctoutcome such as, for example, failing to correctly respond to one orseveral data packets, failure to achieve a correct level of completionof a program, for example in a pre-defined time period, failure toachieve a correct development outcome, or the like. In some embodiments,the probability can identify the probability of the particular-endpointfailing to complete 60% of the program.

In some embodiments, these models can include a plurality of modelfunctions including, for example, a first model function, a second modelfunction, a third model function, and a fourth model function. In someembodiments, some or all of the model functions can be associated with aportion of the program such as, for example a completion stage and/orcompletion status of the program. In one embodiment, for example, thefirst model function can be associated with a first completion status,the second model function can be associated with a second completionstatus, the third model function can be associated with a thirdcompletion status, and the fourth model function can be associated witha fourth completion status. In some embodiments, these completionstatuses can be selected such that some or all of these completionstatuses are less than the correct level of completion of the program.Specifically, in some embodiments, these completion statuses can beselected to all be at less than 60% completion of the program, and morespecifically, in some embodiments, the first completion status can be at20% completion of the program, the second completion status can be at30% completion of the program, the third completion status can be at 40%completion of the program, and the fourth completion status can be at50% completion of the program. Similarly, any correct number of modelfunctions can be associated with any correct number of completionstatuses.

In some embodiments, a model function can be selected from the pluralityof model functions based on an endpoint's progress through a program. Insome embodiments, the endpoint's progress can be compared to one orseveral status trigger thresholds, each of which status triggerthresholds can be associated with one or more of the model functions. Ifone of the status triggers is triggered by the endpoint's progress, thecorresponding one or several model functions can be selected.

The model functions can comprise a variety of types of models and/orfunctions. In some embodiments, each of the model functions outputs afunction value that can be used in calculating a probability. Thisfunction value can be calculated by performing one or severalmathematical operations on one or several values indicative of one orseveral endpoint attributes and/or endpoint parameters, also referred toherein as program status parameters. In some embodiments, each of themodel functions can use the same program status parameters, and in someembodiments, the model functions can use different program statusparameters. In some embodiments, the model functions use differentprogram status parameters when at least one of the model functions usesat least one program status parameter that is not used by others of themodel functions.

In some embodiments, a performance model can comprise a statisticalmodel identifying a predictive performance level of one or severalendpoints. In some embodiments, this model can identify a singleperformance level of an endpoint and/or a range of possible performancelevels of an endpoint. In some embodiments, this statistical model canidentify a performance level of a particular-endpoint and an error valueor error range associated with that performance level. In someembodiments, the error value can be associated with a confidenceinterval determined based on a confidence level. Thus, in someembodiments, as the number of endpoint interactions with the contentaccess network increases, the confidence level can increase and theerror value can decrease such that the range identified by the errorvalue about the predicted performance level is smaller.

A threshold data storage 308 can store one or several threshold values.These one or several threshold values can delineate between states orconditions. In one exemplary embodiment, for example, a threshold valuecan delineate between an acceptable endpoint performance and anunacceptable endpoint performance, between content appropriate for anendpoint and content that is inappropriate for an endpoint, betweenprobability levels, or the like.

A prioritization data storage 309 can include data relating to one orseveral operations and the prioritization of those one or severaloperations with respect to each other. In some embodiments, theprioritization data storage 309 can be unique to a specific endpoint,and in some embodiments, the prioritization data storage 309 can beapplicable to a plurality of endpoints. In some embodiments in which theprioritization data storage 309 is unique to a specific endpoint, theprioritization data storage 309 can be a sub-data storage of theendpoint specification data storage 301. In some embodiments, theprioritization data storage 309 can include data identifying a pluralityof operations and a relative prioritization amongst that plurality ofoperations. In some embodiments, this prioritization can be static andin some embodiments, this prioritization can be dynamic in that theprioritization can change based on updates, for example, one or severalof the operations, the endpoint specification data storage 301, or thelike. In some embodiments, the prioritization data storage 309 caninclude data relating to operations associated with a single process,group, class, or the like, and in some embodiments, the prioritizationdata storage 309 can include data relating to operations associated witha plurality of processes, groups, classes, or the like.

An operation can define an objective and/or result and can be associatedwith one or several data packets that can, for example, contribute toendpoint attainment of the objective and/or result. In some embodiments,some or all of the data packets contained in the content object datastorage 303 can be linked with one or several operations retained in theprioritization data storage 309 such that a single operation can belinked and/or associated with one or several data packets.

The prioritization data storage 309 can further include data germane tothe prioritization of one or several operations and/or theprioritization data storage 309 can include data that can be used indetermining the prioritization of one or several operations. In someembodiments, this can include weight data which can identify a relativeand/or absolute weight of a operation. In some embodiments, for example,the weight data can identify the degree to which an operationcontributes to an outcome such as, for example, a score or a grade. Insome embodiments, this weight data can specify the portion and/orpercent of a grade of a class, section, process, or study that resultsfrom, and/or that is associated with the operation.

The prioritization data storage 309 can further include data germane tothe composition of the operation. In some embodiments, for example, thisdata, also referred to herein as a composition value, can identify oneor several sub-operations and/or content categories forming theoperations, as well as a contribution of each of those sub-operationsand/or content categories to the operation. In some embodiments, theapplication of the weight data to the composition value can result inthe identification of a contribution value for the operation and/or forthe one or several sub-operations and/or content categories forming theoperation. This contribution value can identify the contribution of one,some, or all of the sub-operations and/or content categories to theoutcome such as, for example, the score or the grade.

The calendar data source 310, also referred to herein as the calendardata storage 310 can include timing data germane to the operationscontained in the prioritization data storage 309. In some embodiments,this timing data can identify one or several dates by which theoperations should be completed, one or several event dates associatedwith the operation such as, for example, one or several due dates, testdates, or the like, excluded day data, or the like. In some embodiments,the calendar data storage 310 can further include any data provided tothe endpoint relating to other objectives, commitments, or the like.

In addition to the illustrative data storages described above, datastorage server(s) 104 (e.g., data storage servers, file-based storageservers, etc.) may include one or more external data aggregators 311.External data aggregators 311 may include external data sourcesaccessible to the content access network 100, but not maintained by thecontent access network 100. External data aggregators 311 may includeany electronic data source relating to the endpoints, content resources,or applications of the content access network 100. For example, externaldata aggregators 311 may be external data storages containingdevelopment-related data and the like. Data retrieved from variousexternal data aggregators 311 may be used to verify and update endpointparticularized record data, suggest endpoint content, and performendpoint and content diagnostics.

An authentication data storage 312 can include authentication datacollected during the performance of the authenticated operation. Thisauthentication data can include any information collected and/orcollectible during the authenticated operation and useful in identifyingthe actual endpoint. This information can, in some embodiments,correspond to information stored in the endpoint specification datastorage 301.

A verification data storage 313 can include information used indetermining and/or verifying the identity of the actual endpoint. Insome embodiments, for example, this information can include algorithmsand/or procedures for comparing endpoint specification data withauthentication data and/or for processing results of the comparison ofthe endpoint specification data with the authentication data. In someembodiments, the verification data storage 313 can include, for example,criteria and/or thresholds useful in evaluating the results of thecomparison of endpoint specification data with authentication data.

With reference now to FIG. 4, a block diagram is shown illustrating anembodiment of one or more content management servers 102 within acontent access network 100. In such an embodiment, content managementserver 102 performs internal data gathering and processing of streamedcontent along with external data gathering and processing. Otherembodiments could have either all external or all internal datagathering. This embodiment allows reporting timely data that might be ofinterest to the reporting party or other parties. In this embodiment,the content management server 102 can monitor gathered data from severalsources to allow it to make timely business and/or processing decisionsbased upon that data. For example, reports of endpoint actions and/orresponses, as well as the status and/or results of one or severalprocessing operations could be gathered and reported to the contentmanagement server 102 from a number of sources.

Internally, the content management server 102 gathers data from one ormore internal components 402-408. The internal components 402-408 gatherand/or process data relating to such things as: content provided toendpoints; content consumed by endpoints; responses provided byendpoints; endpoint performance levels; content difficulty levels; nextcontent for providing to endpoints; etc. The internal components 402-408can report the gathered and/or created data in real-time, near real-timeor along another time line. To particularized record for any delay inreporting data, a time stamp or staleness indicator can inform others ofhow timely the data was sampled. The content management server 102 canopt to allow third parties to use internally or externally gathered datathat is aggregated within the server 102 by subscription to the contentaccess network 100.

A command and control (CC) interface 338 configures the gathered inputdata to an output of data streams, also referred to herein as contentstreams. APIs for accepting gathered data and providing data streams areprovided to third parties external to the server 102 who want tosubscribe to data streams. The server 102 or a third party can design asyet undefined APIs using the CC interface 338. The server 102 can alsodefine authorization and authentication parameters using the CCinterface 338 such as authentication, authorization, login, and/or dataencryption. CC data is passed to the internal components 402-408 and/orother components of the content access network 100 through a channelseparate from the gathered data or data stream in this embodiment, butother embodiments could embed CC data in these communication channels.The CC data allows throttling data reporting frequency, specifyingformats for data and data streams, deactivation of one or severalinternal components 402-408 and/or other components of the contentaccess network 100, updating authentication and authorization, etc.

The various data streams that are available can be researched andexplored through the CC interface 338. Those data stream selections fora particular subscriber, which can be one or several of the internalcomponents 402-408 and/or other components of the content access network100, are stored in the queue subscription data storage 322. The server102 and/or the CC interface 338 then routes selected data streams toprocessing subscribers that have selected delivery of a given datastream. Additionally, the server 102 also supports historical queries ofthe various data streams that are stored in an historical data storage334 as gathered by an archive data agent 336. Through the CC interface338 various data streams can be selected for archiving into thehistorical data storage 334.

Components of the content access network 100 outside of the server 102can also gather data that is reported to the server 102 in real-time,near real-time, or along another time line. There is a defined APIbetween those components and the server 102. Each type of data orvariable collected by server 102 falls within a defined API or multipleAPIs. In some cases, the CC interface 338 is used to define additionalvariables to modify an API that might be of use to processingsubscribers. The additional variables can be passed to all processingsubscribes or just a subset. For example, a component of the contentaccess network 100 outside of the server 102 may report an endpointresponse, but define an identifier of that endpoint as a privatevariable that would not be passed to processing subscribers lackingaccess to that endpoint and/or authorization to receive that endpointdata. Processing subscribers having access to that endpoint and/orauthorization to receive that endpoint data would receive the subscriberidentifier along with the response reported to that component.Encryption and/or unique addressing of data streams or sub-streams canbe used to hide the private variables within the messaging queues.

The endpoint devices 106 and/or administrator devices 110 communicatewith the server 102 through security and/or integration hardware 410.The communication with security and/or integration hardware 410 can beencrypted or not. For example, a socket using a TCP connection could beused. In addition to TCP, other transport layer protocols like ControlTransmission Protocol (SCTP) and Endpoint Datagram Protocol (UDP) couldbe used in some embodiments to intake the gathered data. A protocol suchas SSL could be used to protect the data over the TCP connection.Authentication and authorization can be performed to any endpointdevices 106 and/or administrator device interfacing to the server 102.The security and/or integration hardware 410 receives the data from oneor several of the endpoint devices 106 and/or the administrator devices110 by providing the API and any encryption, authorization, and/orauthentication. In some cases, the security and/or integration hardware410 reformats or rearranges this received data

The messaging bus 412, also referred to herein as a messaging queue or amessaging channel, can receive data from the internal components of theserver 102 and/or components of the content access network 100 outsideof the server 102 and distribute the gathered data as a data stream toany processing subscribers that have requested the data stream from themessaging queue 412. As indicated in FIG. 4, processing subscribers areindicated by a connector to the messaging bus 412, the connector havingan arrow head pointing away from the messaging bus 412. In someexamples, only data streams within the messaging queue 412 that aparticular processing subscriber has subscribed to may be read by thatprocessing subscriber if received at all. Gathered data sent to themessaging queue 412 is processed and returned in a data stream in afraction of a second by the messaging queue 412. Various multicastingand routing techniques can be used to distribute a data stream from themessaging queue 412 that a number of processing subscribers haverequested. Protocols such as Multicast or multiple Unicast could be usedto distributed streams within the messaging queue 412. Additionally,transport layer protocols like TCP, SCTP, and UDP could be used invarious embodiments.

Through the CC interface 338, an external or internal processingsubscriber can be assigned one or more data streams within the messagingqueue 412. A data stream is a particular type of messages in aparticular category. For example, a data stream can comprise all of thedata reported to the messaging bus 412 by a designated set ofcomponents. One or more processing subscribers could subscribe andreceive the data stream to process the data and make a decision and/orfeed the output from the processing as gathered data fed back into themessaging queue 412. Through the CC interface 338 a developer can searchthe available data streams or specify a new data stream and its API. Thenew data stream might be determined by processing a number of existingdata streams with a processing subscriber.

The content access network 100 has internal processing subscribers402-408 that process assigned data streams to perform functions withinthe server 102. Internal processing subscribers 402-408 could performfunctions such as providing content to an endpoint, receiving a responsefrom an endpoint, determining the correctness of the received response,updating one or several models based on the correctness of the response,recommending new content for providing to one or several endpoints, orthe like. The internal processing subscribers 402-408 can decidefiltering and weighting of records from the data stream. To the extentthat decisions are made based upon analysis of the data stream, eachdata record is time stamped to reflect when the data was gathered suchthat additional credibility could be given to more recent results, forexample. Other embodiments may filter out records in the data streamthat are from an unreliable source or stale. For example, a particularcontributor of data may prove to have less than optimal gathered dataand that could be weighted very low or removed altogether.

Internal processing subscribers 402-408 may additionally process one ormore data streams to provide different data to feed back into themessaging queue 412 to be part of a different data stream. For example,hundreds of endpoint devices 106 could provide responses that are putinto a data stream on the messaging queue 412. An internal processingsubscriber 402-408 could receive the data stream and process it todetermine the difficulty of one or several data packets provided to oneor several endpoints and supply this data back onto the messaging queue412 for possible use by other internal and external processingsubscribers.

As mentioned above, the CC interface 338 allows the network 100 to queryhistorical messaging queue 412 data. An archive data agent 336 listensto the messaging queue 412 to store data streams in a historical datastorage 334. The historical data storage 334 may store data streams forvarying amounts of time and may not store all data streams. Differentdata streams may be stored for different amounts of time.

With regards to the components 402-408, the content management server(s)102 may include various server hardware and software components thatmanage the content resources within the content access network 100 andprovide interactive and adaptive content to endpoints on variousendpoint devices 106. For example, content management server(s) 102 mayprovide instructions to and receive data from the other devices withinthe content access network 100, in order to manage and transmit contentresources, endpoint data, and server or client applications executingwithin the network 100.

A content management server 102 may include a packet selection system402. The packet selection system 402 may be implemented using dedicatedhardware within the content access network 100 (e.g., a packet selectionserver 402), or using designated hardware and software resources withina shared content management server 102. In some embodiments, the packetselection system 402 may adjust the selection and adaptive capabilitiesof content resources to match the needs and desires of the endpointsreceiving the content. For example, the packet selection system 402 mayquery various data storages and servers 104 to retrieve endpoint data,such as endpoint preferences and characteristics (e.g., from an endpointspecification data storage 301), endpoint access restrictions to contentreprocesses (e.g., from a content access data storage 304), previousendpoint results and content diagnostics (e.g., from an diagnostic datastorage 306), and the like. Based on the retrieved data from datastorages 104 and other data sources, the packet selection system 402 maymodify content resources for particular endpoints.

In some embodiments, the packet selection system 402 can include arecommendation engine, also referred to herein as an adaptiverecommendation engine. In some embodiments, the recommendation enginecan select one or several pieces of content, also referred to herein asdata packets, for providing to an endpoint. These data packets can beselected based on, for example, the data retrieved from the data storageserver 104 including, for example, the endpoint specification datastorage 301, the content object data storage 303, the model data storage307, or the like. In some embodiments, these one or several data packetscan be adaptively selected and/or selected according to one or severalselection rules. In one embodiment, for example, the recommendationengine can retrieve data from the endpoint specification data storage301 identifying, for example, a performance level of the endpoint. Therecommendation engine can further retrieve data from the content objectdata storage 303 identifying, for example, potential data packets forproviding to the endpoint and the difficulty of those data packetsand/or the performance level associated with those data packets.

The recommendation engine can identify one or several potential datapackets for providing and/or one or several data packets for providingto the endpoint based on, for example, one or several rules, models,predictions, or the like. The recommendation engine can use theperformance level of the endpoint to generate a prediction of thelikelihood of one or several endpoints providing a correct response tosome or all of the potential data packets. In some embodiments, therecommendation engine can pair one or several data packets withselection criteria that may be used to determine which packet should bedelivered to an endpoint based on one or several received responses fromthat particular-endpoint. In some embodiments, one or several datapackets can be eliminated from the pool of potential data packets if theprediction indicates either too high a likelihood of a correct responseor too low a likelihood of a correct response. In some embodiments, therecommendation engine can then apply one or several selection criteriato the remaining potential data packets to select a data packet forproviding to the endpoint. These one or several selection criteria canbe based on, for example, criteria relating to a correct estimated timefor receipt of response to the data packet, one or several contentparameters, one or several assignment parameters, or the like.

A content management server 102 also may include a summary model system404. The summary model system 404 may be implemented using dedicatedhardware within the content access network 100 (e.g., a summary modelserver 404), or using designated hardware and software resources withina shared content management server 102. In some embodiments, the summarymodel system 404 may monitor the progress of endpoints through varioustypes of content resources and groups, such as resource compilations,processes, or curriculums in development or development contexts,interactive gaming environments, and the like. For example, the summarymodel system 404 may query one or more data storages and/or data storageservers 104 to retrieve endpoint data such as associated contentcompilations or programs, content completion status, endpointobjectives, results, and the like.

A content management server 102 also may include a response system 406,which can include, in some embodiments, a response processor. Theresponse system 406 may be implemented using dedicated hardware withinthe content access network 100 (e.g., a response server 406), or usingdesignated hardware and software resources within a shared contentmanagement server 102. The response system 406 may be configured toreceive and analyze data from endpoint devices 106. For example, variousratings of content resources submitted by endpoints may be compiled andanalyzed, and then stored in a data storage (e.g., a content object datastorage 303 and/or diagnostic data storage 306) associated with thecontent. In some embodiments, the response server 406 may analyze thedata to determine the effectiveness or appropriateness of contentresources with, for example, a subject matter, an age group, aperformance level, or the like. In some embodiments, the response system406 may provide updates to the packet selection system 402 or thesummary model system 404, with the attributes of one or more contentresources or groups of resources within the network 100. The responsesystem 406 also may receive and analyze endpoint diagnostic data fromendpoint devices 106, administrator devices 110, and administratorservers 116, etc. For instance, response system 406 may receive,aggregate, and analyze endpoint diagnostic data for different types ofendpoints (e.g., endpoints, administrators, administrators, etc.) indifferent contexts (e.g., resource consumer ratings, developee orparticular comprehension levels, administrator device effectivenesslevels, gamer performance levels, etc.).

In some embodiments, the response system 406 can be further configuredto receive one or several responses from the endpoint and analyze theseone or several responses. In some embodiments, for example, the responsesystem 406 can be configured to translate the one or several responsesinto one or several observables. As used herein, an observable is acharacterization of a received response. In some embodiments, thetranslation of the one or several response into one or severalobservables can include determining whether the one or several responseare correct responses, also referred to herein as correct responses, orare incorrect responses, also referred to herein as incorrect responses.In some embodiments, the translation of the one or several response intoone or several observables can include characterizing the degree towhich one or several response are correct responses and/or incorrectresponses. In some embodiments, one or several values can be created bythe response system 406 to reflect endpoint performance in responding tothe one or several data packets. In some embodiments, these one orseveral values can comprise one or several scores for one or severalresponses and/or data packets.

A content management server 102 also may include a presentation system408. The presentation system 408 may be implemented using dedicatedhardware within the content access network 100 (e.g., a presentationserver 408), or using designated hardware and software resources withina shared content management server 102. The presentation system 408 caninclude a presentation engine that can be, for example, a softwaremodule running on the content delivery system.

The presentation system 408, also referred to herein as the presentationmodule or the presentation engine, may receive content resources fromthe packet selection system 402 and/or from the summary model system404, and provide the resources to endpoint devices 106. The presentationsystem 408 may determine the appropriate presentation format for thecontent resources based on the endpoint characteristics and preferences,and/or the device capabilities of endpoint devices 106. If needed, thepresentation system 408 may convert the content resources to theappropriate presentation format and/or compress the content beforetransmission. In some embodiments, the presentation system 408 may alsodetermine the appropriate transmission resource and communicationprotocols for transmission of the content resources.

In some embodiments, the presentation system 408 may include specializedsecurity and integration hardware 410, along with corresponding softwarecomponents to implement the appropriate security features contenttransmission and storage, to provide the supported network and clientaccess models, and to support the performance and scalabilityrequirements of the network 100. The security and integration layer 410may include some or all of the security and integration components 208discussed above in FIG. 2, and may control the transmission of contentresources and other data, as well as the receipt of requests and contentinteractions, to and from the endpoint devices 106, administratordevices 110, administrator servers 116, and other devices in the network100.

With reference now to FIG. 5, a block diagram of an illustrativecomputer system is shown. The system 500 may correspond to any of thecomputing devices or servers of the content access network 100 describedabove, or any other computing devices described herein, and specificallycan include, for example, one or several of the endpoint devices 106,the administrator device 110, and/or any of the servers 102, 104, 108,112, 114, 116. In this example, computer system 500 includes processingunits 504 that communicate with a number of peripheral subsystems via abus subsystem 502. These peripheral subsystems include, for example, astorage subsystem 510, an I/O subsystem 526, and a communicationssubsystem 532.

Bus subsystem 502 provides a mechanism for letting the variouscomponents and subsystems of computer system 500 communicate with eachother as intended. Although bus subsystem 502 is shown schematically asa single bus, alternative embodiments of the bus subsystem may utilizemultiple buses. Bus subsystem 502 may be any of several types of busstructures including a memory bus or memory controller, a peripheralbus, and a local bus using any of a variety of bus architectures. Sucharchitectures may include, for example, an Industry StandardArchitecture (ISA) bus, Micro Channel Architecture (MCA) bus, EnhancedISA (EISA) bus, Video Electronics Standards Association (VESA) localbus, and Peripheral Component Interconnect (PCI) bus, which can beimplemented as a Mezzanine bus manufactured to the IEEE P1386.1standard.

Processing unit 504, which may be implemented as one or more integratedcircuits (e.g., a conventional microprocessor or microcontroller),controls the operation of computer system 500. One or more processors,including single core and/or multicore processors, may be included inprocessing unit 504. As shown in the figure, processing unit 504 may beimplemented as one or more independent processing units 506 and/or 508with single or multicore processors and processor caches included ineach processing unit. In other embodiments, processing unit 504 may alsobe implemented as a quad-core processing unit or larger multicoredesigns (e.g., hexa-core processors, octo-core processors, ten-coreprocessors, or greater.

Processing unit 504 may execute a variety of software processes embodiedin program code, and may maintain multiple concurrently executingprograms or processes. At any given time, some or all of the programcode to be executed can be resident in processor(s) 504 and/or instorage subsystem 510. In some embodiments, computer system 500 mayinclude one or more specialized processors, such as digital signalprocessors (DSPs), outboard processors, graphics processors,application-specific processors, and/or the like.

I/O subsystem 526 may include device controllers 528 for one or moreendpoint interface input devices and/or endpoint interface outputdevices 530. Endpoint interface input and output devices 530 may beintegral with the computer system 500 (e.g., integrated audio/videosystems, and/or touchscreen displays), or may be separate peripheraldevices which are attachable/detachable from the computer system 500.The I/O subsystem 526 may provide one or several outputs to an endpointby converting one or several electrical signals to endpoint perceptibleand/or interpretable form, and may receive one or several inputs fromthe endpoint by generating one or several electrical signals based onone or several endpoint-caused interactions with the I/O subsystem suchas the depressing of a key or button, the moving of a mouse, theinteraction with a touchscreen or trackpad, the interaction of a soundwave with a microphone, or the like.

Input devices 530 may include a keyboard, pointing devices such as amouse or trackball, a touchpad or touch screen incorporated into adisplay, a scroll wheel, a click wheel, a dial, a button, a switch, akeypad, audio input devices with voice command recognition systems,microphones, and other types of input devices. Input devices 530 mayalso include three dimensional (3D) mice, joysticks or pointing sticks,gamepads and graphic tablets, and audio/visual devices such as speakers,digital cameras, digital camcorders, portable resource players, webcams,image scanners, fingerprint scanners, barcode reader 3D scanners, 3Dprinters, laser rangefinders, and eye gaze tracking devices. Additionalinput devices 530 may include, for example, motion sensing and/orgesture recognition devices that enable endpoints to control andinteract with an input device through a natural endpoint interface usinggestures and spoken commands, eye gesture recognition devices thatdetect eye activity from endpoints and transform the eye gestures asinput into an input device, voice recognition sensing devices thatenable endpoints to interact with voice recognition systems throughvoice commands, medical imaging input devices, MIDI keyboards, digitalmusical instruments, and the like.

Output devices 530 may include one or more display subsystems, indicatorlights, or non-visual displays such as audio output devices, etc.Display subsystems may include, for example, cathode ray tube (CRT)displays, flat-panel devices, such as those using a liquid crystaldisplay (LCD) or plasma display, light-emitting diode (LED) displays,projection devices, touch screens, and the like. In general, use of theterm “output device” is intended to include all possible types ofdevices and mechanisms for outputting data from computer system 500 toan endpoint or other computer. For example, output devices 530 mayinclude, without limitation, a variety of display devices that visuallyconvey text, graphics, and audio/video data such as monitors, printers,speakers, headphones, automotive navigation systems, plotters, voiceoutput devices, and modems.

Computer system 500 may comprise one or more storage subsystems 510,comprising hardware and software components used for storing data andprogram instructions, such as system memory 518 and computer-readablestorage resource 516. The system memory 518 and/or computer-readablestorage resource 516 may store program instructions that are loadableand executable on processing units 504, as well as data created duringthe execution of these programs.

Depending on the configuration and type of computer system 500, systemmemory 518 may be stored in volatile memory (such as random accessmemory (RAM) 512) and/or in non-volatile storage drives 514 (such asread-only memory (ROM), flash memory, etc.). The RAM 512 may containdata and/or program modules that are intermediately accessible to and/orpresently being operated and executed by processing units 504. In someimplementations, system memory 518 may include multiple different typesof memory, such as static random access memory (SRAM) or dynamic randomaccess memory (DRAM). In some implementations, a basic input/outputsystem (BIOS), containing the basic routines that help to transfer databetween elements within computer system 500, such as during start-up,may typically be stored in the non-volatile storage drives 514. By wayof example, and not limitation, system memory 518 may includeapplication programs 520, such as client applications, Web browsers,mid-tier applications, server applications, etc., program data 522, andan operating system 524.

Storage subsystem 510 also may provide one or more tangiblecomputer-readable storage resource 516 for storing the basic programmingand data constructs that provide the functionality of some embodiments.Software (programs, code modules, instructions) that when executed by aprocessor provide the functionality described herein may be stored instorage subsystem 510. These software modules or instructions may beexecuted by processing units 504. Storage subsystem 510 may also providea repository for storing data used in accordance with the presentdisclosure.

Storage subsystem 510 may also include a computer-readable storageresource reader that can further be connected to computer-readablestorage resource 516. Together and, optionally, in combination withsystem memory 518, computer-readable storage resource 516 maycomprehensively represent remote, local, fixed, and/or removable storagedevices plus storage resource for temporarily and/or more permanentlycontaining, storing, transmitting, and retrieving computer-readabledata.

Computer-readable storage resource 516 containing program code, orportions of program code, may include any appropriate resource known orused in the art, including storage resource and communication resource,such as, but not limited to, volatile and non-volatile, removable andnon-removable resource implemented in any method or technology forstorage and/or transmission of data. This can include tangiblecomputer-readable storage resource such as RAM, ROM, electronicallyerasable programmable ROM (EEPROM), flash memory or other memorytechnology, CD-ROM, digital versatile disk (DVD), or other opticalstorage, magnetic cassettes, magnetic tape, magnetic disk storage orother magnetic storage devices, or other tangible computer readableresource. This can also include nontangible computer-readable resource,such as data signals, data transmissions, or any other medium which canbe used to transmit the correct data and which can be accessed bycomputer system 500.

By way of example, computer-readable storage resource 516 may include ahard disk drive that reads from or writes to non-removable, nonvolatilemagnetic resource, a magnetic disk drive that reads from or writes to aremovable, nonvolatile magnetic disk, and an optical disk drive thatreads from or writes to a removable, nonvolatile optical disk such as aCD ROM, DVD, and Blu-Ray® disk, or other optical resource.Computer-readable storage resource 516 may include, but is not limitedto, Zip® drives, flash memory cards, universal serial bus (USB) flashdrives, secure digital (SD) cards, DVD disks, digital video tape, andthe like. Computer-readable storage resource 516 may also include,solid-state drives (SSD) based on non-volatile memory such asflash-memory based SSDs, enterprise flash drives, solid state ROM, andthe like, SSDs based on volatile memory such as solid state RAM, dynamicRAM, static RAM,

DRAM-based SSDs, magnetoresistive RAM (MRAM) SSDs, and hybrid SSDs thatuse a combination of DRAM and flash memory based SSDs. The disk drivesand their associated computer-readable resource may provide non-volatilestorage of computer-readable instructions, data structures, programmodules, and other data for computer system 500.

Communications subsystem 532 may provide a communication interface fromcomputer system 500 and external computing devices via one or morecommunication networks, including local area networks (LANs), wide areanetworks (WANs) (e.g., the Internet), and various wirelesstelecommunications networks. As illustrated in FIG. 5, thecommunications subsystem 532 may include, for example, one or morenetwork interface controllers (NICs) 534, such as Ethernet cards,Asynchronous Transfer Mode NICs, Token Ring NICs, and the like, as wellas one or more wireless communications interfaces 536, such as wirelessnetwork interface controllers (WNICs), wireless network adapters, andthe like. As illustrated in FIG. 5, the communications subsystem 532 mayinclude, for example, one or more location determining features 538 suchas one or several navigation system features and/or receivers, and thelike. Additionally and/or alternatively, the communications subsystem532 may include one or more modems (telephone, satellite, cable, ISDN),synchronous or asynchronous digital subscriber line (DSL) units,FireWire® interfaces, USB® interfaces, and the like. Communicationssubsystem 536 also may include radio frequency (RF) transceivercomponents for accessing wireless voice and/or data networks (e.g.,using cellular telephone technology, advanced data network technology,such as 3G, 4G or EDGE (enhanced data rates for global evolution), WiFi(IEEE 802.11 family standards, or other mobile communicationtechnologies, or any combination thereof), global positioning system(GPS) receiver components, and/or other components.

The various physical components of the communications subsystem 532 maybe detachable components coupled to the computer system 500 via acomputer network, a FireWire® bus, or the like, and/or may be physicallyintegrated onto a motherboard of the computer system 500. Communicationssubsystem 532 also may be implemented in whole or in part by software.

In some embodiments, communications subsystem 532 may also receive inputcommunication in the form of structured and/or unstructured data feeds,event streams, event updates, and the like, on behalf of one or moreendpoints who may use or access computer system 500. For example,communications subsystem 532 may be configured to receive data feeds inreal-time from endpoints of social networks and/or other communicationfunctionalities, web feeds such as Rich Site Summary (RSS) feeds, and/orreal-time updates from one or more third party data sources (e.g.,external data source 311). Additionally, communications subsystem 532may be configured to receive data in the form of continuous datastreams, which may include event streams of real-time events and/orevent updates (e.g., sensor data applications, financial tickers,network performance measuring tools, clickstream analysis tools,automobile traffic monitoring, etc.). Communications subsystem 532 mayoutput such structured and/or unstructured data feeds, event streams,event updates, and the like to one or more data storages 104 that may bein communication with one or more streaming data source computerscoupled to computer system 500.

Due to the ever-changing nature of computers and networks, thedescription of computer system 500 depicted in the figure is intendedonly as a specific example. Many other configurations having more orfewer components than the system depicted in the figure are possible.For example, customized hardware might also be used and/or particularelements might be implemented in hardware, firmware, software, or acombination. Further, connection to other computing devices, such asnetwork input/output devices, may be employed. Based on the disclosureand teachings provided herein, an endpoint of ordinary performance inthe art will appreciate other ways and/or methods to implement thevarious embodiments.

With reference now to FIG. 6, a block diagram illustrating oneembodiment of the communication network is shown. Specifically, FIG. 6depicts one hardware configuration in which messages are exchangedbetween a source hub 602 and a terminal hub 606 via the communicationnetwork 120 that can include one or several intermediate hubs 604. Insome embodiments, the source hub 602 can be any one or severalcomponents of the content access network generating and initiating thesending of a message, and the terminal hub 606 can be any one or severalcomponents of the content access network 100 receiving and notre-sending the message. In some embodiments, for example, the source hub602 can be one or several of the endpoint device 106, the administratordevice 110, and/or the server 102, and the terminal hub 606 can likewisebe one or several of the endpoint device 106, the administrator device110, and/or the server 102. In some embodiments, the intermediate hubs604 can include any computing device that receives the message andresends the message to a next node.

As seen in FIG. 6, in some embodiments, each of the hubs 602, 604, 606can be communicatively connected with the data storage 104. In such anembodiments, some or all of the hubs 602, 604, 606 can send data to thedata storage 104 identifying a received message and/or any sent orresent message. This data can, in some embodiments, be used to determinethe completeness of any sent and/or received messages and/or to verifythe accuracy and completeness of any message received by the terminalhub 606.

In some embodiments, the communication network 120 can be formed by theintermediate hubs 604. In some embodiments, the communication network120 can comprise a single intermediate hub 604, and in some embodiments,the communication network 120 can comprise a plurality of intermediatehubs. In one embodiment, for example, and as depicted in FIG. 6, thecommunication network 120 includes a first intermediate hub 604-A and asecond intermediate hub 604-B.

With reference now to FIG. 7, a block diagram illustrating oneembodiment of endpoint device 106 and administrator device 110communication is shown. In some embodiments, for example, an endpointmay have multiple devices that can connect with the content accessnetwork 100 to send or receive data. In some embodiments, for example,an endpoint may have a particular device such as a mobile device, asmartphone, a tablet, a smartwatch, a laptop, a PC, or the like. In someembodiments, the other device can be any computing device in addition tothe particular device. This other device can include, for example, alaptop, a PC, a smartphone, a tablet, a smartwatch, or the like. In someembodiments, the other device differs from the particular device in thatthe particular device is registered as such within the content accessnetwork 100 and the other device is not registered as a particulardevice within the content access network 100.

Specifically with respect to FIG. 7 in view of the devices illustratedwith FIG. 1, the endpoint device 106 can include a particular endpointdevice 106-A and one or several other endpoint devices 106-B. In someembodiments, one or both of the particular endpoint device 106-A and theone or several other endpoint devices 106-B can be communicativelyconnected to the content management server 102 and/or to the navigationsystem 122. Similarly, the administrator device 110 can include aparticular administrator device 110-A and one or several otheradministrator devices 110-B. In some embodiments, one or both of theparticular administrator device 110-A and the one or several otheradministrator devices 110-B can be communicatively connected to thecontent management server 102 and/or to the navigation system 122.

In some embodiments, the content access network can send one or morealerts to one or more endpoint devices 106 and/or one or moreadministrator devices 110 via, for example, the communication network120. In some embodiments, the receipt of the alert can result in thelaunching of an application within the receiving device, and in someembodiments, the alert can include a link that, when selected, launchesthe application or navigates a web-browser of the device of the selectorof the link to page or portal associated with the alert.

In some embodiments, for example, the providing of this alert caninclude the identification of one or several endpoint devices 106 and/orparticular-endpoint particularized records associated with theparticular-endpoint and/or one or several administrator devices 110and/or administrator-endpoint particularized records associated with theadministrator-endpoint. After these one or several devices 106, 110and/or particularized records have been identified, the providing ofthis alert can include determining an active device of the devices 106,110 based on determining which of the devices 106, 110 and/orparticularized records are actively being used, and then providing thealert to that active device.

Specifically, if the endpoint is actively using one of the devices 106,110 such as the other endpoint device 106-B and the other administratordevice 110-B, and/or particularized records, the alert can be providedto the endpoint via that other device 106-B, 110-B, and/orparticularized record that is actively being used. If the endpoint isnot actively using another device 106-B, 110-B, and/or particularizedrecord, a particular device 106-A, 110-A device, such as a smart phoneor tablet, can be identified and the alert can be provided to thisparticular device 106-A, 110-A. In some embodiments, the alert caninclude code to direct the default device to provide an indicator of thereceived alert such as, for example, an oral, tactile, or visualindicator of receipt of the alert.

In some embodiments, the recipient device 106, 110 of the alert canprovide an indication of receipt of the alert. In some embodiments, thepresentation of the alert can include the control of the I/O subsystem526 to, for example, provide an oral, tactile, and/or visual indicatorof the alert and/or of the receipt of the alert. In some embodiments,this can include controlling a screen of the administrator device 110 todisplay the alert, data contained in alert and/or an indicator of thealert.

With reference now to FIG. 8, a schematic illustration of one embodimentof an application stack, and particularly of a stack 650 is shown. Insome embodiments, the content access network 100 can comprise a portionof the stack 650 that can include an infrastructure layer 652, aplatform layer 654, an applications layer 656, and a products layer 658.In some embodiments, the stack 650 can comprise some or all of thelayers, hardware, and/or software to provide one or several correctfunctionalities and/or productions.

As depicted in FIG. 8, the infrastructure layer 652 can include one orseveral servers, communication networks, data storages, privacy servers,and the like. In some embodiments, the infrastructure layer can furtherinclude one or several endpoint devices 106 and/or devices 110 connectedas part of the content access network.

The platform layer can include one or several platform softwareprograms, modules, and/or capabilities. These can include, for example,identification functionalities, security functionalities, and/oradaptive platform functionalities 660. In some embodiments, theidentification functionalities can, for example, identify one or severalendpoints, components of the content access network 100, or the like.The security functionalities can monitor the content access network forone or several security threats, breaches, viruses, malware, or thelike. The adaptive platform functionalities 660 can receive data fromone or several components of the content access network 100 and canprovide predictions, models, recommendations, or the like based on thatreceived data. The adaptive platform functionalities 660 will bediscussed in greater detail in FIGS. 9-11, below.

The applications layer 656 can include software or software modules uponor in which one or several product softwares or product software modulescan operate. In some embodiments, the applications layer 656 caninclude, for example, a management system, record system, or the like.In some embodiments, the management system can include, for example, aDevelopment Management System (L[earning]MS), a Content ManagementSystem (CMS), or the like. The management system can be configured tocontrol the delivery of one or several resources to an endpoint and/orto receive one or several responses from the endpoint. In someembodiments, the records system can include, for example, a virtualperformance metric log, a virtual assistant, or the like.

The products layer can include one or several software products and/orsoftware module products. These software products and/or software moduleproducts can provide one or several functionalities to one or severalendpoints of the software products and/or software module products.

With reference now to FIG. 9-11, schematic illustrations of embodimentsof communication and processing flow of modules within the contentaccess network 100 are shown. In some embodiments, the communication andprocessing can be performed in portions of the platform layer 654 and/orapplications layer 656. FIG. 9 depicts a first embodiment of suchcommunications or processing that can be in the platform layer 654and/or applications layer 656 via the message channel 412.

The platform layer 654 and/or applications layer 656 can include aplurality of modules that can be embodied in software or hardware. Insome embodiments, some or all of the modules can be embodied in hardwareand/or software at a single location, and in some embodiments, some orall of these modules can be embodied in hardware and/or software atmultiple locations. These modules can perform one or several processesincluding, for example, a presentation process 670, a response process676, a summary model process 680, and a packet selection process 684.

The presentation process 670 can, in some embodiments, include one orseveral method and/or steps to deliver content to one or severalendpoint devices 106 and/or administrator devices 110. The presentationprocess 670 can be performed by a presenter module 672 and a view module674. The presenter module 672 can be a hardware or software module ofthe content access network 100, and specifically of the server 102. Insome embodiments, the presenter module 672 can include one or severalportions, features, and/or functionalities that are located on theserver 102 and/or one or several portions, features, and/orfunctionalities that are located on the endpoint device 106. In someembodiments, the presenter module 672 can be embodied in thepresentation system 408.

The presenter module 672 can control the providing of content to one orseveral endpoint devices 106 and/or administrator devices 110.Specifically, the presenter module 672 can control the generation of oneor several messages to provide content to one or several correctendpoint devices 106 and/or administrator devices 110. The presentermodule 672 can further control the providing of these one or severalmessages to the correct one or several correct endpoint devices 106and/or administrator devices 110. Thus, in some embodiments, thepresenter module 672 can control one or several features of thecommunications subsystem 532 to generate and send one or severalelectrical signals comprising content to one or several endpoint devices106 and/or administrator devices 110.

In some embodiments, the presenter module 672 can control and/or managea portion of the presentation functions of the presentation process 670,and can specifically manage an “outer loop” of presentation functions.As used herein, the outer loop refers to operations relating to thetracking of an endpoint's progress through all or a portion of a groupof data packets. In some embodiments, this can include theidentification of one or several completed data packets or nodes and/orthe non-adaptive selection of one or several next data packets or nodesaccording to, for example, one or several fixed rules. Such non-adaptiveselection does not rely on the use of predictive models, but rather onrules identifying next data packets based on data relating to thecompletion of one or several previously completed data packets orassessments and/or whether one or several previously completed datapackets were successfully completed.

In some embodiments, and due to the management of the outer loop ofpresentation functions including the non-adaptive selection of one orseveral next data packets, nodes, or operations by the presenter module,the presenter module can function as a recommendation engine referred toherein as a first recommendation engine or a rules-based recommendationengine. In some embodiments, the first recommendation engine can beconfigured to select a next node for an endpoint based on one or all of:the endpoint's current location in the content network; potential nextnodes; the endpoint's history including the endpoint's previousresponses; and one or several guard conditions associated with thepotential next nodes. In some embodiments, a guard condition defines oneor several prerequisites for entry into, or exit from, a node.

In some embodiments, the presenter module 672 can include a portionlocated on the server 102 and/or a portion located on the endpointdevice 106. In some embodiments, the portion of the presenter module 672located on the server 102 can receive data packet data and provide asubset of the received data packet data to the portion of the presentermodule 672 located on the endpoint device 106. In some embodiments, thissegregation of functions and/or capabilities can prevent solution datafrom being located on the endpoint device 106 and from being potentiallyaccessible by the endpoint of the endpoint device 106.

In some embodiments, the portion of the presenter module 672 located onthe endpoint device 106 can be further configured to receive the subsetof the data packet data from the portion of the presenter module 672located on the server 102 and provide that subset of the data packetdata to the view module 674. In some embodiments, the portion of thepresenter module 672 located on the endpoint device 106 can be furtherconfigured to receive a content request from the view module 674 and toprovide that content request to the portion of the presenter module 674located on the server 102.

The view module 674 can be a hardware or software module of some or allof the endpoint devices 106 and/or administrator devices 110 of thecontent access network 100. The view module 674 can receive one orseveral electrical signals and/or communications from the presentermodule 672 and can provide the content received in those one or severalelectrical signals and/or communications to the endpoint of the endpointdevice 106 and/or administrator device 110 via, for example, the I/Osubsystem 526.

In some embodiments, the view module 674 can control and/or monitor an“inner loop” of presentation functions. As used herein, the inner looprefers to operations relating to the tracking and/or management of anendpoint's progress through a data packet. This can specifically relateto the tracking and/or management of an endpoint's progression throughone or several pieces of content, queries, assessments, and/or the likeof a data packet. In some embodiments, this can further include theselection of one or several next pieces of content, next queries, nextassessments, and/or the like of the data packet for presentation and/orproviding to the endpoint of the endpoint device 106.

In some embodiments, one or both of the presenter module 672 and theview module 674 can comprise one or several presentation engines. Insome embodiments, these one or several presentation engines can comprisedifferent capabilities and/or functions. In some embodiments, one of thepresentation engines can be configured to track the progress of anendpoint through a single data packet, operation, content object, or thelike, and in some embodiments, one of the presentation engines can trackthe progress of an endpoint through a series of data packets,operations, content objects, or the like.

The response process 676 can comprise one or several methods and/orsteps to analyze a response. In some embodiments, this can include, forexample, determining whether the response comprises a correct responseand/or an incorrect response. In some embodiments, the response process676 can include one or several methods and/or steps to determine thecorrectness and/or incorrectness of one or several received responses.In some embodiments, this can include, for example, determining thecorrectness and/or incorrectness of a multiple choice response, atrue/false response, a short answer response, an essay response, or thelike. In some embodiments, the response processor can employ, forexample, natural language processing, semantic analysis, or the like indetermining the correctness or incorrectness of the received responses.

In some embodiments, the response process 676 can be performed by aresponse processor 678. The response processor 678 can be a hardware orsoftware module of the content access network 100, and specifically ofthe server 102. In some embodiments, the response processor 678 can beembodied in the response system 406. In some embodiments, the responseprocessor 678 can be communicatively connected to one or more of themodules of the presentation process 670 such as, for example, thepresenter module 672 and/or the view module 674. In some embodiments,the response processor 678 can be communicatively connected with, forexample, the message channel 412 and/or other components and/or modulesof the content access network 100.

The summary model process 680 can comprise one or several methods and/orsteps to generate and/or update one or several models. In someembodiments, this can include, for example, implementing data receivedeither directly or indirectly from the response processor 678 to updateone or several models. In some embodiments, the summary model process680 can include the update of a model relating to one or severalendpoint attributes such as, for example, an endpoint performance model,an endpoint knowledge model, a development style model, or the like. Insome embodiments, the summary model process 680 can include the updateof a model relating to one or several content attributes includingattributes relating to a single content object and/or data packet and/orattributes relating to a plurality of content objects and/or datapackets. In some embodiments, these models can relate to an attribute ofthe one or several data packets such as, for example, difficulty,discrimination, required time, or the like.

In some embodiments, the summary model process 680 can be performed bythe model engine 682. In some embodiments, the model engine 682 can be ahardware or software module of the content access network 100, andspecifically of the server 102. In some embodiments, the model engine682 can be embodied in the summary model system 404.

In some embodiments, the model engine 682 can be communicativelyconnected to one or more of the modules of the presentation process 760such as, for example, the presenter module 672 and/or the view module674, can be connected to the response processor 678 and/or therecommendation. In some embodiments, the model engine 682 can becommunicatively connected to the message channel 412 and/or othercomponents and/or modules of the content access network 100.

The packet selection process 684 can comprise one or several stepsand/or methods to identify and/or select a data packet for presentationto an endpoint. In some embodiments, this data packet can comprise aplurality of data packets. In some embodiments, this data packet can beselected according to one or several models updated as part of thesummary model process 680. In some embodiments, this data packet can beselected according to one or several rules, probabilities, models, orthe like. In some embodiments, the one or several data packets can beselected by the combination of a plurality of models updated in thesummary model process 680 by the model engine 682. In some embodiments,these one or several data packets can be selected by a recommendationengine 686. The recommendation engine 686 can be a hardware or softwaremodule of the content access network 100, and specifically of the server102. In some embodiments, the recommendation engine 686 can be embodiedin the packet selection system 402. In some embodiments, therecommendation engine 686 can be communicatively connected to one ormore of the modules of the presentation process 670, the responseprocess 676, and/or the summary model process 680 either directly and/orindirectly via, for example, the message channel.

In some embodiments, and as depicted in FIG. 9, a presenter module 672can receive a data packet for presentation to an endpoint device 106.This data packet can be received, either directly or indirectly, from arecommendation engine 686. In some embodiments, for example, thepresenter module 672 can receive a data packet for providing to anendpoint device 106 from the recommendation engine 686, and in someembodiments, the presenter module 672 can receive an identifier of adata packet for providing to an endpoint device 106 via a view module674. This can be received from the recommendation engine 686 via amessage channel 412. Specifically, in some embodiments, therecommendation engine 686 can provide data to the message channel 412indicating the identification and/or selection of a data packet forproviding to an endpoint via an endpoint device 106. In someembodiments, this data indicating the identification and/or selection ofthe data packet can identify the data packet and/or can identify theintended recipient of the data packet.

The message channel 412 can output this received data in the form of adata stream 690 which can be received by, for example, the presentermodule 672, the model engine 682, and/or the recommendation engine 686.In some embodiments, some or all of: the presenter module 672, the modelengine 682, and/or the recommendation engine 686 can be configured toparse and/or filter the data stream 690 to identify data and/or eventsgermane to their operation. Thus, for example, the presenter module 672can be configured to parse the data stream for data and/or eventsgermane to the operation of the presenter module 672.

In some embodiments, the presenter module 672 can, extract the datapacket from the data stream 690 and/or extract data identifying the datapacket and/or indicating the selecting of a data packet from the datastream. In the event that data identifying the data packet is extractedfrom the data stream 690, the presenter module 672 can request andreceive the data packet from the data storage server 104, andspecifically from the content object data storage 303. In embodiments inwhich data indicating the selection of a data packet is extracted fromthe data stream 690, the presenter module 672 can request and receiveidentification of the data packet from the recommendation engine 686 andthen request and receive the data packet from the data storage server104, and specifically from the content object data storage 303, and insome embodiments in which data indicating the selection of a data packetis extracted from the data stream 690, the presenter module 672 canrequest and receive the data packet from the recommendation engine 686.

The presenter module can then, provide the data packet and/or portionsof the data packet to the view module 674. In some embodiments, forexample, the presenter module 672 can retrieve one or several rulesand/or conditions that can be, for example, associated with the datapacket and/or stored in the data storage server 104. In someembodiments, these rules and/or conditions can identify portions of adata packet for providing to the view module 674 and/or portions of adata packet to not provide to the view module 674. In some embodiments,for example, sensitive portions of a data packet, such as, for example,solution data to any queries associated with a data packet, is notprovided to the view module 674 to prevent the possibility of incorrectaccess to those sensitive portions of the data packet. Thus, in someembodiments, the one or several rules and/or conditions can identifyportions of the data packet for providing to the view module 674 and/orportions of the data packet for not providing to the view module.

In some embodiments, the presenter module 672 can, according to the oneor more rules and/or conditions, generate and transmit an electronicmessage containing all or portions of the data packet to the view module674. The view module 674 can receive these all or portions of the datapacket and can provide all or portions of this data to the endpoint ofthe endpoint device 106 associated with the view module 674 via, forexample, the I/O subsystem 526. In some embodiments, as part of theproviding of all or portions of the data packet to the endpoint of theview module 674, one or several endpoint responses can be received bythe view module 674. In some embodiments, these one or several endpointresponses can be received via the I/0 subsystem 526 of the endpointdevice 106.

After one or several endpoint responses have been received, the viewmodule 674 can provide the one or several endpoint responses to theresponse processor 678. In some embodiments, these one or severalresponses can be directly provided to the response processor 678, and insome embodiments, these one or several responses can be providedindirectly to the response processor 678 via the message channel 412.

After the response processor 678 receives the one or several responses,the response processor 678 can determine whether the responses arecorrect responses and/or the degree to which the received responses arecorrect responses. In some embodiments, the response processor can makethis determination via, for example, use of one or several techniques,including, for example, natural language processing (NLP), semanticanalysis, or the like.

In some embodiments, the response processor can determine whether aresponse is a correct response and/or the degree to which a response isa correct response with comparative data which can be associated withthe data packet. In some embodiments, this comparative data cancomprise, for example, an indication of a correct response and/or anindication of one or several incorrect responses, a response key, aresponse rubric comprising one or several criterion for determining thedegree to which a response is a correct response, or the like. In someembodiments, the comparative data can be received as a portion of and/orassociated with a data packet. In some embodiments, the comparative datacan be received by the response processor 678 from the presenter module672 and/or from the message channel 412. In some embodiments, theresponse data received from the view module 674 can comprise dataidentifying the endpoint and/or the data packet or portion of the datapacket with which the response is associated. In some embodiments inwhich the response processor 678 merely receives data identifying thedata packet and/or portion of the data packet associated with the one orseveral responses, the response processor 678 can request and/or receivecomparative data from the data storage server 104, and specifically fromthe content object data storage 303 of the data storage server 104.

After the comparative data has been received, the response processor 678determines whether the one or several responses comprise correctresponses and/or the degree to which the one or several responsescomprise correct responses. The response processor can then provide thedata characterizing whether the one or several responses comprisescorrect responses and/or the degree to which the one or severalresponses comprise correct responses to the message channel 412. Themessage channel can, as discussed above, include the output of theresponse processor 678 in the data stream 690 which can be constantlyoutput by the message channel 412.

In some embodiments, the model engine 682 can subscribe to the datastream 690 of the message channel 412 and can thus receive the datastream 690 of the message channel 412 as indicated in FIG. 9. The modelengine 682 can monitor the data stream 690 to identify data and/orevents germane to the operation of the model engine. In someembodiments, the model engine 682 can monitor the data stream 690 toidentify data and/or events germane to the determination of whether aresponse is a correct response and/or the degree to which a response isa correct response.

When a germane event and/or germane data is identified by the modelengine, the model engine 682 can take the identified germane eventand/or germane data and modify one or several models. In someembodiments, this can include updating and/or modifying one or severalmodels germane to the endpoint who provided the responses, updatingand/or modifying one or several models germane to the data packetassociated with the responses, and/or the like. In some embodiments,these models can be retrieved from the data storage server 104, and insome embodiments, can be retrieved from the model data source 307 of thedata storage server 104.

After the models have been updated, the updated models can be stored inthe data storage server 104. In some embodiments, the model engine 682can send data indicative of the event of the completion of the modelupdate to the message channel 412. The message channel 412 canincorporate this data into the data stream 690 which can be received bythe recommendation engine 686. The recommendation engine 686 can monitorthe data stream 690 to identify data and/or events germane to theoperation of the recommendation engine 686. In some embodiments, therecommendation engine 686 can monitor the data stream 690 to identifydata and/or events germane to the updating of one or several models bythe model engine 682.

When the recommendation engine 686 identifies data in the data stream690 indicating the completion of the summary model process 680 formodels germane to the endpoint providing the response and/or for modelsgermane to the data packet provided to the endpoint, the recommendationengine 686 can identify and/or select a next data packet for providingto the endpoint and/or to the presentation process 470. In someembodiments, this selection of the next data packet can be performedaccording to one or several rules and/or conditions. After the next datapacket has been selected, the recommendation engine 686 can provide datato the model engine 682 identifying the next selected data packet and/orto the message channel 412 indicating the event of the selection of thenext content object. After the message channel 412 receives dataidentifying the selection of the next content object and/or receives thenext content object, the message channel 412 can include this data inthe data stream 690 and the process discussed with respect to FIG. 9 canbe repeated.

With reference now to FIG. 10, a schematic illustration of a secondembodiment of communication or processing that can be in the platformlayer 654 and/or applications layer 656 via the message channel 412 isshown. In the embodiment depicted in FIG. 10, the data packet providedto the presenter module 672 and then to the view module 674 does notinclude a prompt for an endpoint response and/or does not result in thereceipt of an endpoint response. As no response is received, when thedata packet is completed, nothing is provided to the response processor678, but rather data indicating the completion of the data packet isprovided from one of the view module 674 and/or the presenter module 672to the message channel 412. The data is then included in the data stream690 and is received by the model engine 682 which uses the data toupdate one or several models. After the model engine 682 has updated theone or several models, the model engine 682 provides data indicating thecompletion of the model updates to the message channel 412. The messagechannel 412 then includes the data indicating the completion of themodel updates in the data stream 690 and the recommendation engine 686,which can subscribe to the data stream 690, can extract the dataindicating the completion of the model updates from the data stream 690.The recommendation engine 686 can then identify a next one or severaldata packets for providing to the presenter module 672, and therecommendation engine 686 can then, either directly or indirectly,provide the next one or several data packets to the presenter module672.

With reference now to FIG. 11, a schematic illustration of an embodimentof dual communication, or hybrid communication, in the platform layer654 and/or applications layer 656 is shown. Specifically, in thisembodiment, some communication is synchronous with the completion of oneor several operations and some communication is asynchronous. Thus, inthe embodiment depicted in FIG. 11, the presenter module 672communicates synchronously with the model engine 682 via a directcommunication 692 and communicates asynchronously with the model engine682 via the message channel 412.

Specifically, and with reference to FIG. 11, the presenter module 672can receive and/or select a data packet for presentation to the endpointdevice 106 via the view module 674. In some embodiments, the presentermodule 672 can identify all or portions of the data packet that can beprovided to the view module 674 and portions of the data packet forretaining form the view module 674. In some embodiments, the presentermodule can provide all or portions of the data packet to the view module674. In some embodiments, and in response to the receipt of all orportions of the data packet, the view module 674 can provide aconfirmation of receipt of the all or portions of the data packet andcan provide those all or portions of the data packet to the endpoint viathe endpoint device 106. In some embodiments, the view module 674 canprovide those all or portions of the data packet to the endpoint device106 while controlling the inner loop of the presentation of the datapacket to the endpoint via the endpoint device 106.

After those all or portions of the data packet have been provided to theendpoint device 106, a response indicative of the completion of one orseveral operations associated with the data packet can be received bythe view module 674 from the endpoint device 106, and specifically fromthe I/O subsystem 526 of the endpoint device 106. In response to thisreceive, the view module 674 can provide an indication of thiscompletion status to the presenter module 672 and/or can provide theresponse to the response processor 678.

After the response has been received by the response processor 678, theresponse processor 678 can determine whether the received response is acorrect response. In some embodiments, this can include, for example,determining whether the response comprises a correct answer and/or thedegree to which the response comprises a correct answer.

After the response processor has determined whether the receivedresponse is a correct response, the response processor 678 can providean indicator of the result of the determination of whether the receivedresponse is a correct response to the presenter module 672. In responseto the receipt of the indicator of whether the result of thedetermination of whether the received response is a correct response,the presenter module 672 can synchronously communicate with the modelengine 682 via a direct communication 692 and can asynchronouslycommunicate with model engine 682 via the message channel 412. In someembodiments, the synchronous communication can advantageously includetwo-way communication between the model engine 682 and the presentermodule 672 such that the model engine 682 can provide an indication tothe presenter module 672 when model updating is completed by the modelengine.

After the model engine 682 has received one or both of the synchronousand asynchronous communications, the model engine 682 can update one orseveral models relating to, for example, the endpoint, the data packet,or the like. After the model engine 682 has completed the updating ofthe one or several models, the model engine 682 can send a communicationto the presenter module 672 indicating the completion of the updated oneor several modules.

After the presenter module 672 receives the communication indicating thecompletion of the updating of the one or several models, the presentermodule 672 can send a communication to the recommendation engine 686requesting identification of a next data packet. As discussed above, therecommendation engine 686 can then retrieve the updated model andretrieve the endpoint data. With the updated models and the endpointdata, the recommendation engine can identify a next data packet forproviding to the endpoint, and can provide the data packet to thepresenter module 672. In some embodiments, the recommendation engine 686can further provide an indication of the next data packet to the modelengine 682, which can use this data relating to the next data packet toupdate one or several models, either intermediately, or after receivinga communication from the presenter module 672 subsequent to thedetermination of whether a received response for that data packet is acorrect response.

With reference now to FIG. 12, a schematic illustration of oneembodiment of the presentation process 670 is shown. Specifically, FIG.12 depicts multiple portions of the presenter module 672, namely, theexternal portion 673 and the internal portion 675. In some embodiments,the external portion 673 of the presenter module 672 can be located inthe server, and in some embodiments, the internal portion 675 of thepresenter module 672 can be located in the endpoint device 106. In someembodiments, the external portion 673 of the presenter module can beconfigured to communicate and/or exchange data with the internal portion675 of the presenter module 672 as discussed herein. In someembodiments, for example, the external portion 673 of the presentermodule 672 can receive a data packet and can parse the data packet intoportions for providing to the internal portion 675 of the presentermodule 672 and portions for not providing to the internal portion 675 ofthe presenter module 672. In some embodiments, the external portion 673of the presenter module 672 can receive a request for additional dataand/or an additional data packet from the internal portion 675 of thepresenter module 672. In such an embodiment, the external portion 673 ofthe presenter module 672 can identify and retrieve the requested dataand/or the additional data packet from, for example, the data storageserver 104 and more specifically from the content access data storage304.

With reference now to FIG. 13, a flowchart illustrating one embodimentof a process 440 for data management is shown. In some embodiments, theprocess 440 can be performed by the content management server 102, andmore specifically by the presentation system 408 and/or by thepresentation module or presentation engine. In some embodiments, theprocess 440 can be performed as part of the presentation process 670.

The process 440 begins at block 442, wherein a data packet isidentified. In some embodiments, the data packet can be a data packetfor providing to a particular-endpoint. In some embodiments, the datapacket can be identified based on a communication received eitherdirectly or indirectly from the recommendation engine 686.

After the data packet has been identified, the process 440 may proceedto block 444, wherein the data packet is requested. In some embodiments,this can include the requesting of data relating to the data packet suchas the data forming the data packet. In some embodiments, this data canbe requested from, for example, the content object data storage 303.After the data packet has been requested, the process 440 may proceed toblock 446, wherein the data packet is received. In some embodiments, thedata packet can be received by the presentation system 408 from, forexample, the content object data storage 303.

After the data packet has been received, the process 440 may proceed toblock 448, wherein one or several data components are identified. Insome embodiments, for example, the data packet can include one orseveral data components which can, for example, contain different data.In some embodiments, one of these data components, referred to herein asa presentation component, can include content for providing to theendpoint, which content can include one or several requests and/orqueries and/or the like. In some embodiments, one of these datacomponents, referred to herein as a response component, can include dataused in evaluating one or several responses received from the endpointdevice 106 in response to the data packet, and specifically in responseto the presentation component and/or the one or several requests and/orqueries of the presentation component. Thus, in some embodiments, theresponse component of the data packet can be used to ascertain whetherthe endpoint has provided a correct response or an incorrect response.

After the data components have been identified, the process 440 mayproceed to block 450, wherein a delivery data packet is identified. Insome embodiments, the delivery data packet can include the one orseveral data components of the data packets for delivery to an endpointsuch as the endpoint via the endpoint device 106. In some embodiments,the delivery packet can include the presentation component, and in someembodiments, the delivery packet can exclude the response packet. Afterthe delivery data packet has been created, the process 440 may proceedto block 452, wherein the delivery data packet is provided to theendpoint device 106 and more specifically to the view module 674. Insome embodiments, this can include providing the delivery data packet tothe endpoint device 106 via, for example, the communication network 120.

After the delivery data packet has been provided to the endpoint device106, the process 440 may proceed to block 454, wherein the data packetand/or one or several components thereof is sent to and/or provided tothe response processor 678. In some embodiments, this sending of thedata packet and/or one or several components thereof to the responseprocessor can include receiving a response from the endpoint, andsending the response to the endpoint to the response processorsimultaneous with the sending of the data packet and/or one or severalcomponents thereof to the response processor. In some embodiments, forexample, this can include providing the response component to theresponse processor. In some embodiments, the response component can beprovided to the response processor from the presentation system 408.

With reference now to FIG. 14, a flowchart illustrating one embodimentof a process 460 for evaluating a response is shown. In someembodiments, the process can be performed as a part of the responseprocess 676 and can be performed by, for example, the response system406 and/or by the response processor 678. In some embodiments, theprocess 460 can be performed by the response system 406 in response tothe receipt of a response, either directly or indirectly, from theendpoint device 106 or from the view module 674.

The process 460 begins at block 462, wherein a response is receivedfrom, for example, the endpoint device 106 via, for example, thecommunication network 120. After the response has been received, theprocess 460 may proceed to block 464, wherein the data packet associatedwith the response is received. In some embodiments, this can includereceiving all or one or several components of the data packet such as,for example, the response component of the data packet. In someembodiments, the data packet can be received by the response processorfrom the presentation engine.

After the data packet has been received, the process 460 may proceed toblock 466, wherein the response type is identified. In some embodiments,this identification can be performed based on data, such as metadataassociated with the response. In other embodiments, this identificationcan be performed based on data packet data such as the responsecomponent.

In some embodiments, the response type can identify one or severalattributes of the one or several requests and/or queries of the datapacket such as, for example, the request and/or query type. In someembodiments, this can include identifying some or all of the one orseveral requests and/or queries as true/false, multiple choice, shortanswer, essay, or the like.

After the response type has been identified, the process 460 may proceedto block 468, wherein the data packet and the response are compared todetermine whether the response comprises a correct response and/or anincorrect response. In some embodiments, this can include comparing thereceived response and the data packet to determine if the receivedresponse matches all or portions of the response component of the datapacket, to determine the degree to which the received response matchesall or portions of the response component, to determine the degree towhich the received response embodies one or several qualities identifiedin the response component of the data packet, or the like. In someembodiments, this can include classifying the response according to oneor several rules. In some embodiments, these rules can be used toclassify the response as either correct or incorrect. In someembodiments, these rules can be used to identify one or several errorsand/or misconceptions evidenced in the response. In some embodiments,this can include, for example: use of natural language processingsoftware and/or algorithms; use of one or several digital thesauruses;use of lemmatization software, dictionaries, and/or algorithms; or thelike.

After the data packet and the response have been compared, the process460 may proceed to block 470 wherein response desirability isdetermined. In some embodiments this can include, based on the result ofthe comparison of the data packet and the response, whether the responseis a correct response or is an incorrect response. In some embodiments,this can further include quantifying the degree to which the response isa correct response. This determination can include, for example,determining if the response is a correct response, an incorrectresponse, a partially correct response, or the like. In someembodiments, the determination of response desirability can include thegeneration of a value characterizing the response desirability and thestoring of this value in one of the data storages 104 such as, forexample, the endpoint specification data storage 301. After the responsedesirability has been determined, the process 460 may proceed to block472, wherein an assessment value is created. In some embodiments, theassessment value can be an aggregate value characterizing responsedesirability for one or more of a plurality of responses. Thisassessment value can be stored in one of the data storages 104 such asthe endpoint specification data storage 301.

In some embodiments, content provisioning performed in accordance withthe processes of FIGS. 11 through 14 can provide significant benefitsover current content provisioning with a computer, especially overcurrent content provisioning with a computer in an developmentenvironment. In some embodiments, content provisioning as described inFIGS. 11 through 14 can be based on real-time and dynamic prioritizationthat can be based on models of one or several endpoint attributes suchas endpoint performance level, models of one or several operationattributes, such as operation difficulty levels, or the like. Thisprovides the significant benefit of accurately selecting content mostsuited for delivery which increases the efficiency with which content isprovided to the endpoint.

As disclosed herein, embodiments according to the present disclosureprovide technological solutions to multiple problems existing withconventional systems and approaches. Conventional systems and approachesare deficient in providing access to system resources and performancetesting and development resources. Conventional systems and approachesmay provide access with insufficient or no protection of authenticationintegrity and insufficient or no measures to address or remediate a lackof authentication integrity. The technical improvements provided bydisclosed embodiments include improvements in accuracy ofauthentication, speed, timeliness, adaptability, sensitivity, andresponsiveness in authentication by way of adaptive authentication thatis based at least in part on a learned endpoint patterns and causingreal-time activation adjustments and enhanced authentication measureswhen endpoint attributes detected in real-time do not conform to thepatterns, in order to capture additional data to identify fraud, developthe learned pattern, lock down or otherwise prohibit access toresources, alert administratory devices, and/or the like disclosedherein. Further, among other things, the technical improvements providedby disclosed embodiments solve problems associated with adaptive systemsand multiplicities of sensor data being extremely computing-resourceintensive—which is especially problematic at scale when simultaneouslyhosting services for many user devices. While processing sensor-baseddata from a multiplicity of sensors is extremely computing-resourceintense, disclosed embodiments with selective, multi-stageauthentication can require significantly fewer computing resources thanotherwise, reduce latency, and increase operational speed to providefaster access at scale to manifold endpoint devices. Such selective useof various sensor-based means of authentication can requiresignificantly fewer resources to traverse user devices through a networkof nodes while performing adaptive authentication operations asdisclosed herein. As such, the disclosed solutions will more quickly andsmoothly perform the specific operations, while the system will,especially from the perspective of multiple endpoints, operatesignificantly faster than otherwise. Various embodiments disclosedherein perform adaptive authentication based at least in part on alearned pattern of activity of the endpoint and sensorthrottling/adjustment when detected endpoint activity does not conformto the pattern, in order to capture additional data to identify fraudand/or develop the learned pattern. Various embodiments disclosed hereinperform adaptive authentication based at least in part on intelligentrisk/authentication scoring of a particular endpoint that takes intoaccount different detected phenomena and situations and weights thosefactors differently in order to accurately characterize the risk andneed for enhanced authentication. Various embodiments disclosed hereinperform adaptive authentication that is a function of arisk/authentication score and that performs appropriate multi-stage,multi-modal authentication depending on the authentication score.Various embodiments disclosed herein perform adaptive authentication atscale with multiplicities of endpoints, where multi-endpoint-basedadaptive authentication detects a colocation situation of multipleendpoints and handles authentication based on the multiplicity. Suchembodiments are described further in the following.

FIG. 15 illustrates a subsystem 100-1 to facilitate adaptively securinga set of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources, in accordance with various embodiments of the presentdisclosure. While the subsystem 100-1 is illustrated as being composedof multiple components, it should be understood that the subsystem 100-1may be broken into a greater number of components or collapsed intofewer components. Each component may include any one or combination ofcomputerized hardware, software, and/or firmware. In variousembodiments, the subsystem 100-1 includes one or more adaptiveprocessing and controlling devices 500-1, which may be implemented withone or a combination of devices 102, 114, 116, 104, 106, 108, and/or 110in various embodiments.

The one or more adaptive processing and controlling devices 500-1 (oftenreferenced herein as one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1) maybe configured to cause a number of adjustments in the subsystem 100-1 asdisclosed herein. The one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1 maybe communicatively coupled with interface components and communicationchannels (which may take various forms in various embodiments asdisclosed herein) configured to receive authentication input 540. Theauthentication input 540 may include input from a plurality of differentdata sources. The technical improvements provided by the subsystem 100-1over prior technologies include improvements in authentication accuracyand adaptability at least in part by machine-intelligent handling inputfrom multiple different sources, including sensors, endpoints, and othersource input in order to adapt to various particular technicalenvironments in various distinct endpoints, as is disclosed furtherherein.

As depicted, the authentication input 540 may include sensor data 208A.The subsystem 100-1 may process sensor data 208A and analyze the sensordata 208A to provide for features disclosed further herein. The sensordata 208A may be captured by any or combination of the sensors/detectors208 disclosed herein. The authentication input 540 may include endpointdevice input 106A that may include input from one or more endpointdevices 106. The authentication input 540 may include other source input110A, which could correspond to input from one or more other sourcesthat may include input from an administrator device 110 and/or anysuitable data source, which could be network-accessible. The one or moreadaptive processing devices 500-1 may include a monitoring engine 521.The monitoring engine 521 may be configured to monitor theauthentication input 540 for any suitable aspects pertaining toendpoints to facilitate improvements with individualization adaptationfeatures disclosed herein. For example, the monitoring engine 521 mayprocess information enabling identification of endpoints and individualstates.

FIG. 15A illustrates certain aspects of adaptive data processing andcontrol flow 700, in accordance with various embodiments of the presentdisclosure. The one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1 may beconfigured to gather authentication input 540 as disclosed herein, andmay gather the authentication input 540 via data acquisitioninterface(s) 702. In various embodiments, the authentication input 540from the one or more data sources may be retrieved and/or received bythe one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1 via the one or moredata acquisition interface(s) 702, which may include interfaces of theone or more adaptive processing devices 500-1, components of thesubsystem 100-1 and the system 100, and/or the like—through network(s)120, through any suitable means for direct communication, and/or throughany other suitable means of transferring data. According to disclosedembodiments, data pulled and/or pushed from the one or more data sourcesmay be transformed and the transformed data and/or other data generatedbased thereon may be made available by the one or more adaptiveprocessing devices 500-1.

In some embodiments, the one or more data acquisition interface(s) 702may include one or more application programming interfaces (APIs) thatdefine protocols and routines for interfacing with the data sources(e.g., sensors, computing devices, communication devices, wearabledevices, remote data sources, and/or the like). The APIs may specifyapplication programming interface (API) calls to/from data sourcecomponents and/or systems. In some embodiments, the APIs may include aplug-in to integrate with an application of a data components and/orsystems. The one or more data acquisition interfaces 702, in someembodiments, could use a number of API translation profiles configuredto allow interface with the one or more additional applications of thedata sources to access data (e.g., a database or other data store) ofthe data sources. The API translation profiles may translate theprotocols and routines of the data source component and/or system tointegrate at least temporarily with the system and allow communicationwith the system (one-way communication to the system and/or two-waycommunication with system in various embodiments) by way of API calls.Data, as referenced herein, may correspond to any one or combination ofraw data, unstructured data, structured data, information, and/orcontent which may include media content, text, documents, files,instructions, code, executable files, images, video, audio, and/or anyother suitable content suitable for embodiments of the presentdisclosure.

The authentication input 540 may include device identification data 704,such as data to facilitate detection, recognition, and differentiationof any one or combination of types of endpoint devices and components.For instance, the device identification data 704 may include indicia ofsmart phones, tablets, wearable computing/communication devices, othercomputing devices, electronic wallets, electronic tokens, authenticationcodes (e.g., key codes entered with an input device), and/or the like.The authentication input 540 may include biometric identification data706, such as any data to facilitate one or combination of fingerprintrecognition, facial recognition, audio recognition, optical recognition,heat recognition, infrared recognition, and/or the like. Theauthentication input 540 may include action data 708, such as any datato facilitate detection, recognition, and differentiation of one orcombination of types of movements, directions of movements, speeds ofmovements, device use, voice data, performance recognition, explicituser input, and/or the like. The authentication input 540 may includelocation data 710, such as any data to facilitate detection,recognition, and differentiation of one or combination of locations. Forinstance, the location data 710 may include data about approvedlocations of endpoint devices, colocations of endpoint devices, changesin locations of endpoint devices, and/or the like. The authenticationinput 540 may include temporal data 712, such as any data to facilitatedetection, recognition, and differentiation of one or combination oftemporal factors that may bear on, and enhance, authentication featuresdisclosed herein. For instance, the temporal data 712 may include timeof day data, time of week data, time of year data, time on task data,state-based timing data, transition timing data, and/or the like. Theauthentication input 540 may include contextual data 714, such as anydata to facilitate detection, recognition, and differentiation of one orcombination of contextual factors that may bear on, and enhance,authentication features disclosed herein. For instance, the contextualdata 714 may include data about numbers of endpoint devicescorresponding to a certain location and/or a certain set of operations,types of endpoint devices, endpoint colocations, ambient or baselineaudio data, ambient or baseline video data, and/or the like.

The monitoring engine 521 of FIG. 15 may be configured to monitor deviceidentification data 704, biometric identification data 706, action data708, location data 710, temporal data 712, contextual data 714, and/orthe like. The one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1 may includea matching engine 507 that may be an analysis engine. The matchingengine 507 may be configured to perform any one or combination offeatures directed to matching or otherwise correlating information aboutendpoints, device identification data 704, biometric identification data706, action data 708, location data 710, temporal data 712, contextualdata 714, and/or the like. In some embodiments, the monitoring engine521 and/or the matching engine 507 may facilitate one or morelearning/training modes disclosed herein.

The monitoring engine 521 may gather and process authentication input540 to facilitate creation, development, and/or use of endpointspecifications, including activity endpoint specifications, categories,and/or rules. The data may include any suitable data that may becaptured to indicate, infer, and/or determine endpoint identification,actions, locations, temporal factors, contexts, and patterns for anendpoint. The captured data may be aggregated, consolidated, andtransformed into endpoint specifications. For example, in someembodiments, the matching engine 507 may determine endpointcharacteristics based at least in part on authentication input 540received and processed by the monitoring engine 521. The matching engine507 may define attributes of an endpoint sensed based at least in parton the individual characteristics. The technical improvements providedby the subsystem 100-1 include improvements in accuracy, speed,timeliness, adaptability, sensitivity, and responsiveness inauthentication by way of adaptive authentication that is based at leastin part on a learned endpoint patterns and causing real-time activationadjustments and enhanced authentication measures when endpointattributes detected in real-time do not conform to the patterns, inorder to capture additional data to identify fraud and/or develop thelearned pattern, as disclosed further herein.

In various embodiments, the matching engine 507 may generate, develop,and/or otherwise use endpoint specifications, activity endpointspecifications, categories, and/or rules for endpoints sensed and/or forlocations based at least in part on authentication input 540. Thematching engine 507 may, for example, correlate items of deviceidentification data 704, biometric identification data 706, action data708, location data 710, temporal data 712, contextual data 714, and/orthe like. The monitoring engine 521 may compile any one or combinationof such data to create, based at least in part on machine-learning,pattern data that may include pattern particulars to facilitatedetection, recognition, and differentiation of endpoint patterns basedat least in part on device identification data 704, biometricidentification data 706, action data 708, location data 710, temporaldata 712, contextual data 714, and/or the like. The matching engine 507may include a reasoning module to make logical inferences from a set ofthe detected and differentiated data to infer one or more patterns ofactivity for particular endpoints and/or for aspects in the proximity ofthe endpoint devices. For instance, the pattern data may includeinformation about any one or combination of identification histories,action histories, location histories, temporal histories, and/or thelike, any set of which may be used to derive one or more patterns ofactivity for particular endpoints and/or for aspects in the proximity ofthe endpoint devices. A pattern-based reasoner could be employed to usevarious statistical techniques in analyzing the data in order to makeinferences based on the analysis of the different types of sensor dataand performance data, both current and historical. A transitive reasonermay be employed to infer relationships from a set of relationshipsrelated to different types of sensor data and performance data.

The monitoring engine 521 and/or the matching engine 507 may employ anongoing learning mode to confirm, correct, and/or refine determinationsmade for the endpoint specifications, including activity endpointspecifications, categories, and/or rules, for endpoints and proximateconditions sensed. For example, having come to one or more conclusionsabout endpoints and/or conditions sensed, the one or more adaptiveprocessing devices 500-1 may confirm and/or correct the determinationswith feedback loop features. Certain embodiments may provide the device110 with feedback options to facilitate the ongoing learning mode.User-selectable options (e.g., via a device interface, voice recognitionwith a microphone communicatively coupled with the device 110, etc.)provided with notifications (e.g., push notifications to device 110and/or the like) could be provided to allow administrative confirmationor correction of conditions detected. The feedback could be used fortraining the system to heuristically adapt conclusions, endpointspecifications, correlations, attributes, triggers, patterns, and/or thelike.

Each endpoint specification may be unique and may include baselineattributes for activity endpoint specifications, categories, and/orrules attributed to a particular endpoint. Subsequently detected datamay be used, in conjunction with previously detected data, to adjust anendpoint specification for the particular endpoint. For example,baseline detected biometric data, action data, location data, temporaldata, and/or contextual data may be attributed to, and/or used to refineattributes for, the endpoint with an initialization process, and one ormore subsequent detections may be compared to the baseline readingsand/or attributes to determine changes between the baselines and thesubsequent readings and/or attributes. Such differences may be used todevelop the endpoint specification for the particular endpoint.

Having endpoint specification which include distinctive characteristicsand attributes of each endpoint, the matching engine 507 mayindividually distinguish each endpoint, actions of the endpoint,locations corresponding to the actions, temporal aspects correspondingto the actions, and contexts corresponding to the action of the endpointwhen the monitoring engine 521 receives and processes data correspondingto the endpoint. The matching engine 507 may correlate captured deviceidentification data and/or biometric identification data to previouslycaptured and stored device identification data and/or biometricidentification data in order to identify an endpoint. The matchingengine 507 may be configured to match information for an endpointcaptured via the monitoring engine 521 to one or more patterns from aset of patterns. In some embodiments, the matching engine 507 canreceive sensor data corresponding to one or more endpoints, identifyattributes of the one or more endpoints based at least in part on thesensor data, and match the one or more endpoints to one or more patternsfrom a patterns information repository. Any suitable category may beemployed to facilitate adjustment features in accordance variousembodiments. Certain patterns disclosed herein may correspond tocharacterizations of endpoints.

The matching engine 507 could use facial recognition to match data foran endpoint to image data retained by the system (e.g., in the endpointspecifications) to determine whether a sensed endpoint is known or a newendpoint. Captured endpoint image data may be correlated to referenceimages using any suitable facial trait qualifications for correlation.The matching engine 507 may link particular endpoint image data toendpoint specifications with image data associated with endpoints, toidentify a known endpoint or a new endpoint (e.g., based at least inpart on satisfying one or more thresholds that may correspond to atolerance range of the extent of matching characteristics, in someembodiments). In various embodiments, the matching engine 507 may match(e.g., based at least in part on satisfying one or more thresholds thatmay correspond to a tolerance range of the extent of matchingcharacteristics, in some embodiments) any one or combination of types ofdevice identification data, biometric identification data, action data,location data, temporal data, contextual data, and/or pattern data todetermine and identify a status of an endpoint and/or to causeauthentication control in view of a particular endpoint.

The matching engine 507 may be configured to match information for input540 captured via the monitoring engine 521 to one or more categoriesfrom a set of categories. Some embodiments may qualify captured dataaccording to a graduated identification scale. Any suitableauthentication scale may be used in various embodiments. In someembodiments, an authentication scale could entail a categorizationscheme, with categories such as strong authentication of a particularendpoint, possible authentication of a particular endpoint, weakauthentication of a particular endpoint, and an unknown endpoint, or anysuitable categories such as other categories disclosed herein.

The rules may include authentication criteria for matching a set ofindicia of endpoint state to a set of one or more categories. In someembodiments, the rules may include criteria for matching captured datacorresponding to a detected endpoint to one or more operational settingsof one or more sensors. In some embodiments, the rules may include oneor more arbitration rules for handling situations of multiple endpoints.

The technical improvements provided by the subsystem 100-1 includeimprovements in accuracy, speed, timeliness, adaptability, sensitivity,and responsiveness in machine authentication based at least in part onadaptive authentication that is a function of machine-generatedauthentication scores and that performs appropriate multi-stage,multi-modal authentication in real-time depending on the authenticationscores. This can include multi-stage, multi-modal authentication wheremultiple stages of authentication with different types of sensors (e.g.,image-based, audio, keystroke) are intelligently triggered in differentways as a function of the authentication score. The one or more adaptiveprocessing devices 500-1 may include an adjustment engine 527 which maybe configured to cause one or more adjustments of authentication controlcomponents. The adjustment engine 527 may analyze input monitored by themonitoring engine 521, determinations of the matching engine 507, and/orinformation stored in the one or more data storages 104 to makeadjustment determinations. Based at least in part on one or moreadjustment determinations, the adjustment engine 527 may causeactivation of one or more adjustment actions of the authenticationcontrol components. As disclosed further herein, activation adjustments531 may include adjusting one or more times of one or more operations ofone or more sensors 209, adjusting one or more sampling rates of one ormore sensors 209, activating one or more sensors 209 of one or moredifferent types, generating one or more operational interrupts tointerrupt operations of an endpoint device, cause one or morenotifications to an administratory device, adjust one or more thresholdsfor endpoint characterization and/or triggering authenticationadjustments, and other adjustments disclosed herein.

FIG. 15B depicts certain aspects of a method 800 to adaptively secure aset of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources via authentication control based at least in part onindividualized authentication protocol, in accordance with embodimentsof the present disclosure. FIG. 15B and the subsequent figures depictvarious aspects of methods to adaptively secure a set of accessoperations with respect to one or more electronic resources (e.g., aspart of machine-facilitated development and/or testing), in accordancewith embodiments of the present disclosure. In various embodiments, oneor a combination of the aspects of the methods may be performed in wholeor in part by the adaptive authentication system 100. For example, thesubsystem 100-1, with the one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1,may be configured to perform one or a combination of the aspects of themethods. One or more non-transitory, computer-readable storage media maystore instructions which, when executed by the one or more adaptiveprocessing devices 500-1, cause the one or more adaptive processingdevices 500-1 to perform any one or combination of operations of themethods. It is noted that the methods may include additional operations,and that one or more of the operations disclosed herein may berearranged, omitted, and/or modified to include other operations and/orfeatures described in this disclosure.

The technical improvements provided by the subsystem 100-1 includeimprovements in accuracy, speed, and adaptability in authentication byway of adaptive authentication that is based at least in part onmachine-intelligent authentication scoring of particular endpoints thattakes into account different detected phenomena and situations (e.g.,multiple endpoints, a different endpoints, multiple voices, a differentvoice, static images, drastic change in performance, performance style,low-quality sensor data, non-functional sensor, etc.) and weights thosefactors differently in order to accurately characterize authenticationintegrity and need the for enhanced authentication. As indicated byblock 802, one or more sets of data may be captured from one or moredata sources. In disclosed embodiments, different types of data may becaptured from a variety of different data sources. As indicated by block804, sensor data may be captured from one or more sensors 209. Thesensors 209 could be disposed in and/or about the location 107, asdisclosed herein. For example, the one or more sensors 209 may includeany one or combination of sensors, detectors, controllers, and/or otherdevices associated with any one or combination of components disclosedherein. In disclosed embodiments, the sensor data may correspond toendpoint input. As indicated by block 806, endpoint input may becaptured. As indicated by block 808, other input from one or more otherdata sources may be captured.

As indicated by block 810, one or more particularized control processesmay be based at least in part on the one or more sets of data may becaptured from one or more data sources. The particularized controlprocesses 810 may include one or more endpoint authentication processes812. The particularized control processes may include processes foraction determination 818, location determination 820, temporaldetermination 822, and/or contextual determination 824. In someembodiments, any one or combination of such determinations may beutilized in the particular authentication process 812 to assess anendpoint sensed. For example, determined actions 708, locations 710,temporal factors 712, and/or contextual factors 714 of an endpoint maybe compared to corresponding patterns 716 that may have been previouslydetermined for particular endpoints to determine to what extent thedetected indicia match the patterns. In some embodiments, suchpattern-based analysis may be implemented as a supplement toidentification process 812.

As indicated by block 812, having captured data, the control system mayimplement one or more endpoint characterization processes. The one ormore endpoint characterization processes 812 may include one or moremetric analysis processes 826 to determine an identity of an endpointsensed and assess an integrity of the endpoint and a level of certaintywith which the endpoint is authenticated. Further, the one or moreendpoint characterization processes 812 may include one or more metricanalysis processes 826 to determine one or more authentication rules 828based at least in part on one or more sets of captured data 802. The oneor more endpoint authentication processes 812 may determine the one ormore authentication rules 828 based at least in part on determinedactions 708, locations 710, temporal factors 712, contextual factors 714and/or corresponding patterns 716 attributed to an identified endpoint.Such factors may be taken into account with results from currentprocesses (i.e., in real time along with an endpoint currently beingsensed) and past processes (i.e., the results of which have beenpreviously logged 830 and stored in an authentication data store 104 inassociation with the endpoint's specification) of action determination818, location determination 820, temporal determination 822, and/orcontextual determination 824. Accordingly, in various instances,authentication processes 812 may yield an authentication score of anendpoint sensed and/or automation rules 828 for handling aninsufficiently authenticated endpoint and/or a sufficientlyauthenticated endpoint, and, consequently, the subsystem may causeauthentication control operations based at least in part on the endpointqualification. The authentication control operations as a function ofthe authentication score may include one or combination of theactivation adjustments 531 disclosed further herein.

Authentication data can be consolidated and processed to yield anauthentication score. Any one or combination of types of authenticationdata may be captured and qualified. Some embodiments may qualify anendpoint according to a graduated authentication scale. Any suitableauthentication scale may be used in various embodiments. In someembodiments, an authentication scale could entail a categorizationscheme 816, with categories such as strong authentication of aparticular endpoint, possible authentication of a particular endpoint,weak authentication of a particular endpoint, and an unknown endpoint,or any suitable categories such as other categories disclosed herein.

In disclosed embodiments, an authentication scale could entail anauthentication scoring system 814. The authentication scoring system 814could be correlated to the category scheme in some embodiments, suchthat certain scores correspond to certain categories. Some embodimentsmay score an endpoint with a numerical expression, for example, anauthentication score. For example, in some embodiments, anauthentication score may be an assessment of a certainty with which thesystem identifies an endpoint, characterizes integrity of the endpoint,and authenticates the endpoint, taking into account a number of factors,each of which may be weighted differently. By way of example withoutlimitation, an authentication scale could include a range ofauthentication scores from 0 to 100, or from 0 to 1,000, with the highend of the scale indicating greater probability. Some embodiments mayuse methods of statistical analysis to derive an authentication score.Various embodiments may determine an authentication score based on anyone or more suitable quantifiers. An authentication score may be basedat least in part on the extent to which detected characteristics of thecaptured data match previously determined characteristics stored in theendpoint specifications. In some embodiments, an authentication scoremay be cumulative of endpoint scores based on matching each type of thecharacteristics. With an authentication score determined,categorizations may be made based on the score. By way of examplewithout limitation, a score correlated to a 75-100% band may be deemed apositive authentication of an endpoint; a score correlated to a 70-75%band may be deemed a possible authentication of an endpoint with someindicia of questionable physical, behavioral, and/or interactionattributes; a score correlated to a 25-50% band may be deemed a weakauthentication of an endpoint with more indicia of questionable orsuspicious physical, behavioral, and/or interaction attributes; a scorebelow a 25% minimum threshold may be deemed a weak/insufficientauthentication of an endpoint with even more indicia of questionable orsuspicious physical, behavioral, and/or interaction attributes; andscore of zero may correspond to an unknown, unauthenticated, and/orhighly suspicious endpoint.

In some embodiments, a similar scoring scheme may be used to derivepatterns of activity and corresponding automation rules. For example, asimilar scoring scheme may be used to determine one or more extents towhich monitored sets of actions, locations, times, and/or contexts matchother sets of actions, locations, times, and/or contexts for anendpoint. By way of example without limitation, a score correlated to a75-100% band may be deemed a positive match; a score correlated to a50-75% band may be deemed a possible match with possible deviation; ascore correlated to a 25-50% band may be deemed a weak match withsignificant deviation; a score below a 25% minimum threshold may bedeemed a weak/insufficient match with substantial deviation; and scoreof zero may be deemed to have no correspondence.

Video data and/or other types of sensor data (e.g., heat/IR, etc.) maybe analyzed to recognize patterns and thereby establish baselines withrespect to the endpoint device and to further identify deviations withrespect to the endpoint device. For example, video data may be analyzedto recognize the particular endpoint and to further identify deviationswith respect to the recognized endpoint. When facial recognition is usedto authenticate an endpoint via one authentication stage, subsequentstages of authentication may be implemented to confirm no deviationsfrom the recognized endpoint. One deviation may correspond to a changedor additional endpoint such that a different endpoint is detected at theendpoint device. The different endpoint may or may not be recognized,but the lack of correspondence to the previously authenticated endpointmay be determined with the one or more subsequent stages ofauthentication and may correspond to a complete mismatch, which may bescored accordingly. Consequently, the subsystem may cause authenticationcontrol 832 to initiate activation adjustments 531 such as one or moreadditional authentication stages, prohibit access via the endpointdevice, and/or to otherwise cause notification of the deviation,depending on the authentication score, the score thresholds that aresatisfied by the authentication score, and the authentication control832 triggered by the respective threshold being satisfied.

As another example, video and/or other types of sensor data (e.g.,heat/IR, etc.) may be analyzed to recognize the general form and/orpatterns of movement of an endpoint. With such patterns created,subsequent stages of authentication may be implemented to confirm nodeviations from the recognized general endpoint form and/or patterns ofendpoint movement, which may be distinguished from ambient action (e.g.,baselines for movement of others and objects in the background). Suchdeviations may correspond to types of movements, such as an endpointmoving away from an endpoint device (e.g., leaving an approved locationin the proximate area about the endpoint device to a disapproved orunclassified location, leaning away from the endpoint device, moving outof a range of a sensor, etc.), a changed endpoint such that a differentendpoint is detected at the endpoint device, deviations in gaze (e.g.,repetitively gazing downward or to the side), recognition of anadditional device, a static image inserted in front of a camera, arepetitive video loop, other lack of variability in captured images, astatic image in front of a changing background, and/or the like. Suchdeviations may lower authentication scores to varying extents, based onwhich, the subsystem may cause authentication control 832 to initiateactivation adjustments 531 such as one or more additional authenticationstages, prohibit access via the endpoint device, and/or to otherwisecause notification of the deviations.

Another related deviation may correspond to the detection of multipleendpoints at the single endpoint device. For example, while theinitially authenticated endpoint may be detected as continuing accessvia the endpoint device, an additional endpoint may also be detected.The recognition of the additional endpoint, not having beenauthenticated with respect to the particular endpoint device, may bedetermined with the one or more subsequent stages of authentication andmay correspond to a lower authentication score. Again, as a consequence,the subsystem may cause authentication control 832 to initiateactivation adjustments 531 such as one or more additional authenticationstages, prohibit access via the endpoint device, and/or to otherwisecause notification of the deviation, depending on the authenticationscore and score thresholds.

Similarly, audio data may be analyzed to recognize audio patterns andthereby establish audio baselines with respect to the endpoint deviceand to further identify deviations with respect to the endpoint device.The audio pattern analysis may identify tonal, pitch, and volumecharacteristics; keywords and corresponding language used; cadence,pauses, and accents; ambient noise; and/or the like as distinctivemarkings and could compile the audio pattern characteristics for thepurposes of endpoint characterization. When such audio patternrecognition is used as at least part of one authentication stage,subsequent stages of authentication may be implemented to confirm nodeviations from the audio pattern with respect to one or more of theaudio characteristics of the audio pattern. Again, one deviation maycorrespond to a changed endpoint such that one or more differentendpoints are detected at the endpoint device via audio detection of oneor more different voices. The different endpoint may or may not berecognized, but the lack of correspondence to the previously detectedaudio pattern may be determined with the one or more subsequent stagesof authentication and may correspond to a complete mismatch or a partialmismatch that may correspond to an additional endpoint being potentiallydetected at the endpoint device. In some embodiments, audio recognitionmay not be used to authenticate an endpoint via a first-stageauthentication process, where other types of sensor input is used forauthentication in the first-stage authentication process. However, audiorecognition may be used with subsequent stages of authentication torecognize audio patterns and detect deviations therefrom, lowerauthentication scores, and then cause authentication control 832 toinitiate activation adjustments 531 as disclosed herein.

Further, other types of action data in conjunction with temporal datamay be analyzed to recognize patterns and subsequent deviations forproviding inputs, such as typing patterns, mouse click patterns, typingspeed, words used, words not used by the endpoint, typing speed, whichtyping speed can be either a general typing speed or a typing speed forone or several words, synonym pairs that include a used and a non-usedword, vocabulary, omitted words, correctly spelled words, misspellings,other performance attributes, time on task, overall speed completing aset of tasks, and/or the like. As with other deviations detected, whenone or more of the various deviations from action data patterns aredetected, authentication scores may be lowered depending on the variousweights according to the various factors and extents of deviations andauthentication control 832 to initiate activation adjustments 531 may betriggered when score thresholds are met.

In like manner, other types of temporal data in conjunction withcontextual data may be analyzed to recognize patterns with respect to aplurality of colocated endpoint devices. Location data for the endpointdevices may be gathered using GPS coordinates, cellular towertriangulation techniques, Wi-Fi-based location information,carrier-provided location information, and/or other locationdetermination systems to identify a location of the endpoint devices.Such data may be analyzed to recognize colocation of endpoint devicesand movement of endpoint devices (e.g., within an approved location,from approved location to a disapproved or unclassified location, etc.).With the identification of colocated endpoint devices, time on task,timing of transitions between tasks, and/or the like and be analyzed todetect patterns of coincidental timing with respect to such temporalmetrics. The patterns of coincidental timing may be deemed questionableor suspicious activity, thereby lowering authentication scores to anextent. In addition, similarity of the colocated endpoint devices may betaken into account. For example, if the operations of the colocatedendpoint devices are similar or the same, greater weight may beaccording to the coincidental timing detected so that the authenticationscores are lowered to a greater extent. In some such cases is these, itis not a deviation detected but rather a detected correlation that maylower authentication scores according to various weights according tothe various factors and extents of correlations, with authenticationcontrol 832 to initiate activation adjustments 531 being triggered whenscore thresholds are met.

The criteria for qualifying endpoints may specify rules and thresholdsfor various types of authentication data. For example, criteria forqualifying endpoints may specify rules and thresholds based at least inpart on any one or combination of device authentication data 704,biometric authentication data 706, action data 708, location data 710,temporal data 712, contextual data 714, and/or pattern data 716. Forexample, device authentication data 704 and/or biometric authenticationdata 706 of an endpoint may be compared to previously stored deviceauthentication data and/or biometric authentication data to determine towhat extent the device authentication data 704 and/or biometricauthentication data 706 can be authenticated. For example, biometricdata 706 may be considered as more reliable authentication data thandevice authentication data 704, and, as such, detected biometric data706 may increase the authentication score more than detected deviceauthentication data 704 would increase the authentication score. Variousendpoints may be associated with various collections of devices, deviceidentifiers, and other device authentication data 704. When the systemdetects device authentication data, say a MAC address of computingdevice associated with a particular endpoint or a device having a validWiFi password, the system may take that data as an indication ofidentity of the endpoint having that device data stored in theendpoint's specification. However, in some embodiments, the system maynot deem an authentication of the device alone as dispositive ofendpoint's identity and may seek further evidence of the identity of theendpoint.

Even within a category of authentication input 540, the various means ofauthentication may be correlated to different probabilities and may beweighted differently to affect authentication scores differently. Forexample, with respect to biometric data 706, fingerprint authenticationdata, received via a fingerprint scanner of the system, matchingpreviously recorded fingerprint data for an endpoint could be weightedmore heavily to lead to very high authentication score (absent otherfactors decreasing the score), whereas a heat recognition data, receivedvia a heat sensor of the system, could be weighted less heavily to becorrelated to a comparatively lower authentication score. Likewise, withrespect to action data 708, voice recognition could be weighted moreheavily to contribute to a higher authentication score than performanceattribute pattern recognition (absent other factors affecting thescore).

Accordingly, in various embodiments, the authentication process 812 maybe based at least in part on any one or combination of actiondetermination 818, location determination 820, temporal determination822, and/or contextual determination 824. The authentication process 812may employ a protocol order, such as a decision tree, checklist,workflow, and/or the like to capture various aspects of data and assessthose aspects to infer endpoint integrity qualification. Such a decisiontree, checklist, and/or workflow may incorporate any one or combinationof the depicted aspects and/or similar aspects in any desired order,according to various embodiments. For example, biometric data 706 may beconsidered as more reliable authentication data than some action data708. As a consequence, the protocol order may include first checking forand processing any available biometric data 706 in one stage ofauthentication before checking for and processing any available actiondata 708 in a subsequent stage of authentication.

In some embodiments, pattern-based analysis may be implemented as acheck on the authentication process 812 in one or more subsequent stagesof authentication that serves to confirm that the endpoint acts inconformity with what is expected for the endpoint identified with one ormore previous stage of authentication of the authentication process 812.For example, for a weakly identified endpoint, the subsystem may promptfurther authentication via a different type of sensor data. In somecases, the subsystem may cause one or more endpoint notifications (pushnotifications, automated system voice announcements, pop-ups on anendpoint interface communicatively coupled with the system, emails,automated phone calls, alarms, etc.) to be directed to one or moreauthenticated endpoints, devices, and/or accounts based at least in parton data retained in the endpoint specification, and the subsystem mayrequire additional authentication, which could be captured consequent tothe one or more endpoint notifications. In addition or in alternative,the subsystem may monitor an initially authenticated endpoint forconsistencies and/or inconsistencies with predetermined pattern(s)associated with that endpoint, where inconsistencies may trigger one ormore additional authentication adjustments.

With reference now to FIG. 16, a flowchart illustrating an embodiment ofa process 1600 for protection of authentication integrity is shown. Theprocess 1600 may begin at block 1602 wherein an indicator of a requestedauthenticated operation is received. In some embodiments, for example,the indicator of the requested authenticated operation can be receivedby the one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1 of the adaptiveauthentication system 100. In some embodiments, for example, theindicator of the request authenticated operation can be received fromone of the endpoint devices 106. In some embodiments, for example, theindicator of the requested authenticated operation can be received fromone or more of the servers of system 100.

After the indicator of the requested authenticated operation has beenreceived, the process 1600 may proceed to block 1604 wherein theauthenticated operation is provided. In some embodiments, for example,the authenticated operation can be provided to one of the endpointdevices 106, and the authenticated operation can be provided by one ofthe components of the adaptive authentication system 100 such as, forexample, one or more of the servers of system 100.

After the authenticated operation has been provided, the process 1600may proceed to block 1606 wherein the capture of authentication data isrequested. In some embodiments, for example, authentication integrityverification can be provided in connection with an authenticatedoperation. In some embodiments, for example, an authenticated operationmay be associated with the request for authentication integrityverification. Thus, in one embodiment, an authenticated operation can beassociated with an indicator of requested authentication integrityverification. If authentication integrity verification is requested,then the adaptive authentication system requests the capture of theauthentication data. In some embodiments, for example, theauthentication data can be collected by the components of the adaptiveauthentication system 100 such as, for example, one of the endpointdevices 106 and/or a camera 209 of the one or more sensors 209. In someembodiments, for example, the request for the capture of authenticationdata can include, for example, a request for the camera 209 to collectimage data of the actual endpoint performing the authenticatedoperation.

After the request for the capture of authentication data, the process1600 may proceed to block 1608 wherein the authentication data isreceived. In some embodiments, for example, authentication data can bereceived by one or more of the components of the adaptive authenticationsystem 100 such as, for example, the one or more adaptive processingdevices 500-1, one or more of the endpoint devices 106, or one of thedata storages 104, and in some embodiments, the authentication data canbe received by the verification engine 208-1 of the endpoint device 106.

After the authentication data has been received, the process 1600 mayproceed to block 1610 wherein the endpoint specification data isrequested. In some embodiments, for example, the endpoint specificationdata can be requested by one of the components of the adaptiveauthentication system 100 such as, for example, one or more adaptiveprocessing devices 500-1 and/or one or more of the endpoint devices 106.In some embodiments, for example, the endpoint specification data can berequested by the verification engine 208-1 of one or more of theendpoint devices 106. In some embodiments, the endpoint specificationdata can be requested from one of the data storages 104, such as theendpoint specification data storage 301.

After the endpoint specification data has been requested, the process1600 may proceed to block 1612 wherein the endpoint specification datais received. In some embodiments, for example, the endpointspecification data can be received by a component of the adaptiveauthentication system 100 such as, for example, the one or more adaptiveprocessing devices 500-1, one or more of the endpoint devices, and/orone of the components of one or more of the endpoint devices 106 suchas, for example, the verification engine 208-1.

After the endpoint specification data has been received, the process1600 may proceed to block 1614 wherein the authentication data isevaluated. In some embodiments, for example, the authentication data canbe evaluated by comparing the received authentication data to receiveendpoint specification data. In some embodiments, for example, thecomparison of the authentication data to the endpoint specification datacan include determining the likelihood that the actual endpoint is theprovisional endpoint. In some embodiments, in which the authenticationdata includes one or several photographs, the evaluation of theauthentication data can include an evaluation of clothing worn by theactual endpoint, the location surrounding the actual endpoint, or thelike. In one embodiment, for example, a discrepancy in the clothingstyle or location between the authentication data and the endpointspecification data may indicate that the actual endpoint is not theprovisional endpoint. In some embodiments, for example, the evaluationof the authentication data can be performed by a component of theadaptive authentication system 100 such as, for example, the one or moreadaptive processing devices 500-1, one or more of the endpoint devices106, and/or a component of one or more of the endpoint devices 106 suchas, for example, the verification engine 208-1.

After the authentication data has been evaluated, the process 1600 mayproceed to block 1616 wherein an indicator of authentication integrityis provided. In some embodiments, for example, an indicator ofauthentication integrity can be provided to one of the data storages104, such as the endpoint specification data storage 301, authenticationdata storage 312, and/or verification data storage 313. In someembodiments, for example, the indicator of authentication integrity canbe provided to an endpoint via the endpoint device 106 and/or to one ormore of the servers of system 100.

With reference now to FIG. 17, a flowchart illustrating an embodiment ofa process 1700 for authenticating an endpoint is provided. The process1700 may begin at block 1702 wherein an indicator of a requestedauthenticated operation is received. In some embodiments, for example,the indicator the requested authenticated operation can be received bythe one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1 of the adaptiveauthentication system 100. In some embodiments, for example, theindicator of the request authenticated operation can be received fromone of the endpoint devices 106. In some embodiments, for example, theindicator of the requested authenticated operation can be received fromone or more of the servers of system 100.

After the indicator of the requested authenticated operation has beenreceived, the process 1700 may proceed to block 1704 wherein theauthenticated operation is provided. In some embodiments, for example,the authenticated operation can be provided to one of the endpointdevices 106, and the authenticated operation can be provided by one ofthe components of the adaptive authentication system 100 such as, forexample, one or more of the servers of system 100.

After the authenticated operation has been provided, the process 1700may proceed to block 1706 wherein the capture of authentication data isrequested. In some embodiments, for example, authentication integrityverification can be provided in connection with an authenticatedoperation. In some embodiments, for example, an authenticated operationmay be associated with the request for authentication integrityverification. Thus, in one embodiment, an authenticated operation can beassociated with an indicator of desired authentication integrityverification. If authentication integrity verification is requested,then the adaptive authentication system requests the capture of theauthentication data. In some embodiments, for example, theauthentication data can be collected by the components of the adaptiveauthentication system 100 such as, for example, one of the endpointdevices 106 and/or the camera 209. In some embodiments, for example, therequest for the capture of authentication data can include, for example,a request for the camera 209 to collect image data of the actualendpoint performing the authenticated operation.

After the request for the capture of authentication data, the process1700 may proceed to block 1708 wherein the authentication data andintegrity criteria are received. In some embodiments, for example, theauthentication data and integrity criteria can be received by one ormore of the components of the adaptive authentication system 100 suchas, for example, the one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1, oneor more of the endpoint devices 106, or one of the data storages 104,and in some embodiments, the authentication data can be received by theverification engine 208-1 of the endpoint device 106. In someembodiments, for example, the authentication data can be received from,for example, a component of the adaptive authentication system 100 suchas, for example, the endpoint interface 207 of the endpoint device 106and/or the camera 209. In some embodiments, for example, the integritycriteria can be received from one of the databases such as, for example,the verification database. In some embodiments, for example, theintegrity criteria can comprise one or several thresholds. Thesethresholds can delineate the circumstances in which an actual endpointis identified as being the provisional endpoint and in which an actualendpoint is identified as not being the provisional endpoint.

After the authentication data and integrity criteria are received, theprocess 1700 may proceed to block 1710 wherein the endpointspecification data is received. In some embodiments, for example, block1710 can include the request for endpoint specification data as well asthe receipt of endpoint specification data. In some embodiments, forexample, the endpoint specification data can be requested from one ormore of the components of the adaptive authentication system 100 suchas, for example, the endpoint specification data storage 301. In someembodiments, for example, endpoint specification data can be received bya component of the adaptive authentication system 100 such as, forexample, the one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1, one or moreof the endpoint devices, and/or one of the components of one or more ofthe endpoint devices 106 such as, for example, the verification engine208-1.

After the endpoint specification data has been received, the process1700 may proceed to block 1712 wherein the authentication data isevaluated. In some embodiments, for example, the authentication data canbe evaluated by comparing the received authentication data to receivedendpoint specification data. In some embodiments, for example, thecomparison of the authentication data to the endpoint specification datacan include determining the likelihood that the actual endpoint is theprovisional endpoint. In some embodiments, for example, the evaluationof the authentication data can be performed by a component of theadaptive authentication system 100 such as, for example, the one or moreadaptive processing devices 500-1, one or more of the endpoint devices106, and/or a component of one or more of the endpoint devices 106 suchas, for example, the verification engine 208-1.

After the authentication data has been evaluated, the process 1700 mayproceed to block 1714 wherein an authentication level is determined. Insome embodiments, for example, the determination of the authenticationlevel can include the generation of an authentication score. Asdisclosed herein, this score can reflect the likelihood that anprovisional endpoint is the actual endpoint. In some embodiments, forexample, this score can be based on the similarities and differencesbetween the endpoint specification data and the authentication data. Thescore can be generated and the authentication level can be determined bya component of the integrity system such as, for example, the one ormore adaptive processing devices 500-1, one or more of the endpointdevices 106, and/or the verification engine 208-1 of one or more of theendpoint devices 106.

After the authentication level has been determined, the process 1700 mayproceed to block 1716 wherein an indicator of the authentication levelis added. In some embodiments, for example, the indicator of theauthentication level can be added to, for example, one of the datastorages 104 such as, for example, the endpoint specification datastorage 301, the authentication data storage 312, and/or theverification data storage 313. After the indicator of the authenticationlevel has been added, the process 1700 may proceed to decision state1718 wherein it is determined if there is additional authenticationdata. The determination of whether there is additional authenticationdata can be made to determine how many types of authentication data touse in authenticating the actual endpoint.

The authentication data and endpoint specification data can be of one orseveral types.

In some embodiments, for example, these types can be defined by theaspect of the actual and/or provisional endpoint that they characterize.Thus, for example, in some embodiments, these types may include datarelating to a physical attribute, data relating to a performanceattribute, and/or data relating to an interaction. Similarly, each ofthese types can be further divided into subtypes. In some embodiments,for example, the data type can correspond to one or several grouped dataaspects that are useful in identifying the actual endpoint. In someembodiments, these types can be associated with a value indicative of alikelihood of the type of authentication data being used to successfullyidentify the actual endpoint.

In some embodiments, the identification and/or authentication of theactual endpoint can be based on one or more of these types. Thus, forexample, in some embodiments the identity of the actual endpoint can bedetermined by comparing a physical characteristic of the actual endpointwith physical characteristics of the provisional endpoint stored in theendpoint specification data, and in some embodiments the identity of theactual endpoint can be determined by comparing nonphysicalcharacteristics such as, for example, the performance attribute of theactual endpoint with performance attributes of the provisional endpointstored in the endpoint specification data. Thus, the identity of theactual endpoint can be determined, using different types ofauthentication data. In some embodiments, for example, multiple types ofauthentication data can be used in identifying the actual endpoint. Insuch an embodiment, for example a physical attribute and a performanceattribute of the actual endpoint can be compared with the physicalattribute and a performance attribute of the provisional endpoint storedin the endpoint specification data. In some embodiments, theauthentication data can be used to determine if another, in addition tothe actual endpoint, is involved in and/or present during the completionof the authenticated operation. In some embodiments, this can bedetermined by the presence of another in one or several photographs orvideo segments, by the detection of a second voice or sounds fromanother via a microphone, and/or the detection of one or severalbehaviors indicative of communication such as, for example, repeatedlooking in a certain direction, hand gestures, facial expressions, bodylanguage, the combination of repeated looking in a certain direction andone or more of hand gestures, facial expressions, and body language, orthe like.

In some embodiments, one or more of the components of the adaptiveauthentication system 100 can be used to determine if there is anadditional authentication data. In some embodiments, this determinationcan include identifying received un-evaluated authentication data. Insome embodiments, for example, this identification can be performed bythe one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1, by one or more of theendpoint devices 106, and/or by the verification engine 208-1 of one ormore of the endpoint devices 106. If it is determined that there isadditional authentication data, the process can return to block 1706.

If it is determined that there is no additional authentication data, theprocess 1700 may proceed to block 1720 wherein indicators of theauthentication level are retrieved. In some embodiments, for example,the indicator of the authentication level can be retrieved from, forexample, one of the data storages 104 such as, for example, the endpointspecification data storage 301, the authentication data storage 312,and/or the verification data storage 313.

After the indicators of the authentication level are retrieved, theprocess 1700 may proceed to block 1722 wherein the total authenticationlevel is evaluated. In some embodiments, for example, the evaluation thetotal authentication level can include the comparison of a singleindicator of the authentication level and/or the comparison of acombination of a plurality of indicators of the authentication level tothe integrity criteria. In some embodiments, for example, thiscomparison can be performed according to a Boolean function, wherein anauthentication level defined as authenticated by the integrity criteriacan be assigned a first Boolean value and an authentication leveldefined as unauthenticated by the integrity criteria can be assigned asecond Boolean value. In some embodiments, for example, this comparisoncan be made by a component of the adaptive authentication system 100such as, for example, the one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1,one or more of the endpoint devices 106, and/or the verification engine208-1 of one or more of the endpoint devices 106.

After the total authentication level has been evaluated, the process1700 may proceed to decision state 1724 wherein it is determined if theendpoint is authenticated. In some embodiments, for example, thisdetermination can be made by a component of the adaptive authenticationsystem 100 such as, for example, the one or more adaptive processingdevices 500-1 and/or one or more of the endpoint devices 106 orcomponents thereof. In some embodiments, this determination can includeretrieving the assigned Boolean value and determining whether theBoolean value is indicative of the identification of the actual endpointas the provisional endpoint or of the identification of the actualendpoint as different from the actual endpoint.

If the endpoint is authenticated in that the actual endpoint isidentified as the provisional endpoint, then the process 1700 mayproceed to block 1726 wherein an indication of authentication is added.In some embodiments, for example, the indication of authentication canbe added to one of the data storages 104 of the adaptive authenticationsystem 100 such as, for example, the endpoint specification data storage301.

After the indication of authentication has been added, the process mayproceed to block 1728 wherein an indicator of integrity is provided. Insome embodiments, for example, the indicator of integrity can beprovided to the endpoint specification data stored in the endpointspecification data storage 301. In some embodiments, for example, theindicator of authentication integrity can be provided to an endpoint viathe endpoint device 106 and/or to one or more of the servers of system100.

Returning again to decision state 1724, if it is determined that theendpoint is not authenticated, then the process 1700 may proceed toblock 1730 wherein an indication of non-Authentication is added. In someembodiments, for example, the indication of non-Authentication can beadded to one of the data storages 104 of the adaptive authenticationsystem 100 such as, for example, the endpoint specification data storage301.

After the indication of non-authentication has been added, the processmay proceed to block 1732 wherein an indicator of fraud is provided. Insome embodiments, for example, the indicator of fraud can be provided tothe endpoint specification data stored in the endpoint specificationdata storage 301. In some embodiments, for example, the indicator offraud can be provided to an endpoint via the endpoint device 106 and/orto one or more of the servers of system 100.

With reference now to FIG. 18, a flowchart depicting an embodiment of aprocess 1800 for protection of authentication integrity with imagebatches is provided. The process 1800 may begin at block 1802 whereinthe capture of authentication data is requested. In some embodiments,for example, verification of authentication integrity (which may bereferenced herein as academic integrity) can be provided in connectionwith an authenticated operation. In some embodiments, for example, anauthenticated operation may be associated with the request forauthentication integrity verification. Thus, in one embodiment, anauthenticated operation can be associated with an indicator of desiredauthentication integrity verification. If authentication integrityverification is requested, then the adaptive authentication systemrequests the capture of the authentication data.

After the capture of authentication data has been requested, the process1800 may proceed to block 1804 wherein still image batch data isreceived. In some embodiments, for example, the still image batch datacan be received from, for example, the camera 209. In some embodiments,the still image batch data can comprise a batch of still images. Thisbatch can include, for example, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 20, 50, 100,or any other or intermediate number of still images. Advantageously, forexample, the capture of the batch of still images can increase theaccuracy of the adaptive authentication system 100 by decreasing thelikelihood of a false positive and/or false-negative due to a non-idealimage.

After the still image batch data has been received, the process 1800 mayproceed to block 1806 wherein endpoint specification data is received.The endpoint specification data can include, for example, one or severalendpoint specification images. These images can be image data of theprovisional endpoint. In some embodiments, for example, endpointspecification data can be received by a component of the adaptiveauthentication system 100 such as, for example, the one or more adaptiveprocessing devices 500-1, one or more of the endpoint devices, and/orone of the components of one or more of the endpoint devices 106 suchas, for example, the verification engine 208-1.

After the endpoint specification data has been received, the process mayproceed to block 1808 wherein an image is selected from the still imagebatch. In some embodiments, for example, the image can be selected by acomponent of the adaptive authentication system 100 such as, forexample, the one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1 and/or one ormore of the endpoint devices 106 or component thereof.

After the image has been selected, the process 1800 may proceed to block1810 wherein the selected image is compared to the endpointspecification image. In some embodiments, for example, the selectedimage can be compared to the endpoint specification image by a componentof the adaptive authentication system 100 such as, for example, the oneor more adaptive processing devices 500-1 and/or one or more of theendpoint devices 106 or a component thereof. In some embodiments, forexample, a value representing the authentication level can be generatedbased on the comparison of the selected image and the endpointspecification image. This value can reflect the likelihood that theactual endpoint depicted in the selected image is the provisionalendpoint depicted in the endpoint specification image.

In some embodiments, for example, this comparison of the selected imageand the endpoint specification image can further include the comparisonof the authentication level with the integrity criteria. This comparisoncan be performed according to a Boolean function, wherein anauthentication level defined as authenticated by the integrity criteriacan be assigned a first Boolean value and an authentication leveldefined as unauthenticated by the integrity criteria can be assigned asecond Boolean value. In some embodiments, for example, this comparisoncan be made by a component of the adaptive authentication system 100such as, for example, the one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1,one or more of the endpoint devices 106, and/or the verification engine208-1 of one or more of the endpoint devices 106.

After the selected images are compared to the endpoint specificationimage, the process may proceed to decision state 1812 wherein it isdetermined if the actual endpoint is authenticated. In some embodiments,for example, this determination can be made by a component of theadaptive authentication system 100 such as, for example, the one or moreadaptive processing devices 500-1 and/or one or more of the endpointdevices 106 or components thereof. In some embodiments, thisdetermination can include retrieving the assigned Boolean value anddetermining whether the Boolean value is indicative of theidentification of the actual endpoint as the provisional endpoint or ofthe identification of the actual endpoint as different than the actualendpoint.

If the actual endpoint is authenticated, the process may proceed toblock 1814 wherein an indicator of the image match is added. In someembodiments, for example, the indicator of the image match can be addedto one of the data storages 104 such as, for example, the endpointspecification data storage 301. After the indicator of image match hasbeen added, the process 1800 may proceed to block 1816 and returns todecision state 1718 of FIG. 17.

Returning again to decision state 1812, if it is determined that theactual endpoint is not authenticated, the process may proceed to block1818 wherein an indicator of the non-Authentication of the actualendpoint is added. In some embodiments, for example, the indicator ofthe image non-match can be added to one of the data storages 104 suchas, for example, the endpoint specification data storage 301.

After the indicator of the non-authentication is added, the process 1800may proceed to decision state 1820 wherein it is determined if there isan additional image in the image batch. In some embodiments, forexample, this determination can be made by a component of the adaptiveauthentication system 100 such as, for example, the one or more adaptiveprocessing devices 500-1 and/or one or more of the endpoint devices 106or components thereof. If it is determined that there is an additionalimage, the process returns to block 1808. If it is determined that thereis no additional image, then the process may proceed to block 1816 andreturns to decision state 1718 of FIG. 17.

FIG. 19 depicts certain aspects of a method 1900 to adaptively secure aset of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources, in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.Again, in various embodiments, one or combination of operations of themethod 1900 and the other methods herein may be performed in whole or inpart by the adaptive authentication system 100, including the subsystem100-1 and the one or more adaptive processing devices 500-1. The method1900 and the subsequent methods may include additional operations, andthe steps described herein may be rearranged, omitted, and/or modifiedto include other operations and/or features described in thisdisclosure.

As indicated by block 1902, an indicator of a requested authenticatedoperation may be detected. In some embodiments, for example, theindicator of the requested authenticated operation can be received bythe one or more adaptive processing devices of the adaptiveauthentication system 100. In some embodiments, for example, theindicator of the requested authenticated operation can be received fromone of the servers. In addition or in alternative, for example, theindicator of the requested authenticated operation can be received fromone of the endpoint devices 106. As indicated by block 1904, after theindicator of the requested authenticated operation has been received,multi-stage, adaptive authentication operations may be initiated withrespect to the endpoint device. Such operations may include one or acombination of the following.

As indicated by block 1906, first-stage authentication may be initiated.FIG. 20 illustrates certain aspects of first-stage authentication, inaccordance with embodiments of the present disclosure. With reference toFIG. 20, as indicated by block 1906-1, after the indicator of therequested authenticated operation has been received, one or moreidentifiers for the endpoint device may be generated or retrieved. Theone or more identifiers may uniquely correspond to the endpoint deviceamongst a set of endpoint devices. The one or more identifiers may alsoinhibit discovery of an endpoint corresponding to the endpoint device.For example, the one or more identifiers may omit identifyinginformation, such as a name, identifying number (or alphanumeric code)or address.

As indicated by block 1906-2, an access-right indicator configured tofacilitate determination of particularized access for electronicresources may be identified. The access-right indicator may beidentified based at least in part on the one or more identifiers and/oradministratory input. The access-right indicator can be configured toenable a determination as to which types of access are to be grantedwith respect to one or more electronic resources are to be granted. Theaccess-right indicator may be identified (for example) by looking up anidentifier of the endpoint or endpoint device or transmitting a requestfor the access-right indicator to a resource or authorizingadministratory or backend device for a set of one or more permissionvalues, specifications, codes, and/or the like linked to an endpointidentifier.

As indicated by block 1906-3, a protocol that includes parameterconstraint(s) for resource access by the endpoint device may beidentified. The protocol may be identified based at least in part on theone or more identifiers, the access-right indicator, and/oradministratory input. The protocol may include or identify one or moreparameter constraints pertaining to operation of a system. A parameterconstraint may include, for example, a constraint on a performanceresult (e.g., specified as one or more individual values, categoriesand/or via one or more thresholds), which may pertain to (for example) athroughput, operation time or frequency, quality metric, and/orefficiency. A parameter constraint may include, for example, aconstraint on resource accesses (e.g., to pertain to endpoints and/orendpoint devices), such as indications as to which types of resourcesare available for use, types of permitted use and/or times of permitteduse. A protocol may have been defined at least in part based on inputcorresponding to human-provided specifications and/or based on anautomated processing of past performance, such as via machine learning.

As indicated by block 1906-4, initiation of a set of one or more accessevents by the endpoint device may be detected. The set of one or moreaccess events may correspond to one or more of the various interactionswith resources via endpoint devices 106 disclosed herein. For example,an access event may correspond to an authenticated operation. In someembodiments, for example, the authenticated operation can be provided toone of the endpoint devices 106, and the authenticated operation can beprovided by one of the components of the adaptive authentication system100 such as, for example, the content management server 102.

As indicated by block 1906-5, activation of a first set of one or moresensors 209 may be caused. As disclosed herein, the first set of one ormore sensors may be communicatively connected to the one or moreadaptive processing devices 501-1. In some embodiments, the activationof the first set may be caused after the initiation of the set of one ormore access events. In other embodiments, the activation may be causedprior to the initiation of the set of one or more access events. Forexample, the activation may be caused in response to a previous requestfrom the endpoint and/or a previous initiation of one or more accessevents. The first set of one or more sensors 209 may correspond to afirst sensor type. For example, the first set may correspond to a camera209. However, in other embodiments, the first set of one or more sensors209 may include a plurality of sensors of two or more different sensortypes.

Further, the activation of the first set of one or more sensors maycorrespond to a first mode of operation. A mode of sensor operation mayinclude sensor activation such that the sensor is in an on state, or adetection state, as a function of time. For instance, in the case of acamera 209, one mode of operation may include the camera being activatedfor detection and image capture until a deactivation command is receivedand/or for one or more specified durations. Further, the first mode ofoperation may include the camera being activated repeatedly at regularintervals, random intervals, and/or upon triggering by the subsystem100-1. A mode of sensor operation may include sensor activation suchthat the sensor operates according to one or more specified rates, forexample, sampling rates. Hence, in the example of a camera 209, one modeof operation may correspond to a first sampling rate (e.g., number offrames per second, duration of video recording, number of still imagecaptures per minute, number of images in a burst of still imagecaptures, and/or the like).

However, in other embodiments, the first set of one or more sensors 209may be activated by default and/or may already be activated to capturesensor data at the endpoint device. For example, as disclosed herein,the captured sensor data may include input via an input interface of theendpoint device. Such data may be used by the subsystem 100-1 todetermine keystroke patterns, mouse movement patterns, interactionpatterns like common misspellings, interaction patterns with software,performance attributes (e.g., patterns of grades, writing style, wordchoice, typing speed, etc.), and/or the like.

As indicated by block 1906-6, sensor-based data that is based at leastin part on the first set of one or more sensors at the endpoint devicecapturing phenomena at the endpoint device may be received. Hence, suchdata may be based at least in part on the first set of one or moresensors operating according to a first mode of operation. Thesensor-based data may be processed by the subsystem 100-1 and used todevelop an endpoint specification. Such sensor-based data may beincluded in the sensor input 208A and/or endpoint input 106A gatheredand processed by the monitoring engine 521, as disclosed above withrespect to FIG. 15.

Referring to FIG. 20, as indicated by block 1906-7, a particularizedspecification of one or more recognized patterns mapped to theaccess-right indicator may be adaptively developed based at least inpart on processing the sensor-based data. For example, as disclosedabove with respect to FIG. 15, the matching engine 507 may adaptivelydevelop the particularized specification one or more recognized patternsmapped to the access-right indicator corresponding to a particularendpoint. The particularized specification of the one or more recognizedpatterns may include one or more recognized patterns of sensor input.The particularized specification may include a set of values of patterndata 716 that may be structured data corresponding to anticipated sensorinput corresponding to one or more of the types of sensors 209.

Referring again to FIG. 19, second-stage authentication may beinitiated, as indicated by block 1908. In some embodiments, thesecond-stage authentication may include ongoing operation of the firstset of one or more sensors 209 after a specified time period or limitimposed on the first-stage authentication, which may include after oneor more regular intervals, one or more random intervals, and/or upontriggering by the subsystem 100-1. The second-stage authentication may,in some embodiments, include causing activation of the first set of oneor more sensors 209 again at a later time subsequent to the activationof the first set along with the first-stage authentication. In varioussuch embodiments, the subsequent activation may be according to the samemode of operation as the first mode of operation or may be according toa different mode of operation. In other embodiments, the second-stageauthentication may include causing activation of a second set of one ormore sensors 209 that is partially or completely different from thefirst set of one or more sensors 209. In some embodiments, the secondset of one or more sensors 209 may include one or more different sensorsof one or more different types, different from the first set of one ormore sensors 209. With some embodiments, the second-stage authenticationmay include operations similar to those indicated by blocks 1906-5 and1906-6, but based at least in part on a different set of one or moresensors.

Per the second-stage authentication, additional sensor-based data may bereceived. In various embodiments, the additional sensor-based data maybe one or more of based at least in part on the first set of one or moresensors, based at least in part on the second set of one or more sensorsat the endpoint device, and/or based at least in part on input via aninput interface of the endpoint device. Again, such sensor-based datamay be included in the sensor input 208A and/or endpoint input 106Agathered and processed by the monitoring engine 521. The subsystem 101-1may derive one or more values corresponding to the subsequentsensor-based data and may compare the one or more derived values to oneor more stored values mapped to the access-right indicator. Forinstance, the subsystem 101-1 may process the subsequent sensor-baseddata to identify distinctive values for comparison to the set of valuesof pattern data 716 that may be structured data stored in theparticularized specification.

As indicated by block 1910, it may be determined whether anonconformance and/or inconsistency is detected. For example, thematching engine 507 of the subsystem 101-1 may compare the additionalsensor-based data to stored reference data. This may include determiningwhether a deviation of the additional data with respect to theparticularized specification of the one or more recognized patternsmapped to the access-right indicator is detected.

In the case that a nonconformance and/or inconsistency is not detected,the operational flow may proceed to block 1916. However, in the casethat a nonconformance and/or inconsistency is detected, the operationalflow may proceed to additional machine-intelligent authentication, asindicated by block 1911.

As indicated by block 1912, third-stage authentication may be initiated.In various embodiments, the third-stage authentication may includecausing activation of a second set of one or more sensors 209 that ispartially or completely different from the first set of one or moresensors 209. In various embodiments, the third-stage authentication mayinclude causing activation of a third set of one or more sensors 209that is partially or completely different from the first set of one ormore sensors 209 and/or the second set of one or more sensors 209. Invarious embodiments, the third set of one or more sensors 209 mayinclude one or more different sensors of one or more different types,different from the first set of one or more sensors 209 and/or thesecond set of one or more sensors 209. With some embodiments, thethird-stage authentication may include operations similar to thoseindicated by blocks 1906-5 and 1906-6, but based at least in part on adifferent set of one or more sensors. Hence, the third-stageauthentication may include, responsive to the detection of thenonconformance, selectively causing an activation adjustment inoperation of one or both of the first set of one or more sensors and thesecond set of one or more sensors, and collecting subsequentsensor-based data based at least in part on the activation adjustment ofone or both of the first set of one or more sensors and the second setof one or more sensors. The activation adjustment may be a function ofan authentication score that is based at least in part on the additionaldata.

Further, the sensor activation of the third-stage authentication maycorrespond to another particularized mode of operation, which may, invarious embodiments, be different from the first mode of operation. Forinstance, a second mode of operation may include the one or more sensorsbeing activated for different durations and/or according to one or morespecified rates (e.g., sampling rates). By way of example, the secondmode of operation may include throttling of the one or more sensors—say,camera 209—to operate for one or more specified times according to asecond sampling rate (e.g., number of frames per second, duration ofvideo and/or audio recording, number of repeated video recordings,number of still image captures per minute, number of images in a burstof still image captures, and/or the like) that is different from thefirst sampling rate. One difference in the operational modes may be afunction of time—e.g., sensor activation for longer periods of timeand/or at shorter intervals, which may correspond to one or more rollingwindows that may allow a period of time of sensor-captured phenomena tobe reviewed via an administratory device from before a triggering eventand after the triggering event. In addition or in alternative, anotherdifference in the operational modes may be a function of sensorconfiguration and/or resolution—e.g., throttling the sampling rate suchthat the subsequent sampling rate is greater than the previous samplingrate.

FIG. 21 illustrates certain aspects of additional machine-intelligentauthentication, in accordance with embodiments of the presentdisclosure. With reference to FIG. 21, as indicated by block 1911-1, theauthentication score based at least in part on the additionalsensor-based data may be evaluated with respect to the protocol for theendpoint device. A corresponding activation adjustment may be identifiedas a function of the authentication score. As indicated by block 1911-2,the activation adjustment in operation of the first set of one or moresensors and/or the second set of one or more sensors may be selectivelycaused, and subsequent sensor-based data based at least in part on theactivation adjustment may be collected. This may correspond to theoperations indicated by block 1912 of FIG. 19. As indicated by block1911-3, the subsequent sensor-based data may be processed, and theauthentication score may be updated based at least in part on thesubsequent sensor-based data.

As indicated by block 1911-4, it may be determined whether a scorethreshold is satisfied. For example, in one case, the updatedauthentication score may meet or exceed a positive threshold dispositiveof authentication. In case, the updated authentication score may meet orexceed a negative threshold dispositive of a lack of integrity,high-level suspicion, and/or fraud. In either case, the process flow maytransition to block 1916, or access of the endpoint device to resourcesmay be controlled in accordance with security policy. However, inanother case, the authentication score may not necessarily satisfy athreshold, but may be within a midrange that is not deemed dispositiveof authentication or fraud or the like. And such, the process flow maytransition to block 1911-5.

As indicated by block 1911-5, one or more additional activationadjustments may be identified as a function of the updatedauthentication score. As indicated by block 1911-6, the additionalsensor-based data gathered pursuant to the one or more additionalactivation adjustments may be processed, and the additional sensor-baseddata may be collected based at least in part on the one or moreadditional activation adjustments. As indicated by block 1911-7, theauthentication score may be updated based at least in part on theadditional sensor-based data. The process flow may loop back to block1911-4 for a subsequent determination of whether the updatedauthentication score satisfies a score threshold. These operations maycorrespond to the operations indicated by block 1914 of FIG. 19. Asindicated by block 1914, one or more additional stages of authenticationmay be implemented. As in the depicted example, in some embodiments, oneor more additional stages may be implemented as a function ofauthentication score. Say, in the case of the authentication score in amidrange that is not deemed dispositive of authentication or fraud,additional stages of authentication may be implemented with differentoperational modes and/or sensor types in an effort to gather moreauthentication data to develop a more definitive authentication score.However, in some embodiments, in the case of the third-stageauthentication sufficiently authenticating the endpoint, one or moreadditional stages may still be implemented as ongoing, periodic, orrandom checks to confirm authentication. In any case, the process flowmay transition to block 1916 directly from block 1912 (e.g., when theauthentication score sufficiently definitive to satisfy one or morethresholds) or indirectly from block 1912 by way of one or moreadditional stages of authentication.

The technical improvements provided by the subsystem 100-1 includeimprovements in accuracy, speed, timeliness, adaptability, sensitivity,and responsiveness in machine authentication based at least in part onadaptive authentication that performs appropriate multi-stage,multi-modal authentication in real-time using adaptive protocols. Insome embodiments, the protocol may be based at least in part aprecedence order of types of sensor-based authentication. The precedenceorder may be based at least in part on what types of sensors areavailable and adequately operational at a given endpoint device. Forexample, various sets of different types of sensors may be available inoperational at various endpoint devices. The subsystem may detectavailable and operational sensors at a given endpoint device and adjustthe protocol based at least in part on the availability. Moreover, thesubsystem may detect nonoperational or low-quality sensors and adjustthe protocol based at least in part on the practical unavailability ofsuch sensors.

Additionally or alternatively, the precedence order may be based atleast in part on reliability of various sensor-based authenticationmodes. As disclosed herein, certain authentication methods may be deemedmore reliable than others. For example, fingerprint and facialrecognition may be deemed more reliable than performance recognition.Thus, for example, the availability of a more reliable means ofauthentication may allow for the precedence order to weight the morereliable means more heavily. As a result, some embodiments may employmore reliable means of authentication in one or more early stages ofauthentication and/or when authentication scores are low (e.g., when anactivity determined to have a significantly high likelihood of fraud isdetected), which may trigger the more enhanced, more reliable means ofauthentication as a subsequent stage.

Additionally or alternatively, the protocol may take into accountprocessing and/or storage capacities when adjusting the precedence orderwith respect to various means of authentication. For example,video/image analysis may require more processing resources than analysisof performance. The subsystem may take into account limitations onprocessing capacity, particularly in situations involving high numbersof endpoints and thus high authentication demands, and adjust theprecedence order with respect to various means of authentication. Asanother example, audio analysis may less resource intensive than videoanalysis, which may be reflected by the precedence order. In suchembodiments, the less processing intensive means of authentication maybe used to a greater extent (e.g., an ongoing basis), and, when atrigger event (e.g., a significant deviation from a learned pattern) isdetected, the more resource intensive means of authentication may betriggered as a subsequent stage. In some embodiments, as more resourcesbecome available to the subsystem, the subsystem may employ one or moreof the more resource-intensive means of authentication in response totrigger events or without a trigger event (e.g., on an ongoing,periodic, or occasional basis).

Each means of authentication may be weighted differently according tothe foregoing factors. The subsystem may take the different weights intoaccount with the selection of additional means of authentication beingbased at least in part on the different weights of the various means ofauthentication. Additionally or alternatively, the selection ofadditional means of authentication may be based at least in part on theauthentication score derived based at least in part on one or moreprevious means of authentication. For example, if an initial means ofauthentication is weighted heavily according to various factors (e.g.,which may include reliability of authentication) and the currentauthentication score is relatively high to indicate a high level ofauthentication (i.e., a high likelihood of integrity), a subsequentmeans of authentication that is less reliable and that requires lessprocessing power may be selected.

In some embodiments, the operational modes of the means ofauthentication may likewise be functions of authentication scores. Forexample, shorter operational durations, longer intervals, and/or smallersamples may correspond to operational modes selected as a function ofhigh authentication scores. Conversely, longer operational durations,shorter intervals, and/or larger samples may correspond operationalmodes selected as a function of low authentication scores. Accordingly,more extensive operational modes may be selected by the subsystem inresponse to a triggering event. In various embodiments, such enhancedoperational modes may be caused prior to causing activation of adifferent type of sensor, in accordance with the precedence order and isa function of authentication score. In other embodiments, such enhancedoperational modes may be caused in conjunction with causing activationof a different type of sensor.

As indicated by block 1916, the access of the endpoint device toresources may then be controlled in accordance with one or more securitypolicies based at least in part on the absence of any nonconformanceand/or inconsistency. Performance of at least part of the set of one ormore access events may be selectively permitted based at least in parton the processing the subsequent sensor-based data and matching of theone or more derived values corresponding to the subsequent sensor-baseddata to the one or more stored values mapped to the access-rightindicator. However, performance of at least part of the set of one ormore access events may be selectively prohibited based at least in parton the processing the subsequent sensor-based data and detecting amismatch of the one or more derived values corresponding to thesubsequent sensor-based data to the one or more stored values mapped tothe access-right indicator. The subsequent sensor-based data may bestored in association with the one or more identifiers for the endpointdevice, and a communication may be transmitted to a second endpointdevice (e.g., that corresponds to an administratory endpoint) tofacilitate authenticated access to the subsequent sensor-based dataconsequent to authentication of the second endpoint device by the one ormore adaptive processing devices. For example, the communication maycorrespond to an email, a push notification, another type of message, acommand, and/or the like, and may include a link, hyperlink, and/oranother type of redirect command to access the sensor-based data. Invarious example instances, such access may include viewing one or morevideo recordings, listening to one or more audio recordings, viewingperformance metrics, viewing data from the particularized specification,and/or the like, corresponding to the one or more authentication stages.Hence, notifications may include any suitable data to allow for systemmanagement, such as status, image data, audio and/or video data,configuration data, pattern data, summary metrics regarding aparticularized specification, summary metrics regarding mismatches ofderived sets of values, past performance metrics, anticipated input andperformance metrics, and/or the like.

In some embodiments, the communication may correspond to an interruptand/or a command a command that may interrupt one or more currentprocesses on the second endpoint device and/or automatically launch,invoke, wake up, open, and/or otherwise activate a program, application,and/or subroutine on the second endpoint device to act as a notificationand force immediate execution of operations of the second endpointdevice to facilitate such access. Such a program, application, and/orsubroutine may be provided directly or indirectly by subsystem 100-1 forinstallation and execution by the second endpoint device to allow forthe notifications and responsive administratory input with one or moreuser-selectable options and input fields. In one example implementation,one or more modal windows may be generated that prevent furtherinteractions with the second endpoint device without first interactingwith the one or more modal windows and accessing the data correspondingto the one or more authentication stages.

Such access may request input to specify whether sensor-based data fromone or more sensors should be presented, not presented, or if futurenotifications related to such sensors should be ignored. Having come toan inference about a particular endpoint that the system derives via itsreasoning module, the system may cause one or more notifications to bedirected to the second endpoint device to allow for input to confirm,refine, and/or reject the subsystem's inference. If future notificationsare specified to be ignored, this may be for a predefined period oftime, such as a quarter of an hour, or until log off operationscorresponding to the first endpoint at the first endpoint device areexecuted. As another example, administratory input may include a commandto initiate additional stages of authentication, which may includeactivation of different types of sensors according to different modes ofoperation for further phenomena capture and evaluation thereof regardingthe particular endpoint.

As indicated by block 1918, the particularized specification of the oneor more recognized patterns mapped to the access-right indicator may beadaptively developed based at least in part on processing the additionalsensor-based data that is gathered and processed pursuant to theadditional stages of authentication. Thus, over time, the subsystem100-1 adapts to the particular endpoint using additional sensor-baseddata, gather at various times with various types of sensors and variousmodes of operation. Further, the particularized specification may beadaptively developed based at least in part on processing administratoryinput solicited with the notifications above that may confirm or denyauthentication. Accordingly, the endpoint specifications may beautomatically established and developed by the subsystem 100-1, alongwith system-solicited feedback.

FIG. 22 depicts certain aspects of a method 2200 to adaptively secure aset of access operations with respect to electronic resources, where thesubsystem 100-1 adapts method 1900 with respect to multiple endpointsubsystems, in accordance with embodiments of the present disclosure.The technical improvements provided by the subsystem 100-1 includeimprovements in accuracy, speed, timeliness, adaptability, sensitivity,and responsiveness in machine authentication based at least in part onadaptive authentication that identifies colocated states of endpointdevices and provides machine-intelligent authentication based at leastin part on the multiplicity of colocated endpoint devices requestingaccess to resources in close temporal proximity to enhanceauthentication measures for at least a subset of the colocated endpointdevices.

As indicated by block 1901, multiple subsystems within the system 100may be identified. Each subsystem of a plurality of subsystems mayinclude one or more endpoint devices 106. Each endpoint subsystem mayfurther include one or more sensors 209. One or more subsystems may becolocated, while one or more other subsystems may be remotely locatedfrom one another in distant geographic locations. Each sub-system of theplurality of sub-systems can be configured to perform one or moredifferent types and/or the same types of operations via access to andusage of different resources. Other embodiments may involve identifyingonly one subsystem of one or more endpoint devices 106. As indicated byblock 1902-1, the identification of multiple subsystems may includedetecting requests from multiple subsystems within a threshold oftemporal proximity. The threshold of temporal proximity may include atime window (e.g., 15 minutes, one hour, two hours, etc.) and/or a stateof multiple overlapping sessions were endpoint devices are logged intothe system.

As indicated by FIG. 22, for each identified subsystem of the one ormore subsystems, a number of operations to protect authenticationintegrity and to adaptively secure a set of access operations withrespect to one or more electronic resources may be performed. Again, asindicated by block 1902-1, one or more requests received via eachrespective endpoint device may be detected, which, in variousembodiments, may or may not be included in the previous operationsindicated by block 1901. As indicated by block 1904-1, multi-stage,adaptive authentication operations may be initiated with respect to eachrespective endpoint device. As indicated at block 1906-1, first-stageauthentication operations may be initiated with respect to each endpointdevice.

As indicated by block 1907, it may be determined whether two or more ofthe endpoint devices are colocated. In some embodiments, thedetermination of colocation may be based at least in part on a previousrequest received. For example, the requests may include locationidentifiers (e.g., facility identifiers, access point identifiers,network identifiers, administrator identifiers, and/or the like).Additionally or alternatively, the determination may include detectinglocation data corresponding to each endpoint device as disclosed herein,and comparing the detected location data to determine a correspondenceof locations of the endpoint devices within a certain proximitythreshold (e.g., correspondence of access point, mapping the locationdata to the same facility, mapping the location data to geographiclocations within a threshold distance, and/or the like). If none of theendpoint devices are determined to be colocated, the process flow maytransition to block 1908-1, where multistage, adaptive authenticationoperations may continue with respect to each non-colocated endpointdevice as previously disclosed herein. However, if two or more of theendpoint devices are determined to be colocated, the process flow maytransition to block 1908-2.

As indicated by block 1908-2, second-stage authentication operations maybe initiated for each colocated endpoint device. Such operations maycorrespond to previously disclosed authentication operations thatinclude collecting action data, temporal data, and/or contextual datafor correlation analyses with respect to the colocated endpoint devices.As indicated by block 1910-1, it may be determined whether anonconformance and/or inconsistency is detected. This may correspond tothe previous operations indicated with block 1910 with method 1900.

In the case that a nonconformance and/or inconsistency is detected, theoperational flow may proceed to additional machine-intelligentauthentication, as indicated by block 1913. Such additionalauthentication operations may correspond to the operations indicated byblock 1911 of previous figures. Again, as part of such operations, oneor more activation adjustments may be a function of authenticationscores. However, in the case of colocated endpoint devices accessingresources within temporal proximity, such activation adjustments mayapply to two or more of the colocated endpoint devices. For example, insome embodiments, when the updated authentication score satisfies acertain threshold as a result of being updated per the detectednonconformance and/or inconsistency, the activation adjustments mayapply to subset of the colocated endpoint devices within a certainlocation proximity threshold (e.g., a certain number of feet or otherdistance threshold) if such location resolution is available to thesubsystem based at least in part on the location determination methodsdisclosed herein and/or the sensor data available. However, in othercases, the activation adjustments may apply to all of the colocatedendpoint devices. In some embodiments, the same activation adjustmentmay apply to all of the colocated endpoint devices. In some embodiments,different activation adjustments may apply to the different colocatedendpoint devices. The determination of the types of activationadjustments apply severally to the different colocated endpoint devicesmay be based at least in part on the particularized protocols applied tothe respective endpoint devices as disclosed previously herein.

The sensor-based data for each endpoint device gathered with theadditional authentication operations may be analyzed and compared by thesubsystem to identify correlations. For example, if the initiallydetected nonconformance corresponded to multiple voices or a differentvoice being detected at one endpoint device, the additionalauthentication operations may include gathering voice data at otherendpoint devices to identify a match of additionally collected voicedata with the initially collected voice data. As another example, theadditional authentication operations may include gathering video data atother endpoint devices to identify instances where an endpoint may havemoved from one endpoint device to another endpoint device. As stillanother example, if the initially detected nonconformance correspondedto multiple endpoints or a different endpoint being detected at oneendpoint device, the additional authentication operations may includegathering video or other visual data at other endpoint devices toidentify a match of additionally collected data with the initiallycollected data.

Each of the colocated endpoint devices may be authenticated separately.Thus, in some cases, one or more of the colocated endpoint devices maybe sufficiently authenticated, while, in other cases, one or more of thecolocated endpoint devices may be sufficiently authenticated. Asindicated by block 1916-1, access of the colocated endpoint devices toresources may be controlled in accordance with security policy as afunction of the results of the additional authentication operations.And, as indicated by block 1918-1, the particularized specifications ofeach of the colocated endpoint devices may be adaptively developed basedat least in part on processing the additional sensor-based data that isgathered and processed pursuant to any of the stages of authentication.

If, at block 1910-1, a nonconformance and/or inconsistency is detected,the operational flow may proceed to block 1915. As indicated by block1915, it may be determined whether coincidental action attributes,temporal attributes, and/or contextual attributes are detected withrespect to two or more colocated endpoint devices. Such detection may bebased at least in part on the subsystem analyzing the action data,temporal data, and/or contextual data, as disclosed herein. For example,time on task, timing of transitions between tasks, and/or the like maybe analyzed to detect patterns of coincidental timing with respect tosuch temporal metrics. As another example, performance, includingendpoint input, may be analyzed to detect coinciding patterns. Thepatterns of coincidental timing and/or performance may be deemedquestionable or suspicious activity. In addition, similarities ofendpoint devices may be taken into account to detect correlation ofsimilar and/or identical types of resource access of multiple endpointdevices in close temporal proximity. The types of resource accessoperations could correspond to one another based on subject, sequence,classification, and would like. When such attributes are correlatedbetween two or more endpoints, authentication scores of the two or moreendpoints may be lowered, and the process flow may transition to block1913.

Again, as indicated by block 1913, additional intelligent authenticationmay be performed, and operations may flow from there as previouslydescribed. However, in some embodiments, the additional authenticationmay be performed only with respect to those colocated endpoint devicesidentified via the correlated attributes. Accordingly, the additionalauthentication may target only a subset of the colocated endpointdevices.

If, at block 1910-1, a nonconformance and/or inconsistency is notdetected, the operational flow may proceed to block 1916-2. As indicatedby block 1916-2, access of the colocated endpoint devices to resourcesmay be controlled in accordance with security policy. And, as indicatedby block 1918-2, the particularized specifications of each of thecolocated endpoint devices may be adaptively developed based at least inpart on processing any additional sensor-based data that is gathered andprocessed pursuant to any stages of authentication.

A number of variations and modifications of the disclosed embodimentscan also be used. Specific details are given in the above description toprovide a thorough understanding of the embodiments. However, it isunderstood that the embodiments may be practiced without these specificdetails. For example, well-known circuits, processes, algorithms,structures, and techniques may be shown without unnecessary detail inorder to avoid obscuring the embodiments.

Implementation of the techniques, blocks, steps and means describedabove may be done in various ways. For example, these techniques,blocks, steps and means may be implemented in hardware, software, or acombination thereof. For a hardware implementation, the processing unitsmay be implemented within one or more application specific integratedcircuits (ASICs), digital signal processors (DSPs), digital signalprocessing devices (DSPDs), programmable logic devices (PLDs), fieldprogrammable gate arrays (FPGAs), processors, controllers,micro-controllers, microprocessors, other electronic units designed toperform the functions described above, and/or a combination thereof.

Also, it is noted that the embodiments may be described as a processwhich is depicted as a flowchart, a flow diagram, a swim diagram, a dataflow diagram, a structure diagram, or a block diagram. Although adepiction may describe the operations as a sequential process, many ofthe operations can be performed in parallel or concurrently. Inaddition, the order of the operations may be re-arranged. A process isterminated when its operations are completed, but could have additionalsteps not included in the figure. A process may correspond to a method,a function, a procedure, a subroutine, a subprogram, etc. When a processcorresponds to a function, its termination corresponds to a return ofthe function to the calling function or the main function.

Furthermore, embodiments may be implemented by hardware, software,scripting languages, firmware, middleware, microcode, hardwaredescription languages, and/or any combination thereof. When implementedin software, firmware, middleware, scripting language, and/or microcode,the program code or code segments to perform the necessary operationsmay be stored in a machine readable medium such as a storage medium. Acode segment or machine-executable instruction may represent aprocedure, a function, a subprogram, a program, a routine, a subroutine,a module, a software package, a script, a class, or any combination ofinstructions, data structures, and/or program statements. A code segmentmay be coupled to another code segment or a hardware circuit by passingand/or receiving information, data, arguments, parameters, and/or memorycontents. Information, arguments, parameters, data, etc. may be passed,forwarded, or transmitted via any suitable means including memorysharing, message passing, token passing, network transmission, etc.

For a firmware and/or software implementation, the methodologies may beimplemented with modules (e.g., procedures, functions, and so on) thatperform the functions described herein. Any machine-readable mediumtangibly embodying instructions may be used in implementing themethodologies described herein. For example, software codes may bestored in a memory. Memory may be implemented within the processor orexternal to the processor. As used herein the term “memory” refers toany type of long term, short term, volatile, nonvolatile, or otherstorage medium and is not to be limited to any particular type of memoryor number of memories, or type of media upon which memory is stored.

Moreover, as disclosed herein, the terms “storage medium,”“machine-readable media,” “processor-readable media,” “computer-readablemedia,” and variations of such terms may represent one or more memoriesfor storing data, including read only memory (ROM), random access memory(RAM), magnetic RAM, core memory, magnetic disk storage mediums, opticalstorage mediums, flash memory devices and/or other machine readablemediums for storing information. The term “machine-readable medium”includes, but is not limited to portable or fixed storage devices,optical storage devices, and/or various other storage mediums capable ofstoring that contain or carry instruction(s) and/or data.

While the principles of the disclosure have been described above inconnection with specific apparatuses and methods, it is to be clearlyunderstood that this description is made only by way of example and notas limitation on the scope of the disclosure.

What is claimed:
 1. An adaptive authentication system to adaptivelysecure a set of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources, the adaptive authentication system comprising: one or moreadaptive processing devices; and one or more non-transitory,computer-readable storage media storing instructions which, whenexecuted by the one or more adaptive processing devices, cause the oneor more adaptive processing devices to perform actions including:detecting initiation of set of one or more access events initiated bythe endpoint device; causing adaptive authentication with respect to theendpoint device, the adaptive authentication comprising: initiating astage of authentication of the endpoint device, the stage ofauthentication comprising activation one or both of a first set of oneor more sensors at the endpoint device and a second set of one or moresensors at the endpoint device to capture phenomena at the endpointdevice, where: one or both of the first set of one or more sensors andthe second set of one or more sensors is communicatively connected tothe one or more adaptive processing devices; the first set of one ormore sensors correspond to a first sensor type; and the second set ofone or more sensors correspond to a second sensor type that is differentfrom the first sensor type; receiving sensor-based data that is based atleast in part on one or both the first set of one or more sensors and/orthe second set of one or more sensors first set of one or more sensorsactivated with the first stage of authentication; receiving additionalsensor-based data detected at the endpoint device and detecting adeviation of at least part of the additional data with respect to thesensor-based data previously received; generating an authenticationscore with respect to the endpoint device that is based at least in parton the additional sensor-based data and the sensor-based data previouslyreceived; initiating one or more additional stages of authentication ofthe endpoint device at least in part by transferring a command to causean activation adjustment that is a function of the authentication score,where the activation adjustment adjusts operation of one or more of thefirst set of one or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors,and/or a third set of one or more sensors; and consequent to the one ormore additional stages of authentication, receiving further sensor-baseddata detected at the endpoint device, and controlling access of theendpoint device to resources based at least in part on the furthersensor-based data.
 2. The adaptive authentication system to adaptivelysecure a set of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources as recited in claim 1, wherein the actions further include:selecting a mode of sensor operation for one or more of the first set ofone or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors, and/or athird set of one or more sensors, where the mode of sensor operation isa function of the authentication score; where the activation adjustmentcomprising causing one or more of the first set of one or more sensors,the second set of one or more sensors, and/or a third set of one or moresensors to operate in accordance with the mode of sensor operation. 3.The adaptive authentication system to adaptively secure a set of accessoperations with respect to one or more electronic resources as recitedin claim 2, wherein the actions further include: generating an updatedauthentication score with respect to the endpoint device that is basedat least in part on the further sensor-based data; selecting asubsequent mode of sensor operation for one or more of the first set ofone or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors, and/or thethird set of one or more sensors, where the subsequent mode of sensoroperation is a function of the updated authentication score and isdifferent from the mode of sensor operation; and transferring asubsequent command to cause a subsequent activation adjustment so thatone or more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second set ofone or more sensors, and/or a third set of one or more sensors tooperate in accordance with the second mode of sensor operation.
 4. Theadaptive authentication system to adaptively secure a set of accessoperations with respect to one or more electronic resources as recitedin claim 1, wherein the actions further include: selecting one or moreof the first set of one or more sensors, the second set of one or moresensors, and/or a third set of one or more sensors for operationaccording to the activation adjustment, where the selecting is based atleast in part on the authentication score.
 5. The adaptiveauthentication system as recited in claim 4, wherein the selecting oneor more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second set of oneor more sensors, and/or a third set of one or more sensors for operationaccording to the activation adjustment is further based at least in parton a precedence order.
 6. The adaptive authentication system toadaptively secure a set of access operations with respect to one or moreelectronic resources as recited in claim 1, wherein the actions furtherinclude: generating an updated authentication score with respect to theendpoint device that is based at least in part on the furthersensor-based data; wherein the controlling access of the endpoint deviceto resources is a function of the of the updated authentication score.7. The adaptive authentication system to adaptively secure a set ofaccess operations with respect to one or more electronic resources asrecited in claim 6, wherein the controlling access of the endpointdevice to resources as a function of the of the updated authenticationscore comprises selectively permitting or prohibiting performance of atleast part of the set of one or more access events.
 8. One or morenon-transitory, processor-readable media having processor-readableinstructions thereon which, when executed by one or more processingdevices, cause the one or more processing devices to facilitateadaptively securing a set of access operations with respect to one ormore electronic resources by performing actions including: detectinginitiation of set of one or more access events initiated by the endpointdevice; causing adaptive authentication with respect to the endpointdevice, the adaptive authentication comprising: initiating a stage ofauthentication of the endpoint device, the stage of authenticationcomprising activation one or both of a first set of one or more sensorsat the endpoint device and a second set of one or more sensors at theendpoint device to capture phenomena at the endpoint device, where: oneor both of the first set of one or more sensors and the second set ofone or more sensors is communicatively connected to the one or moreadaptive processing devices; the first set of one or more sensorscorrespond to a first sensor type; and the second set of one or moresensors correspond to a second sensor type that is different from thefirst sensor type; receiving sensor-based data that is based at least inpart on one or both the first set of one or more sensors and/or thesecond set of one or more sensors first set of one or more sensorsactivated with the first stage of authentication; receiving additionalsensor-based data detected at the endpoint device and detecting adeviation of at least part of the additional data with respect to thesensor-based data previously received; generating an authenticationscore with respect to the endpoint device that is based at least in parton the additional sensor-based data and the sensor-based data previouslyreceived; initiating one or more additional stages of authentication ofthe endpoint device at least in part by transferring a command to causean activation adjustment that is a function of the authentication score,where the activation adjustment adjusts operation of one or more of thefirst set of one or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors,and/or a third set of one or more sensors; and consequent to the one ormore additional stages of authentication, receiving further sensor-baseddata detected at the endpoint device, and controlling access of theendpoint device to resources based at least in part on the furthersensor-based data.
 9. The one or more non-transitory, processor-readablemedia as recited in claim 8, wherein the actions further include:selecting a mode of sensor operation for one or more of the first set ofone or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors, and/or athird set of one or more sensors, where the mode of sensor operation isa function of the authentication score; where the activation adjustmentcomprising causing one or more of the first set of one or more sensors,the second set of one or more sensors, and/or a third set of one or moresensors to operate in accordance with the mode of sensor operation. 10.The one or more non-transitory, processor-readable media as recited inclaim 9, wherein the actions further include: generating an updatedauthentication score with respect to the endpoint device that is basedat least in part on the further sensor-based data; selecting asubsequent mode of sensor operation for one or more of the first set ofone or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors, and/or thethird set of one or more sensors, where the subsequent mode of sensoroperation is a function of the updated authentication score and isdifferent from the mode of sensor operation; and transferring asubsequent command to cause a subsequent activation adjustment so thatone or more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second set ofone or more sensors, and/or a third set of one or more sensors tooperate in accordance with the second mode of sensor operation.
 11. Theone or more non-transitory, processor-readable media as recited in claim8, wherein the actions further include: selecting one or more of thefirst set of one or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors,and/or a third set of one or more sensors for operation according to theactivation adjustment, where the selecting is based at least in part onthe authentication score.
 12. The one or more non-transitory,processor-readable media as recited in claim 11, wherein the selectingone or more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second set ofone or more sensors, and/or a third set of one or more sensors foroperation according to the activation adjustment is further based atleast in part on a precedence order.
 13. The one or more non-transitory,processor-readable media as recited in claim 8, wherein the controllingaccess of the endpoint device to resources as a function of the of theupdated authentication score comprises selectively permitting orprohibiting performance of at least part of the set of one or moreaccess events.
 14. A method of adaptive authentication to adaptivelysecure a set of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources, the method comprising: detecting initiation of set of one ormore access events initiated by the endpoint device; causing adaptiveauthentication with respect to the endpoint device, the adaptiveauthentication comprising: initiating a stage of authentication of theendpoint device, the stage of authentication comprising activation oneor both of a first set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device anda second set of one or more sensors at the endpoint device to capturephenomena at the endpoint device, where: one or both of the first set ofone or more sensors and the second set of one or more sensors iscommunicatively connected to the one or more adaptive processingdevices; the first set of one or more sensors correspond to a firstsensor type; and the second set of one or more sensors correspond to asecond sensor type that is different from the first sensor type;receiving sensor-based data that is based at least in part on one orboth the first set of one or more sensors and/or the second set of oneor more sensors first set of one or more sensors activated with thefirst stage of authentication; receiving additional sensor-based datadetected at the endpoint device and detecting a deviation of at leastpart of the additional data with respect to the sensor-based datapreviously received; generating an authentication score with respect tothe endpoint device that is based at least in part on the additionalsensor-based data and the sensor-based data previously received;initiating one or more additional stages of authentication of theendpoint device at least in part by transferring a command to cause anactivation adjustment that is a function of the authentication score,where the activation adjustment adjusts operation of one or more of thefirst set of one or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors,and/or a third set of one or more sensors; and consequent to the one ormore additional stages of authentication, receiving further sensor-baseddata detected at the endpoint device, and controlling access of theendpoint device to resources based at least in part on the furthersensor-based data.
 15. The method of adaptive authentication toadaptively secure a set of access operations with respect to one or moreelectronic resources as recited in claim 14, the method furthercomprising: selecting a mode of sensor operation for one or more of thefirst set of one or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors,and/or a third set of one or more sensors, where the mode of sensoroperation is a function of the authentication score; where theactivation adjustment comprising causing one or more of the first set ofone or more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors, and/or athird set of one or more sensors to operate in accordance with the modeof sensor operation.
 16. The method of adaptive authentication toadaptively secure a set of access operations with respect to one or moreelectronic resources as recited in claim 15, the method furthercomprising: generating an updated authentication score with respect tothe endpoint device that is based at least in part on the furthersensor-based data; selecting a subsequent mode of sensor operation forone or more of the first set of one or more sensors, the second set ofone or more sensors, and/or the third set of one or more sensors, wherethe subsequent mode of sensor operation is a function of the updatedauthentication score and is different from the mode of sensor operation;and transferring a subsequent command to cause a subsequent activationadjustment so that one or more of the first set of one or more sensors,the second set of one or more sensors, and/or a third set of one or moresensors to operate in accordance with the second mode of sensoroperation.
 17. The method of adaptive authentication to adaptivelysecure a set of access operations with respect to one or more electronicresources as recited in claim 14, the method further comprising:selecting one or more of the first set of one or more sensors, thesecond set of one or more sensors, and/or a third set of one or moresensors for operation according to the activation adjustment, where theselecting is based at least in part on the authentication score.
 18. Themethod of adaptive authentication to adaptively secure a set of accessoperations with respect to one or more electronic resources as recitedin claim 17, wherein the selecting one or more of the first set of oneor more sensors, the second set of one or more sensors, and/or a thirdset of one or more sensors for operation according to the activationadjustment is further based at least in part on a precedence order. 19.The method of adaptive authentication to adaptively secure a set ofaccess operations with respect to one or more electronic resources asrecited in claim 14, wherein the controlling access of the endpointdevice to resources as a function of the of the updated authenticationscore comprises selectively permitting or prohibiting performance of atleast part of the set of one or more access events.
 20. The method ofadaptive authentication to adaptively secure a set of access operationswith respect to one or more electronic resources as recited in claim 19,wherein the controlling access of the endpoint device to resources as afunction of the of the updated authentication score comprisesselectively permitting or prohibiting performance of at least part ofthe set of one or more access events.